We followed the birth of D&D's fifth edition closely. Doubts about the system arose from the very beginning. Those best able to fix a problem are those capable of recognising it. Yet many core members of the development team were thinking too exclusively in terms of dungeon crawling. At the same time, we had reached the point where players who liked that direction formed an overwhelming majority of D&D players. The others had found numerous other games. It is true that with fewer munchkin builds, D&D 4 could even be a little more conducive to roleplaying than previous editions, but it still was not quite right. Precisely calibrated tactical challenges leave little room for players to portray their characters' flaws or inexperience. Efficiency is supposed to be the aim.
Here too, character creation is largely about competitive builds; a character a little weaker because of its concept... It immediately became clear that in the fifth edition too, perceived or actual balance mattered more than a game that accurately represented the world, or freedom, or diversity in many respects. So I have serious doubts. It is easy to notice a fundamental feature of racial modifiers: every race is weaker than humans, even in its own area of strength. That is hardly good news for fidelity to the world.
A much greater problem is that the people D&D wants to win back are already playing other games. Why would they start playing D&D again if its main message is that the fifth edition is a compromise intended to suit everyone? Those lost players have already found games that are not compromises. The munchkin will not return, because powergaming cannot go as far as in Pathfinder, for example. Another group prefers play faithful to the world. For them, supposedly exceptionally agile creatures having worse Dexterity than humans will send them towards another familiar system. Those who decided computer games were perfectly good for dungeon crawling and did not want to learn lots of things again see hefty books.
It is easy to imagine people in these groups refusing to switch back to D&D. Its fifth edition will therefore fail to win many people back. When D&D lost many players, serious faults and shortcomings were needed to make them switch. The game they switched to had to be substantially better than the D&D they knew. Switching games means all that previously invested work and money... For them to switch from their current favourite to D&D's fifth edition, a similarly substantial difference would have to emerge in D&D's favour. And however much we say that adventures playable anywhere and the succession of Organized Play events are valuable, these are really tools for retaining existing players rather than reaching new ones or winning back those previously lost.
Think of a player who turned towards MMORPGs because they promised play at any time. Numerous opportunities available at fixed times are a step backwards for them. Even raid schedules may be less restrictive. D&D offers no more in terms of achievement, freedom or roleplaying in this situation. Why switch back? All right: if D&D Organized Play suits someone and lets them play a lot, they will be less likely to switch to computer games. Had this direction appeared in 1995, it would have effectively slowed the advance of card games and computer games. But it remains very late compared with that, and even if current Organized Play is better than the earlier Encounters approach, unfortunately it still does not quite deliver in terms of story either.
The last few D&D editions have been accompanied by the claim that five hours of walking take five minutes, while five minutes of combat take five hours. Combat consequently feels anything but lively, making it far from ideal for a combat-oriented game. Meanwhile, it deliberately distances itself from more roleplaying-oriented play. D&D is in a difficult position precisely because it has traditionally always been this kind of game. We can talk about now having rules "to simulate a two-minute battle over two days", just as we can dispose of an army's two-day march in two minutes, but that has no real value.