D&D Essentials: It Was Not Needed
The arrival of D&D Essentials offers no escape from the predicted death spiral either, since it addresses the same target audience, leaving the shrinking market unchanged. But why is the market shrinking? There are chiefly four or five reasons. One typical reason is the contraction of the wargaming market, mainly because of computer games' growing popularity. A turn-based strategy game can be just as complex on a computer as on a table, and with a suitable scenario editor, no less free. So fewer people go to these clubs in the first place. Fewer shops can afford to maintain clubs. RPGNow, D&D Insider and Amazon all compete with them. There would also be plenty to say about the effects of a market shrinking because of computer games.
As a third main reason, I can mention that card games and other collecting games had already squeezed the roleplaying market. D&D is now far from dominant in clubs. We see it in Hungarian shops' clubs too: there are official Magic events, but no D&D events. If roleplaying differs from wargaming in that different players control "units", or heroes, with different tactical roles, and those units themselves develop over a campaign rather than the army growing in size, FPS games and other computer games can provide that approach too. You do not go to a club for that, perhaps a LAN party at most. Like it or not, D&D simply cannot offer more in this area.
The fifth main reason is streamlining. D&D was successfully stripped of many things unnecessary for this market and community but valuable to many other players. That led to the loss of a substantial part of the player base. This concept was already present in the third edition, and the attrition is nothing new. Naturally, the fourth edition intensified it: people who enjoyed going wild with powergaming there did not get what they valued from the fourth edition. The existing base shrank further. Negative criticism circulated widely, among players and potential players alike. Because the transition between editions three and four is so sharp in this respect, the current attrition is conspicuous. With good reason.
But the game did not only just become WOW-like; it could already do that in the d20 System era. Nor did dumbing it down begin now: "streamlining" in this direction was already the third edition's most prominent slogan. What has happened now is that an inherently dangerous concept has finally been executed well. Strangely, this may also have brought us closer to creating lifelike characters. Yet the game remains largely tactical, which is hardly good news. In individual scenes the question is still not how the character would like to resolve things, but which tactics can resolve them. Choices must follow efficiency rather than the character's thoughts. Streamlining, support for clubs and so forth remain.
Simplification and catering to people who dislike reading and thinking much are just as much a dead end as focusing on a market where roleplaying games are weak. The next edition of D&D will succeed when it focuses on roleplaying's strengths. Much water will flow under the bridge before then. Anyone who thinks the current game is "not D&D" should reread the original D&D box and consider what the T stood for in TSR, the company created to publish it. Where are D&D's roots? Why did TSR's and Wizards' explanations approach roleplaying as they did? Why was there never any discussion of unlimited, free imagination, living characters, dilemmas and decisions? Over roughly four decades, since Chainmail's 1971 release, they have scarcely reached the point of seeing that roleplaying can be something else, perhaps something more.
D&D Essentials was an interesting response to the fourth edition's problems. In many respects, however, it was the wrong response. And that is precisely why the fifth edition cannot quite get it right either. The fundamental question has never merely been that D&D competes with GURPS, Call of Cthulhu and many other roleplaying systems. It is also that roleplaying competes with tabletop strategy games, card games and computer games. Tabletop strategy games and board games have been there from the beginning. Leaving them out of competitor analysis is a problem.
D&D Compared with Other Roleplaying Games
D&D 4
- Better game balance, more tactical challenges
- "Sweeter victories"
- "Classic dungeon crawling"
- The DM's work is not wasted (safety rails)
- Freedom to reflavour
- Simplification makes it easy to learn
- But less detailed than its competitors
- Less faithful to its world than its competitors
- Attractive design
- Established brand name
- Regular, predictable opportunities to play
D&D 3.5
- Classic dungeon crawling
- Tactical combat in principle
- The DM's work is not wasted (safety rails)
- Free character creation
- The basics are easy to learn; all the options are not
- Less faithful to its world than many competitors
- Less detail about the world, more options instead
- Attractive design
- Established brand name
Storyteller
- Story-centred
- Familiar system, established brand name
- Atmospheric world
- Atmospheric design
- We know the world of Earth
- Terrible editing
- The system has low granularity
- Many things have not been checked mathematically
GURPS
- Detailed
- Complex
- Good rulebooks
- Slower, harder to learn
- Universal system
- Many worlds, a substantial proportion familiar
- Few supplements tied to particular worlds
D&D in the Overall Market
D&D
- Many rules to learn
- Requires a group
- Difficult for the game master to prepare
- Predictable sense of achievement
- "The game where a five-hour journey takes five minutes, and a five-minute fight takes five hours"
- Dungeon crawling gives lore increasingly less emphasis
- Freedom limited by "safety rails"
- Little visual stimulation
- Familiar brand
- All those books are expensive
Warhammer
- Many rules to learn
- Expensive miniatures
- Simpler preparation
- "A five-minute fight takes five hours"
- Tactics, strategy
- Less free than computer strategy games
- Familiar brand
- Lore explored by many people
- Requires one other player
- Many tournaments with prizes; made for competition
Magic: The Gathering
- Quick to learn
- Many cards are bloody expensive
- You may need to buy enormous numbers of packs
- Fast
- Requires one other player
- Well-known, large tournaments
- Made for competition
- Minimal preparation
- The role of chance
- A "pay to win" feel
Diablo II
- Playable at any time
- Zero preparation required
- Quick to learn
- Reliable, predictable sense of achievement
- A large community to show off your loot to
- A visual medium
- Fast, lively combat and adrenaline
- Some story behind it
- Familiar brand
World of Warcraft
- Quick to learn
- Tactical raids and arenas
- Fast, lively but "chaotic" combat
- A visual medium
- Large community
- Playable at any time
- A sense of achievement is reliably available
- Even roleplaying on RP servers
- More complex game with many abilities
- Continuously expanding lore
The situation is interesting in many respects. D&D outperforms other roleplaying games in areas where computer games, card games and many other products may do still better. Freedom is among tabletop roleplaying's traditional virtues, allowing players to leave a written adventure behind and potentially waste the GM's work. If that possibility disappears, players might as well choose Diablo or Baldur's Gate instead. But if freedom remains, it is easy to leave a prepared adventure, and the GM's work can be wasted. In a similarly freer game, the ability to "improvise" at such moments matters.
For improvisation to work without problems, however, solid foundations help: a setting description written to meet this need and a consistently designed vision of the world. This was not, and has not become, D&D's strength.