Appendix: Interesting Details about the Relationship with Avalon Hill
How Avalon Hill ended up at Hasbro is an interesting question. How did the modern successor to Victory Games, Avalon Hill's development team formed by people fleeing TSR amid the scandal over SPI's absorption, end up at precisely the company where TSR's successor landed? How did a team making advanced strategy games and some roleplaying games become another Hasbro division? Oddly, Gettysburg comes to mind. Yes, I discussed that board game, but hearing the name probably also brings Sid Meier to many people's minds. Well, he too had something to do with Avalon Hill's fall and absorption into Hasbro.
Besides Gettysburg, Avalon Hill also had the Civilization board game, which invented the "tech tree", for example. Sid Meier initially claimed SimCity inspired him and that he did not even know this game. Several colleagues, however, said its related Advanced Civilization had been around the office. And citing SimCity as inspiration would hardly explain inventing the tech tree. Meier later admitted in an interview that he had played it. This did not save Avalon Hill's PC version of Advanced Civilization from losing to Sid Meier's Civilization II in the market. Meier, who stole the name and numerous mechanics and obstructed Avalon Hill, became comfortably wealthy from it... And he likes to denounce the nasty, evil pirates who steal other people's intellectual work by getting his games from torrent sites. This would not yet be particularly interesting, even if we remember a Gettysburg adaptation from Meier too, but there is another interesting detail.
This failure of Avalon Hill's Advanced Civilization PC game immediately preceded Hasbro's acquisition of Avalon Hill. By "stealing one of their last chances", Meier contributed substantially to Avalon Hill ending up exactly where TSR and Wizards did: inside Hasbro. Strangely, Hasbro also bought MicroProse from Spectrum HoloByte, and Meier himself left the company at that time. But the story would still not be particularly interesting. Another of Meier's successful games, Railroad Tycoon, bears an uncanny resemblance in numerous elements to the 18XX board games. Avalon Hill published those too, starting with the second game, 1830, and long planned PC adaptations, though only one appeared thanks to the Railroad Tycoon series. Meier, cleverly producing adaptations while talking around the subject, deprived them of this too.
Many of these games were praised for their "originality", despite their numerous flaws. Besides the discovery that they were not original at all, I mean. The square grid resulted from a simple engine that could be written quickly and cheaply, although hex-grid games already existed. Those openly cited wargames as inspiration, of course, without their developers trying to take credit for someone else's work. In any case, the flaws of square-grid maps accompanied Civilization for a long time. By the fifth instalment, Firaxis had finally reached the point of being able to use hexes, as Avalon Hill had much earlier.
Anyone who finds this combination of unscrupulous adaptation and antipiracy action strange is forgetting that Hungary offers plenty of examples too. Among rights defenders fighting for musicians are numerous people who became wealthy and famous, and worked for the state record company, through people transcribing songs from "Luxi", Radio Luxembourg, or Radio Free Europe broadcasts and adapting them without permission. Yes: they too appropriated and used other people's intellectual work without permission, except that they made money from it as well.
There is more; shall I go on? It is not difficult to discover what the White Wolf team played, where its ideas came from, or how so many errors entered the system as it was changed to "make it different". When the idea of a crossover with another world or game arose, White Wolf quickly decided it was better not to name the game that had inspired it, but a competitor instead. Today it may be the publisher taking the toughest action against piracy, sometimes trying to outdo even Hasbro's actions, which led to the closure of the printed Dragon, for example. And naturally, they are proud that their game is not a D&D clone, and is real roleplaying.
Everyone loves such original, honest children, don't they? And everyone is ready to respect their legal rights to the fullest?
To be fair, invoking pirates obviously has little to do with conviction. If something is not truly successful commercially and partners, investors and so on are unhappy, blaming pirates is easy. Sid Meier's Railroads was not commercially unsuccessful compared with other games because it was crap, but because people stole this one too. Right? Right? Successful games presumably are not stolen. Of course, a good game does have a lower proportion of pirate copies, simply because many evil pirates actually buy a good game after trying it. Disgusting.
And everyone still remembers the Pathfinder story. That was all about nasty pirates too, wasn't it?
I do believe, however, that the Avalon Hill story is interesting for other reasons too.