Article Index

Second and third editions

Two new editions appeared in 1994, doing nothing more than correcting errors. At the same time, numerous questions arose, and as we know, there is no accounting for taste... many people wanted many little things done differently, so a push for reform began. Needless to say, the system's structure did not change along with this, but its market position did: Middle-earth Role Playing came out in the meantime, for example, and the conflict with Bíborhold turned bitter. It is worth recognizing that this kind of warfare was already part of the M.A.G.U.S. scene and the character of many of its creators. In this new situation, roleplaying became much more mainstream.

Meanwhile, two other important changes were happening in the world. When Windows 95 came out, many people still joked about the number of installation disks, but the situation had nevertheless changed by then. You only needed one CD. And CD-ROM and CD-R partly settled the contest between PCs, Amigas, and other computers specifically intended for home use. On the one hand, many people saw a PC as a replacement for a separate CD player; on the other, once CD-R spread, you could compile your own music collections. PCs also suddenly became competitive in multimedia capabilities. More and more people could thus discover computer games and computer RPGs. And István Veér may well have preferred the easier victories available on a computer. 

But however much the world was changing, a corrected reprint meeting customers' needs could not respond to these developments. The second and third editions of M.A.G.U.S. could therefore deliver exactly as much as they did. We could be happy with that. Addressing many of the shortcomings should instead have been the job of the eagerly awaited supplements. Their absence is all too familiar, but unfortunately it is not a phenomenon specific to any one edition.

M.A.G.U.S. — Second and third editions

Strengths Weaknesses
  • Mosaic magic
  • Theory of magic
  • Dual health system
  • More true-to-life play than AD&D
  • A skill system faithful to the setting
  • Class concepts faithful to the setting
  • Designed for life-spanning campaigns (the spirit of the times)
  • The role of adventurers
  • A system thought through by its lead designer
  • A literary background
  • Officially available in Hungarian
  • A friendly price
  • One book is enough to get started
  • Good support (Rúna)
  • An incomplete setting description
  • Problematic ability checks
  • Delayed publications
  • Compatibility problems with supplements
Opportunities Threats
  • Missing details are easy to fill in
  • Supplements can easily become incompatible
  • Competitors may appear
  • Card games pose a growing threat
  • Computers pose a growing threat
  • Poor responses to customer criticism
  • Divided resources

It is clear that although execution improved in many respects, the increasingly legendary delays to supplements and novels did almost as much harm as the early printing errors, which could still be easily corrected or filled in. Meanwhile, Rúna often published answers of dubious value to questions and criticisms, with little time devoted to thinking many solutions through. This did not necessarily affect the system itself, since Rúna was not that decisive an influence, but it was nevertheless a warning sign and a reason for caution. The Bestiary fundamentally stirred things up. XP awards were handled differently, so even where its balance of power was well conceived, many people failed to adjust to it. No explanation was devised for why anyone would summon a weaker demon. In a world that had been human-centered in both its literature and its underlying concept, monsters suddenly became much more important.

Although Két Hold also brought heroes of a more human scale into M.A.G.U.S., the Aun adventurer set a dangerous precedent: from then on, the question of what would be accepted in a city no longer arose... Meanwhile, an attempt to break into the music industry also tied up the publisher's resources. An album associated with Két Hold was released, showcasing singer Lilla Vincze's work. And if that were not enough, the debut material of Carpe Diem, one of the successful bands of the 1990s, was also part of this music project. Consequently, one issue of Rúna came with a cassette. 

And meanwhile, some players received their draft notices. Compulsory military service helped M.A.G.U.S. spread. On guard duty you could not use a computer, play soccer, or even party. Discipline in the army was not as relaxed as in the TV series Angyalbőrben, either. Boring guard duty, peeling potatoes, and so on needed something to liven them up. If a soldier knew the rules and their character's important statistics by heart, there was plenty of opportunity to play. So the game spread among soldiers and border guards. 

I might add that, according to malicious tongues, today's contract personnel are not necessarily unfamiliar with livening up tedious guard duty in this way either. The game thus became fairly mainstream. Those who had played before and took worldbuilding and life-spanning campaigns a little more seriously naturally expected something different from Private Kovács II, the infantryman who wanted to spend guard duty slaughtering the Bestiary's monsters—in XP order, page order, or alphabetical order. Any resemblance between the name of the orc he was about to beat up and his sergeant's was purely coincidental.

If we include the Bestiary's minor contradictions but do not consider Rúna a determining factor, this is how M.A.G.U.S. should be rated at this point:

Ratings:

  • Completeness of setting description: 6/10
  • Consistency of setting description: 5/10
  • Interest of setting description: 7/10
  • Freedom in character creation: 8/10
  • Game balance: 5/10
  • Consistency of the system: 8/10
  • Literary background: 7/10
  • Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
  • Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
  • Execution: 7/10
  • Total: 70%