Article Index

The SPI story

In 1982, an awkward interlude interrupted development. Strategy & Tactics' publisher went bankrupt, and the rights passed to TSR. This may have been the worst investment in TSR's history, not because what it bought was worthless. Avalon Hill had been interested in SPI too, seeing potential in its brands and intellectual property. In the end, however, TSR acquired the company, which had few financially valuable assets besides its distinguished names. A few things might have helped offset the financial mistakes. One was a database produced by machine-processing reply postcards, which said far more than a conventional "marketing database". Responses collected from players could indicate what the market wanted, providing a basis for predicting an individual game's success or failure. The frequent absence of visible market research behind products remains a problem, even though reaching fans is considerably cheaper today.

There were also plenty of steady subscribers who bought enormous numbers of games. They were partly creditors too, having preordered numerous games, and many had previously bought "lifetime subscriptions" to Strategy & Tactics. TSR thought that, since it received none of that money and had acquired only assets, not obligations, it could simply announce that the preorders and lifetime subscriptions were lost. Players received neither money, magazines nor games. Ordinary annual subscriptions suffered the same fate as lifetime ones. On paper, TSR saved money, even though these players' claims did not amount to much, and retaining the customer base would surely have been worth far more over the long term and brought in much more revenue even in the first year. It was a bad decision.

The value of what it bought was thus lost. Money thrown away merely so "nobody else can have it" produces no return. It is true that SPI's lifetime subscriptions were problematic: without new entrants, only advertising revenue remained, and competitors were reluctant to advertise. But TSR could readily have attracted new subscribers and sold many of its own games to these customers. Before the purchase, it should have assessed what would happen to this community and how the company could operate after acquisition. Thorough consideration and assessment never happened, however, and TSR decided not to honour obligations to the players. 

The result was predictable: fans who were among the biggest customers in the roleplaying and wargame markets came to hate TSR. That cost far more than TSR gained from the arrangement. TSR could not recover its earlier claims—the money SPI owed it—either. It emerged owning a few venerable names but probably without any real profit. A true lose–lose situation; even from its own perspective, one of the worst solutions. Why mention big customers? Because a "lifetime subscription" is obviously a more expensive product. Anyone who could readily find the money for it could also have bought other costly products more easily, making these people an important market. By preordering, they were also early adopters who later recommended products within their circles and clubs. In their eyes, TSR became something of a "rotten company" here...

Naturally, SPI's developers had little reason to stay either. They went to Avalon Hill and published products competing with many TSR games. If many people were angry with TSR and heard about this, choosing a side and a new favourite product was easy. One more thing worth knowing about the Avalon Hill thread is that, in 1980, the "big three" RPGs were D&D from TSR, Traveller from Game Designers' Workshop, and RuneQuest. Traveller is a science-fiction game with successors still appearing today. This article is about D&D, and we will return to RuneQuest shortly. You will not have to wait long: the very next page continues with a RuneQuest-related story.