New Competitors
By this time TSR already had numerous competitors to contend with. Many larger, better-known roleplaying games were on the market, taking sizeable slices of the pie. Without attempting a complete list, we can mention Vampire, Shadowrun, Call of Cthulhu and Cyberpunk; GURPS, very successful in America, is another interesting example. Oddly, however, I would single out Call of Cthulhu and James Bond 007, already part of history by then. Neither for its quality nor its market strength, but rather with reference to the scandal following SPI's absorption and its longer-term consequences. James Bond 007 showed that a later competitor could readily beat TSR. And yes, Avalon Hill was behind it. Chaosium, meanwhile, had sold RuneQuest to Avalon Hill. Amid the scandal, many people encountered it as one of the three major games of the time. This publicity came "free" to both Avalon Hill and Chaosium. It did not cost either a penny. The mass of people discovering BRP, and the system's at least relative success, also showed that one system—and the BRP brand appearing in many places—could sustain several games. In both cases, roleplaying in modern settings gained real public recognition too.
Many people found it easier to inhabit an easily imagined character in a familiar world, making roleplaying a little more about immersion, stories and so forth, and less about combat. Many publishers could respond to these market changes. This fine new direction characterised games based on Storyteller, such as Vampire, just as much as Cyberpunk and Shadowrun, set on the Earth of the near future. The triumph of immersion reshaped the market somewhat. Precisely for this reason, system flaws that broke immersion became a sensitive issue, and this process also contributed to TSR's declining sales. BRP's success made GURPS's success predictable too.
By a strange twist of fate, Avalon Hill also found itself in serious trouble at this time. Its story was less straightforwardly a case of self-inflicted damage. Of course, Avalon Hill was responsible for losing ground to Games Workshop, but it had numerous good ideas for computer adaptations of its games. In this area, however, it was helpless against a thief, for example. I will say more about that on the final page, an appendix to this article. It is an interesting little piracy story. But I will let you in on something: Avalon Hill still has a part to play in D&D. Perhaps quite a significant one.
Back to TSR. Wizards of the Coast bought the company, and many people would immediately mention the third edition, but much water flowed under the bridge before that. Among other things, Hasbro acquired Wizards of the Coast before the third edition's 2000 release. D&D 3 therefore appeared as a Hasbro game, backed by a multinational and its own ways of doing things. That belongs on a separate page. Wizards pursued an interesting policy. It liked fan-created material, so it quickly entrusted settings that seemed too risky, had reputations battered by mass production and generated less revenue—Dark Sun, Spelljammer and Planescape—to the fans. This is one way to discontinue risky product lines. It is good because fans do not face their world's complete closure or abolition, and gain a substantial say in developing it. If it grows stronger, the project can easily be revived.
It is bad because it clearly signalled that none of the AD&D worlds was Wizards' own child. It would not nurture them; it would focus on strong product lines bringing reliable profits, using them to supplement its own range. The brands attached to the worlds offered excellent opportunities to sell novels or earn money by licensing computer adaptations. Yes, Planescape: Torment may have brought in a tidy sum too. In the competition between successful projects hungry for funding, they also had to compete with games such as Pokémon, released in 1999. By then, however, Wizards was no longer an independent company.
One success story does belong to the Wizards era, right at its end... Baldur's Gate appeared in 1998, along with its Tales of the Sword Coast expansion. For many people, the collaboration between BioWare and Black Isle is an important milestone, perhaps a significant advance over earlier AD&D- and D&D-based roleplaying games. In many respects that is surely true. It certainly reached a wider audience, introducing many people to Forgotten Realms. Discovering the world plays an important role in the game, assisted by numerous books you can find, giving the computer game depth. In many places the story and our decisions matter more than monsters defeated in dungeons, which is no bad thing.
Baldur's Gate also marked the start of a successful, longer-term collaboration that would lead to Neverwinter Nights, another important milestone in D&D and AD&D history. Computer roleplaying games grew stronger in many respects as a result. But 1998 brought another change in D&D's history. While everyone was watching or waiting for Baldur's Gate, Hasbro acquired Wizards of the Coast in the summer of 1998 after four years of trying and waiting. It will be interesting to examine the AD&D and D&D supplements released at the beginning of the Hasbro era. And yes, I will now try to discuss the third edition, its values and aims too. For players who discovered D&D through the third edition, this period holds many interesting details, and it also shows why comparing D&D's fourth edition to World of Warcraft is unfair.
The next period is truly defined by Hasbro and the d20 System; you can read more after the break. And if your perseverance lasts beyond the next page, the recent past is coming soon, followed by many other interesting and important details.