M.A.G.U.S. — The New Rulebook
I make no secret of it: the New Rulebook will be both the best and the worst of the editions and attempts so far. The best because there are sensible people behind it, so we can expect them to listen to feedback. Much of what they have done could even be attractive, with problems large and small. Some problems are terribly subjective; others are objective. For instance, a representative of the publisher does not accompany every copy sold. It therefore does not necessarily help if three minutes of conversation reveal how one of the publisher's people would interpret a particular rule.
Grace points are one such issue. Many players and game masters interpret them to mean that, because they are not mana points, Destruction does not affect the spell in question. The head of the publisher behind ÚTK interprets it differently: he believes Destruction would indeed affect that spell too. We know from Ynev's history that gods can be defeated—more than one manifestation has met that fate—Ranagol teaches it too, and the solid arguments go on. There is also something called the ancient pact, which cannot be circumvented by a prayer or request, so this certainly cannot be the god's own creative and destructive power.
But which interpretation is decisive? The correct one also used by the publisher's head, or the one that overturns Ynev's history and that many defend on grounds of atmosphere? Obviously, whichever the player encounters more often, and the head of the publisher rarely sits at the table. It is not good for questions like this to interrupt play, so points come off regardless of the solution. I know: errata, the publisher's many plans, or a possible second edition of ÚTK would immediately solve this. But there is no second edition, the errata fail to reach many places, and the question can interrupt play even with them.
Nor is this the only case. There are many other little issues for which the publisher surely has an appealing solution, except that players do not play that way. A wizard learns every mosaic, but struggles to use them under pressure because it is hard to determine what they could achieve and how... That is why many skills are needed to use them meaningfully; all well and good. Except most people treat it as though wizard training were incomplete and did not cover more complex spells. The system also struggles with many kinds of specialization and organizing principle. A wizard specializing in the magical arts, for example, specializes in how magic is applied rather than in particular chapters of magic. What would the system allow them to do, and how, if they learned how to achieve an effect by combining painting and magic?
The concept behind the system could be good, but many characters plausible on Ynev will run into these snags. This means that despite the KAP system, severe restrictions appear. Usually these serve balance, but sometimes they arise unexpectedly, as consequences that were not necessarily intended. And I do not feel that the KAP system's allowing utterly implausible builds that the GM would never permit increases freedom. The system nevertheless works, is playable, and satisfies many people. Its many tournaments provide excellent support too, but this is precisely what has made ÚTK a strong challenger that divides the community more than its predecessors. As long as it has problems, that is not good news.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — New Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
What the table does not show is that my real problem is with the concept. I am not saying it is bad. I am saying I do not like it. Its target audience is a little different, which is understandable given how heterogeneous the M.A.G.U.S. community is. We hear that this or that had to be restricted because people abused it in one way or another. There could have been a good explanation, a restriction that did not immediately wreck a class's abilities. Instead, the result is disheartening. Some say: martial artists already faced many roleplaying restrictions, and now many of their options have been taken away on the grounds that they would be abused. The problem is that this balances the class with would-be abusers in mind, but leaves it less balanced in the hands of those who evade the roleplaying restrictions.
Many also point to knight-versus-paladin balance and say there is none. They play more ÚTK than I do, so I would not argue with them even if I disagreed. Whatever the situation, though, I keep hearing that good players suffer because the system had to be optimized to handle munchkins. You can hack your way through an adventure at a tournament. No problem; some enormously overpowered abuses are impossible. True, utterly implausible builds and many other things are still possible, while restrictions kill off many believable character concepts built on good stories.
But it is good for playing in clubs and tournaments. I would venture to say that in that situation it is better than the patched-together ETK used by most long-established tournament-organizing groups. The trouble is, I do not like these adventure-solving competitions. A system rests on a multitude of compromises. Every decision that sacrifices the home-based, life-spanning campaign—more a "serious, time-consuming hobby than a children's game"—to make adventure-solving competitions and events work better hurts and repels me. Even if I say the best events and competitions of that kind use ÚTK. I cannot do anything with that compromise.
The publisher's head says that this solid foundation can later be relaxed through supplements. There is just one problem: munchkins use supplements too. Roleplaying that requires a solid foundation for its world needs that world's natural laws not to depend on whether those relaxing supplements are used or avoided. Otherwise, from the standpoint of setting and roleplaying, this is anything but a solid foundation. By contrast, many systems with a solid foundation for their worlds have introduced tournament rules for balance. We can say that Shadowrun Third Edition's core book does not offer much freedom either... But it does not impose such severe restrictions. It merely puts some of the content, and some good rules for extending it, elsewhere. Because space is finite, not for balance.
When my simplest response to munchkins is to explain why powergaming will not make them win, why it will backfire badly—and there are simple explanations, guidelines, and rules for this—the restrictions above are of no use to me whatsoever, because the munchkin problem they seek to solve can be solved more easily, unless the group specifically asks to let the munchkin in. But let us move on. I still suffer the problems the restrictions cause, and I do not believe there will ever be a package of supplements that remedies them. Even if there is, it will declare that the world's workings are anything but uniform, since they rest on a host of options.
So I gain nothing by choosing ÚTK over the existing edition, but unfortunately many problems and additional arguments remain. Oh, and I can throw out every existing adventure, NPC, homemade supplement, and everything else in its entirety. Well, thank you very much, but that is not a good offer. Not because ÚTK is worse, but simply because it starts more than a decade behind. I would certainly recommend it to a beginner who has a lot of trouble with munchkins but does not want to engage with many details of the world and therefore does not experience these problems. Overall, though, there is a serious issue: the factors I have mentioned throughout. PCs and the army still matter.
Today there are very few situations in which someone encounters roleplaying without other entertainment alternatives, such as computer games. The fact is that tabletop roleplaying still has several major advantages. An adventure requires less development work, so more adventures are made in a year than computer games. Thus we can say it also suits people who grew up on PC RPGs and want to powergame and win at any cost. D&D Organized Play can provide this too. But MMO games, Diablo III's mechanics emphasizing replayability, and many other things also tempt them. I feel that a powergamer or munchkin starting something today would rarely end up choosing M.A.G.U.S. unless we specifically invited them.
After all, a few dungeon tiles, monster libraries, and Pathfinder cover everything, and there you can really powergame. But it is not a given that munchkins will switch from Diablo to tabletop roleplaying. I know that Nyul, who produced CODEX as a demanding game fundamentally intended for discerning players, grew up at PeCsa, then notorious for undiscerning munchkins. It simply seems he developed a taste for more and better. Nobody starts out as a discerning roleplayer. I do not believe there are fewer munchkins today either.
It is simply easy for them to start with Diablo III today. When they see that roleplaying requires reading and is more complicated, hear what more it offers, but are told that it is not about powergaming, what will they do? Decide they need tabletop roleplaying, yet despite the Internet's size and all the recommendations from all those people, fail to seek a dungeon crawl specifically suited to them? Instead ruin everyone else's game in a story- and setting-focused game, with that group doing nothing about it? And this could not be solved? Or will they seek a game tailored to their needs? I believe the latter.
Most players play with an established group; their experiences at events and tournaments are secondary. A competition judged on solving the adventure distorts even the most roleplaying-focused player's behavior a little: they will powergame there too. I would therefore not even infer how a given player plays at home from tournament exploits. ÚTK is a M.A.G.U.S. with which you can organize excellent competitions for munchkins whose powergaming is being restricted at that moment. Being good at that required many compromises, accepting that it would be less good at other things.
The player looking for a more serious hobby, enjoying the game's depth and freedom, who might even learn invented languages or debate the philosophy of magical theory—and who, whether a humanities graduate, doctor, pilot, or engineer, has an inquisitive mind and books about probability, game theory, and so on on their shelves—will observe: for the sake of munchkins powergaming at tournaments, they gave up what would matter to me. This game plainly was not made for me. It is not for roleplayers like that.
And with a system made for tournaments, we will be no more able to reach someone on a Star Wars: The Old Republic RP server, in an RP guild, teaching apprentices how to interpret the Sith Code or taking a few people on a field exercise while issuing orders in Mando'a, than someone paying closer attention to roleplaying and characters' personalities in a forum RPG, even one set on Ynev. I would seek something else and consider something else good.
But suppose tomorrow or the day after brings a better solution to the problem, and many of ÚTK's creators consider it better too. We would still have to say that ÚTK had to be created using what they knew then and the models and examples available to them at the time. That leads here. Nor is that really the problem. If they created a genuinely simulation-based system for more discerning roleplayers, would the writers and worldbuilders at DV be able to deliver their share at a reasonable pace and quality? I do not think so.
If we look at M.A.G.U.S.'s problems in ÚTK's era, starting from this edition, 5% consists of genuine problems with the system, and 10% of easily corrected system problems. The writing team and community painstakingly built the remaining 85% for themselves over many years, independently of Tuan and ÚTK's creators. If ÚTK moved much further toward the sort of quality game CODEX once was, the 15% within its control might become 3%. But the other problems would remain. Even if we discard many developments of the past twenty years, the question remains: why not CODEX, why not something else, why not build our own world properly?
What dismays me is that many restrictions concerned with balance and game mechanics are described as simulation. Simulation would mean faithfully following the world's history, existing magical laws, and so forth at the rules level, without regard to game balance and other considerations outside the world. Bringing up such considerations currently leads to the situation where "you could find fault with anyone on that basis." When ÚTK began optimizing for certain problems and for play in certain situations, it chose a target audience. What suits that group inevitably puts others off. And it chose an audience for whom quality problems elsewhere in M.A.G.U.S., beyond the creators' control, would not derail the project.
However much one can point to its faults, inconsistencies, or anything else, those are not disruptive in this situation. It is a decent product... There are simply many other decent products on the market. And I could not recommend ÚTK to three groups: people who invested serious work in their own carefully developed solutions for traditional M.A.G.U.S.; munchkins drawing on many online supplements and the communities catering to them; and finally newcomers, because M.A.G.U.S. is no longer the best choice for that last group.
Although I considered scores, I found myself asking: if the Delta Vision-associated creative team supplying much of the literary background worsens ÚTK's position, how fair is it to mark Tuan down for literary support when this too is a source of dispute? If supplements are missing for legal reasons, is it right to punish the system for that? And... There will be no score. It would not be an outstanding one: the result is neither above 67% nor below 61%. Compared with today's expected standards, ÚTK's setting description is much worse than it looks alongside other M.A.G.U.S. editions. And it becomes increasingly difficult to blame decades of support problems on individual systems.
Precisely because the problem seems to be becoming permanent: the dispute between the rights holder and publisher erupted over books published without the rights holder's consent. Tuan wanted to publish more, because ongoing literary support and a supply of supplements are necessary. Authors who at other times approved even rubbish would not consent to many of these publications. And yes, preventing expansions without permission had arisen before too: this intention of the owners was what cost the d20 project the most.
If I count this against them, around 61–62% would be realistic; if I side with them, around 66–67%. That would depend on sympathy and faith.