Article Index

The PDF Story

Yes, Ryan Dancey's name comes up again. Third-edition fans often like the OGL too, but it also meant untested, frequently incompatible supplements could appear. Powergaming was unrestricted. Many people have explained why the OGL was unsustainable, even if it offered Hasbro many short-term advantages. The best example is how quickly Pathfinder RPG emerged as a competitor to the fourth edition: anyone unhappy with the change received a new system. Of course, there were many other problems with the OGL, but hearing the word "open", many praise it regardless of anything else. Let us simply start with an interpretation based on American clubs' priorities.

One important aim of the third edition was to serve this market with a game anyone could quickly play or run after dropping into a club. Players' characters would suit the adventure, and nobody would need special preparation for each occasion. But allowing many people to develop mutually incompatible supplements, then having many people use them, backfired. Other games borrowed a great deal from D&D's rules, which did not really fit their own worlds. Moreover, in many respects—which rule could be reused where—the OGL was as problematic as the American patent system. Its restrictions kept many good rules out of other games where they would have made sense. With your own system it is easy to create a similar rule; here the options were a missing rule, a cross-reference to another game or complete incompatibility.

What bothered Wizards, however, was that OGL continuations of its third edition were competing with the fourth, and their PDFs often appeared in the same shops as PDF versions of its own books. Somehow the situation had to be resolved. Many contracts needed extraordinary termination, and ties with many companies had to be cut, including the former publisher of Dragon and Dungeon, since it published Pathfinder. This required finding fault with all PDF sales. The fault was found: insufficient protection. Pirate versions appeared too quickly. Perhaps that was true. Finding the new protection, the watermark, waiting until a PDF had enough buyers that an early customer could not be identified from a few purchases, and similar delays took only a few days longer than a 300 DPI scan plus OCR. Many PDFs were only slightly better protected than necessary. Stronger protection would merely have brought back scanning and home OCR. Scans of the fourth edition are hardly difficult to find either.

But now the recommendation "customers who buy Wizards products often buy Pathfinder" no longer appeared beside its PDFs, and the PDF offering no longer strengthened a competitor continuing 3.5E. Incidentally, the rules database on its own D&D Insider platform also gained value as the only official electronically readable rules collection. Hasbro seemingly gained on many fronts, but the move was anything but friendly. In the long run, then, Hasbro lost out through the OGL story, and the former vice-president who had set this process in motion—yes, Ryan Dancey—spoke of a death spiral. It is also a fact that this process spelled the end of printed D&D magazines. Another scandal certainly did nothing for Wizards' reputation.

Meanwhile, neither the earlier PDFs, with their colourful designs, nor the new electronic format read well on an e-reader. You could not say your D&D collection was with you and available for comfortable reading at any time. Comfortable reading of electronic documents soon became an important consideration. In many respects, players could once again feel neglected. This surely had a measurable negative impact on D&D's fan base, and if we see the negative effect we would expect from that, we should not seek scapegoats elsewhere.