Article Index

The Beginning of the End

I have often said that rapid growth, a golden age, cannot really last forever. A combination of factors brought this golden age to an end. Many people include mass production among the causes, but part of the real explanation lies further afield. As TSR increasingly focused on roleplaying, while also selling mostly complete games in the wargaming market, it had to face a fact: the revenue available from this was finite, and it lacked products people would buy for themselves "just because". Someone who felt they "deserved something for all that hard work" might easily buy a Warhammer miniature instead of a cake or an ice cream. Buying an AD&D rulebook or boxed set that way was unlikely. It was too expensive for that sort of emotional decision, and choosing required too much thought. Roleplaying was not such a profitable business after all. And despite Battlesystem, players hardly bought miniatures. Somehow a paper token was enough.

There was a reason: one miniature could perfectly well represent a dozen soldiers, but finding one that truly suited a character might take years. And if you had no miniature for your own character, why have them for "nameless" armies? The inexpensive little impulse purchases—a miniature, a pot of paint and similar accessories familiar from wargames—were simply missing from the AD&D market. Yet together they would have brought in considerable money, as well as a fairly steady base income: even if a major publication failed to sell well, people would still buy these things. The collectible AD&D cards, also available as a complete set, were not remotely appealing. In other words, TSR's product range was wrong. And things would soon get much worse.

Although Warhammer and its publisher Games Workshop were the strongest "wargame" publisher, many others also benefited from the genre's renaissance. Even if, as we know, Avalon Hill could enjoy it only in the short term.

Soon it was not just Games Workshop that became stronger commercially, but Wizards of the Coast too, thanks to the success of Magic: The Gathering. All you need to know about the new game is that its entire first year's planned stock sold out within days, shattering every expectation for revenue and profit. The year 1993 clearly belonged to Wizards of the Coast, and the company won numerous awards in 1994 too. The card-game craze was raging, dealing a severe blow to TSR's position. As TSR lost its market leadership, the vulnerable dwarf gradually became a giant. TSR was still far from worthless and remained the market leader in many areas, but management decided to fight the rising titans. It would be no easy struggle: with D&D and AD&D, TSR had become accustomed to fighting from a market-leading position, with the law as a powerful weapon. That no longer worked. TSR had also traditionally handled its community badly, and this now backfired spectacularly.

The first substantial response arrived in 1994 in the form of the Spellfire card game, but it did not deliver a real breakthrough. AD&D acquired an even newer, freer, more open setting: Planescape. Then came Blood Wars, a card game based on it, in 1995. The game was interesting and would have been an excellent advertisement for Planescape. The pictures were beautiful and would have made wonderful illustrations for AD&D adventures too. There was just one snag. While Wizards of the Coast welcomed fair use of its pictures on fan sites, TSR attacked anything and anyone who wanted to use its images. This quickly wrecked the game's popularity. Incidentally, it also ensured that AD&D players did not do much collecting either.

Even worse was the mass production that had become necessary. The beautiful, new, successful world that genuinely offered something different, and the still-successful Forgotten Realms, seemingly could accommodate anything. But releases arrived that undermined the worlds' coherence. Some were commercially successful and occasionally even created new legends, yet they still contributed to TSR's problems. Things deteriorated year after year, despite the potential in many publications and the plans to renew AD&D itself. A great many things simply did not turn out well.