Article Index

M.A.G.U.S. — M.A.G.U.S. 2*0, or the Lunír attempt

My feelings are mixed. On the one hand, where the Lunír team answered questions, I liked their answers, whether about power words or the nature of adventurers. All well and good. There is just one problem: it will not be finished anytime soon. And I dislike their attitude toward playtesting groups just as much as the behavior of the creators around Delta Vision. The literary background's contribution is deteriorating. Suppose the guys overcome every adverse influence and release the best M.A.G.U.S. edition yet—at a time when most people already play other RPGs too, take out M.A.G.U.S. for nostalgia, and want to stick to their existing approaches, good or bad.

There is also one small problem: delays already are a suspicious sign. Supplements will face the same delays later. Many supplements, atlases for example, would not need to wait for the new system's release. Nor do I think whether the system is published has anything to do with the fact that we are not being flooded with one excellent novel after another. Support falls short of Tuan's level, so a disadvantage here is almost certain. Who will simulate the world's many details better if a release happens? We have no way of knowing. That is still in the future. 

But as long as M.A.G.U.S. is often a cash cow, the M.A.G.U.S. logo can sell literary works of dubious value, and quality is not the most important criterion in selecting authors, even the best RPG creative team cannot simultaneously guarantee quality and fidelity to the world known from the fiction. Even now, 90% of the debate concerns which previous state to return to. The munchkin attached to their power-word-using character would choose differently from someone wanting to simulate many events concerning the spread of modern magic.

Unfortunately, the M.A.G.U.S. community's expectations are not uniform. Everyone using different options within a shared system would not unite the community either. In roughly twenty-one years, M.A.G.U.S. has not become a stable system making the most of its potential. Most disappointed people will no longer give it a clean slate, and however inspiring Lunír initially was, delays and uncertainty have largely erased this promising start too. And the situation looks disheartening for reasons beyond the delay. 

The pace of development is problematic, but so is the way beta testers were recruited. This brings to the fore the opinions of people who irresponsibly sign blank contracts, raising questions about how carefully they think about game design and the like. Throwing together ideas from such sources and discarding a well-considered common foundation has caused problems more than once. Add that the team is insufficiently productive, that this much time and working time cannot be financed from individual books, and that neither the literary background nor RPG publications can generate steady profits without steady releases, and the whole project is unsustainable.