The Fourth Edition
Since in 2011 I associated the recent past with the fourth edition's arrival, I should begin there immediately. The fourth edition appeared in 2007. If the marketing department regarded balance-breaking munchkin builds as the problem, it is unsurprising that they tried to address them: unlimited powergaming and the overpowered builds that annoyed so many people disappeared. For many players, however, the sense of achievement then stopped arriving so reliably. Poor things. In return, character creation became simpler, with fewer combinations to consider. That is good: it saves time and curbs "the practice of accumulating parents by taking lots of half-races", potentially making the game feel lifelike. Were it not for one tiny snag. Let me begin with a legendary quotation: "D&D is still about going into dungeons, killing monsters, and taking their treasure." D&D is about going down into dungeons, killing monsters and taking their treasure. The quotation is attributed to one of the fourth edition's authors. In fact, the statement originally came during third-edition playtesting, about that edition, from Ryan Dancey, one of the leaders of the team entrusted with designing it. He had already been Wizards' vice-president responsible for tabletop roleplaying before Hasbro's acquisition. Specifically, it arose in a discussion about the Charisma ability being undervalued. So this was not a goal the creative team first set itself for the fourth edition.
Indeed, an article in Dungeon Online during the fourth-edition era approaches the problem interestingly. It says many D&D players welcome the simplicity of everyone in the dungeon being evil and allies being in town, but that DMs should still occasionally introduce a moral dilemma and let characters think, decide and so on. The application of the Points of Light concept is therefore an observed practice rather than an aim, characteristic of adventures at clubs and events, to which perceived or actual customer demand is accommodated. Consider what this means. For example, among many people nostalgic for the first edition's classic dungeon crawls, points of light were already common, exploring moral questions was rare, Charisma was undervalued, and almost every encounter was reduced to combat, despite encounter reactions still existing in the second edition. Their wargaming roots also made miniatures familiar.
We are the odd ones here in Central Europe. Thanks to formerly closed borders, we first encountered the novels, then saw roleplaying as a game connected with them. In imaginary games of "what if...", "what would we have done differently in the hero's place if..." and similar questions, characters' personalities and ways of thinking, moral issues, decisions and social interaction play prominent roles. Many Hungarian players did not want dungeon crawling or a return to the first edition's often one-dimensional adventures, hanging in the air without a world. In the USA, however, plenty of people wanted precisely that. Those classic AD&D adventures, hanging in the air without a world, really do exemplify the Points of Light concept.
Without mindless powergaming, the fourth edition really is more tactical and often offers better opportunities for storytelling. It is simply missing one thing: roleplaying. Not because anyone deliberately eradicated it, or because the fourth edition wanted to change things, but because its writers knew the wargaming roots, had themselves seen that environment as their model, and could not even imagine that roleplaying is largely about a character's decisions: moral decisions, love, friendship, different interests, a thousand and one other things, but chiefly decisions. That for us it is not natural for a good drow to cut down his sister when he has a chance to redeem her, because he has a choice... We do not treat her as a monster to be killed merely because we encounter her as an "enemy" amid an adventure's battles.
I must admit that recognising this difference shocked me too, and recognising this characteristic was partly what persuaded me to write this article. Of course, beforehand I tried a little roleplaying myself, attempting to work out how an American might view GNS theory. Wizards' developers surely paid attention to this theory, and I have to say I could see a reading of it that applied to the wargaming market and combat games too, leaving out precisely decisions, the character's perspective and a truly living world. Simulation matters in combat systems and battles as well, where it likewise conflicts with gamism's demand for balance and narrativism's demand for an interesting outcome. Simple physical simulation. There is no depth involved—why would there be? If I can interpret it that way, so can someone who sees the market that way!
I went through the core books of several editions. Few discussed decisions, their consequences, freedom, possibilities or individual goals. Little was said about characters' families; somehow these things were not considered particularly important. There were plenty of logistical problems in the name of simulation: food has weight, treasure has weight, even potions have weight. The question is what you can carry and how. But beyond logistics, might food also have a flavour? That no longer mattered. Should there be a central story underlying the dungeon, or was the sole aim a varied challenge of appropriate difficulty? Which considerations contributed to entertaining battles, and which were extra simulation that slowed the game down?
Streamlining—removing unnecessary elements that slow play and optimising the game for classic dungeon crawling, an aim since the third edition—points in this direction. Who cares what dwarven culture is like? There should be dwarf wizards regardless, because those extra HP are needed; the other restrictions are merely frills slowing down play. It was like this in the days of Basic D&D, and it is like this today. Anything offering a little more looked like a sidetrack, disliked by the crowds seeking quick games at clubs. Yet once they were not the only people playing D&D and AD&D. Fortunately. It is no accident that BioWare games give lore more importance and have greater depth, sometimes running rings around many D&D publications precisely where roleplaying should be stronger.