Article Index

Major System Changes in a Nutshell

As we have seen, D&D's and AD&D's creators regard roleplaying not as unlimited imagination, immersion, characters' decisions and lives, but as a series of simple challenges. Every encounter, puzzle and skill challenge is one of these. They form adventures, which form campaigns. A play style based on immersion was mentioned occasionally, but most editions paid it little attention. We learned that a world offering novel-like stories, with many creators, was more a literary background than a setting for play. The most important feature of gaming worlds was that incompatible things could be mixed freely. Does that destroy immersion and believable characters? Who cares? Damage, kills, XP, treasure... We have the more prominent watchwords. Bad luck. The system, however, did change.

Where a wargame player commands armies, here they have a particular role within a party. The party's and characters' affiliations were determined by alignment, referred to in Hungarian as "jellem"... But the English word for jellem is character. Various abilities and skills determining the character's capabilities, behaviour and so on were attached to this: everything on the character sheet. Including a "character class", specifying "what sort of figure we control on the battlefield". When individual heroes engage in cooperative play over a campaign, that is important information.

Initially, this character class included the character's race. With little scope for independent skills, it specified quite precisely what sort of figure someone brought into the game. It was simple. With only three "alignments", designing a party of different figures sharing one alignment was easy. It was just a little strange that "all elves were alike". Well, not quite. An elven woman deserved a different beautifully painted miniature from her husband. Besides, she had a level, alignment and nicely rolled abilities too. And the player invented the physical description, ideally applying those ideas when painting the appropriate miniature.

AD&D separated class and race, a welcome development. We were told which classes were compatible with each race. Echoing the earlier mixed abilities, nonhuman races typically had multiclassing, while humans could change classes. To balance multiclassing and racial abilities, maximum attainable levels differed between races. Naturally, this caused considerable argument: it was no disadvantage in a low-level party, everyone brought a different character for high-level play, and it was alien to the world besides. But it was the simple solution replacing earlier racial classes with mixed abilities. That was one thing. Characters now chose from nine alignments defined along two axes rather than three, a new combat system no longer resembled Chainmail, and the game expanded in countless areas.

The second edition brought enormous change. At least humans could now advance to level twenty regardless of class, initially at any rate; supplements mentioning higher levels appeared later. Quite a few classes disappeared, along with the half-orc race. Demons and devils were renamed, and more people used the optional skill system. The illusionist became a specialist wizard, with many other specialists appearing. The range of specialist wizards and priests continued to grow. Four broad class groups emerged: warriors, rogues, priests and, finally, magic-users. Mages found magic resistance harder to overcome, currency exchange ratios changed, and numerous other small changes appeared. THAC0 replaced the assortment of combat-value tables; segments disappeared, replaced by initiative modifiers. Weapon speeds, surprise and a few other details changed. Oh, and priestly spheres appeared, depending on the priest's deity and class.

The Player's Option series introduced numerous innovations, perhaps more than an average edition. Classes and races could be customised with character points, though the ability lists were class- and race-specific. Customisation required the DM's consent, of course... Nor was the idea to discard mandatory basic training for a few overpowered abilities. There were advantages, disadvantages, multiple specialisations, critical injuries and a more complex combat system. It explained roughly how rare higher-level characters were—there was a rule, but the calculations were wrong. In short, there was a reason so many mockingly called it edition 2.5. It was not halfway towards the third edition, however.

With the third edition, malicious tongues said that alongside multiclassing came multi-mothering and multi-raciality, thanks to combinable "half-race" templates... Multiclassing became universal too: twenty or even more classes could be combined freely. The mixed training previously characteristic of races disappeared, as did level limits. Advancement was initially permitted to level twenty, but later became unlimited. New combat system, feats, mandatory skills, more important skills, new saving throws. Spell resistance replaced magic resistance on an entirely different basis. Virtually everything changed. Most specialist priests disappeared, as did class groups. Like its first-edition counterpart, the monk lacked priestly magic; in the second edition it had been a specialist priest. Domains replaced spheres... The list could continue, but almost everything changed. And one exceptionally important innovation arrived: unlike before, placing monsters was no longer primarily about the world, but about appropriate difficulty for the party's level.

The aim was to provide an appropriate challenge; from then on, in most encounters "how can this be solved?" became more important than "which solution does my character choose?", and the world's role diminished. In return, the DM faced far fewer surprises and could run prewritten adventures much more easily. This created a new situation. Establishing streamlining as an important direction also deserves mention: everything unnecessary to the intended vision could be weeded out, so the game would offer less and less rather than more and more. As eventually almost every monster became playable, with numerous prestige classes too, powergaming possibilities were unlimited. On the other hand, it was very easy to feed the market with "new, even more overpowered" supplements. Edition 3.5 merely added minor fixes.

The fourth edition completely reworked the system again. Multiclassing was entirely redesigned: nobody had several true classes. Separate races replaced most subraces. Skill points disappeared, leaving trained and untrained skills with different checks. Character advancement was new in many respects. Defences replaced the earlier saving throws, though a new kind of saving throw could end certain effects. Many noncombat spells became rituals independent of class. Recovery, healing and much of the combat system were reworked... The list could go on for pages. Once again, a wholly incompatible system appeared, different in many respects. Streamlining remained, however, reflected in the Points of Light concept and the simplification of alignment to five choices.

Is Essentials edition 4.5? Did it change things or supplement them? Perhaps it is a separate product line? Good questions; in any case, the differences here are small. Recently, at least, "half editions" have mostly meant minor fixes, while whole editions mean new systems. Gradual development of the system has disappeared as an approach.

The fifth edition would be a middle way in many respects. We can discuss every rule, the new, looser combat system and many other details, but it still is not perfect. There could be an advanced version alongside it for a "different concept", or many other directions to take. But when reforming D&D this way, it is difficult for developers to change enough without changing too much in many places.