Management, rights and misguided behaviour
Given the company's earlier losses and conflicts, however, guessing where Dungeon's and the clubs' apparent success alone might have led is merely a "what if" exercise. As expected, the next scandal arrived at the publisher. Anyone who thought M.A.G.U.S. was alone in this, that only its system and world changed through such affairs, was badly mistaken. The SPI affair and the attempt to squeeze out a co-founder through Basic D&D were just as natural as the current search for scapegoats. Remember, though: Gygax was the one who stepped back to pursue film rights and let the company rush towards debt without paying attention. New ideas and product lines could have succeeded, and, as we see, a successful strategy could even have repaid the debt. That is good news in many respects.
But we can also say that everyone is wise after the event. At the time, many people did not know which way to turn or how to make this a successful company. That leads to conflicts whose appearance had been foreseeable for a while. It is no surprise to say TSR was not a particularly successful company either. Comparing Mr Gygax with so many other creators who encounter and create conflicts may not be far from reality. This pattern too is hardly unique. Large though these sums were, they could easily have become small change. But that required understanding a few changes.
By the mid-eighties, geeks were fascinated by much more than D&D and wargames. D&D-based games had existed earlier on mainframes and early consoles, and an independent development based on it later appeared under an unrelated brand. But the eighties were also about accessible computing. The Commodore 64 was present in so many geeks' homes that computers suddenly became mainstream. What did this mean? Partly that the average geek had less time and money for roleplaying. Partly that AD&D-based software could also be sold to them. Unfortunately, that still had to wait a little. Selling licences could, however, be an interesting source of revenue. There were directions in which to escape and places to cut costs. Few people recognised that there and then.
Yes, market research was precisely what we had to emphasise among the lost opportunities in the SPI story. Instead, many people saw the solution in scapegoating, hostility and personnel changes.
During the financial crisis, Gygax moved to remove Blumes, who then sold his stake to Williams—out of revenge, according to many. She was now not only an experienced manager who knew the company from within, but also a controlling owner. Remember what I said about the Trojan horse? A professional business manager knows exactly when growth will cover a temporary shortfall. Instead of the picture presented in the initial "investment offer"—debt, an uninteresting game, an investor wanted—she now knew from inside a company with substantial growth potential and had an opportunity to acquire it. Gygax tried to stop the sale, lost the legal battle and decided to leave, selling his own share in TSR. Another era began in TSR's and D&D/AD&D's history. Lorraine Williams, a businesswoman unfamiliar with the gaming world, became not a new investor in the company but its new owner, buying only existing shares. What would TSR achieve during the Williams era? What would become of D&D under an investor unfamiliar with both the game and the battles surrounding it?
This era is no longer such a distant past, and many of its stories may be familiar to many readers. It took place after Dragonlance appeared, and by then people could travel to Vienna, from where a few imported rulebooks reached Hungary and pirate translations began appearing. Alongside international expansion now reaching behind the Iron Curtain, there were many other positives in this period, initially still dominated by the spread of roleplaying. Those who discovered roleplaying very early in Hungary may have known this era. The beginning of the Williams era will therefore include Hungarian connections too. I reveal no great secret by saying that much of it was successful for TSR, though later it also brought the company's fall and loss of independence, thanks to roleplaying's retreat, the spread of card games and plummeting quality. The next page is worth reading for these developments and many other events shaping D&D and AD&D, including TSR's "bankruptcy" and absorption by Wizards.