Article Index

Sandbox, Safety Rails and the Game Master's Work

For D&D, however, this entire direction concerns the problem known as "sandbox vs safety rails". A player who is free, during play or character creation, can easily upset the game master's plans. If a character has personal goals, there is no guarantee they will follow the adventure's direction. The aim is for the characters to form an effective party at any time and make it through the adventure, avoiding trouble at the club. The system's task is precisely not to support unlimited imagination or handle living, feeling, thinking characters with histories and backgrounds. It is to erect the necessary safety rails so unlimited imagination cannot upset the DM's plans. Game balance, which players so often interpret as balance between characters, actually means "balance between parties". If you have an adventure written for level ten, it should generally work well for a tenth-level party. It is that simple. Decisions do not fit easily into this.

Remember: BioWare's games, and generally most story-centred games in which decisions have important later consequences and we can shape our character's personality, behaviour and choices more freely, are strictly single-player. D&D, however, began as a shared game for people sometimes unknown to one another, where it could hardly be obvious at the table which character's interests should prevail. The design decisions stem from this target audience's needs, and D&D's history explains why precisely this audience stood at the centre of development. Many people wanting something different ended up among other games' fans, making it difficult to head in another direction even when building on the available fan base.

In this respect, the fourth edition recognises a predicament from which the fifth edition has since tried to break free, mostly unsuccessfully in my view. I would venture that "sandbox vs safety rails" is, in many respects, tabletop roleplaying's greatest problem. If players can act freely, they can easily surprise the game master, and the game as originally conceived no longer works. If they cannot act freely, however, the game offers little more freedom than a computer roleplaying game. Indeed, the latter does not even require you to "make decisions that keep the party from falling apart"; there is less accommodation of others.

If we count freedom among tabletop roleplaying's virtues, neither dungeon crawling nor safety rails fits, and the game master must primarily portray the world. Many people cannot do that and do not want to be able to. More than one player and game master was surprised when I advised players to discuss their party concept and plans even if that meant contradicting the GM. Freedom disappears from the game's virtues if the party can only go where the GM planned before even knowing the characters. But if the party can go anywhere, the GM must prepare to portray the whole environment, and every group member puts work into the shared game, then the GM's word is only one vote too. And remember: if it remains unacceptable to play out characters' personalities or various emerging concepts because they would take things off the GM's planned storyline, roleplaying itself would be what was missing. We therefore have to reject the inviolability of the planned story and the GM's privileged position in such a situation.

I reread numerous reviews of the fourth edition, and in so many I felt the author struggled to explain what they disliked. Something was missing, something was not as expected, something was not quite D&D. But they could not or would not say what. There was no longer that cleaner, drier, even more overpowered feeling. The fourth edition is less over the top than the third, and players fond of the latter's many outrageous builds miss the familiar sensation. Otherwise, judged by the aim of simplification, the fourth edition really does look like progress in every respect. But in sandbox versus safety rails, balance and the adventure's security mattered; freedom and roleplaying did not.  Of course, the situation is nowhere near this ideal.