Article Index

M.A.G.U.S. — Homebrew systems

The greatest criticism of M.A.G.U.S.'s history so far is that I mention this option, take it seriously, and am prepared to assess it to some degree. Normally, I would say homebrew systems and professional solutions do not play in the same league. Let us imagine three levels. The highest belongs to genuinely professional work, with a business plan and deadlines, for example, but also multiple levels of quality assurance. The company developing and publishing the system employs people with different competencies, and their expertise shows in the result. 

Indie systems also tend to have a strong concept and some business planning, but not necessarily deadlines, so the supply of supplements is not continuous either. There is no carefully structured team, but there is an intention to ensure suitable quality. The means of doing so is sensible self-restraint. And if quality is the goal, developers read up on things, educate themselves, acquire the necessary tools, and build the world deliberately. The underlying attitude is that the developer works to benefit the customer. The developer does things the customer could do themselves on the customer's behalf, preferably to a slightly higher standard. 

Then there is the amateur level. Anyone failing to meet the standards of the two levels above ends up here. With M.A.G.U.S., the very first moment a developer wanted to contradict another rather than serve the player's interests put them in this category. When projects were handled by writers unwilling to think through and learn what world design and game design entail, who consequently often produced worse work than a GM paying even a little attention, they made the decision: from then on, M.A.G.U.S. played in the amateur league. They developed it to please themselves, but it was not a professional product.

If we have covered these periods and creators capable of that level of work, why not discuss all the homemade solutions too? As I said, many people adapted M.A.G.U.S. to the d20 System. They were never official as M.A.G.U.S. But they knew the d20 System and how to build games on it, and might even have been better than the official development team at the time, whom the publisher also recruited from the amateur league. 

There are many homebrew systems and conversions of the M.A.G.U.S. world to other systems, with numerous examples of "CODEX rules, but on Ynev" or "D&D/d20 System, but on Ynev." Evaluating them all separately would be impossible. They do, however, share certain features. Like many official editions, they are unsuitable as a foundation for players who do not know each other to play together with a more or less shared interpretation of the rules. Yet it is also true that while players often treat an official edition as a system where even their preferred interpretation is not good enough, merely less flawed, users of comparable homebrew solutions are generally satisfied with them. 

If these are not substantially worse than several official editions, and some may even be better, and if they have the undeniable advantage that someone has thought them through and the current GM understands what they meant when writing each rule, why should they not be good for home use? They simply cannot be published or meaningfully handed over to another group. And someone capable of creating a system that remains competitive in other people's hands might also be capable of replacing Ynev, solving the problem of contradictory writing and destruction at the setting level. 

I would add that the worst move many M.A.G.U.S. writers made was to say, as rights holders defending contradictory writing and ill-considered opinions, that this was how they had conceived M.A.G.U.S. from the beginning. Because that statement can then be cited. If they say the imaginative, beautiful solutions they are trying to eradicate were never part of M.A.G.U.S. in their view, those things may be easy to copy, and they would then struggle to assert their interests when those ideas and many solutions are borrowed. After all, they publicly declared that the idea in question was never part of M.A.G.U.S. They thought this through and stated it as certain fact in many arguments...

If someone uses those statements as evidence in a legal dispute, it will be difficult to explain that the ideas are theirs after all. M.A.G.U.S. became interesting not because Arel happens to be called Arel, but because of many connections, possibilities, and elements giving the world color. If a rights holder sometimes explains vehemently enough that a particular idea, consistent way of thinking, and so on is alien to M.A.G.U.S., and the strengths built on it are not part of M.A.G.U.S., then they certainly are not the rights holder of those ideas.

That is why destructive contradictory writing, accompanied by insisting "we thought this from the beginning," is dangerous to oneself. 

Leaving a good homebrew system trapped in that legal situation instead of trying to turn it into an original game capable of spreading meaningfully wastes both the work invested and an excellent opportunity.