Article Index

M.A.G.U.S. — New Scrolls

A worthy spiritual successor to the Summarium project. They managed to decide it could not be combined with the old system, but provided no new descriptions for the old races. They devised a new form of magic with no description. And many skills cannot be taken anyway because circular prerequisites forbid it. Many other little details about the system are legendary too. We are in 1999. Meanwhile, the world of computer RPGs has seen the arrival of Planescape: Torment, one of the most atmospheric and interesting computer roleplaying games of all time. Why does that matter? For several reasons.

The recurring complaint so far is still that the world is not developed even where it should be. Its lore, so to speak, is incomplete. By this time, however, an increasing proportion of players are already playing computer RPGs before they discover tabletop roleplaying. Although EverQuest is already around, spreading the MMO era further, that is not a decisive factor here in Hungary. Many players grow accustomed even in the simplest CRPGs to plentiful lore, with developers spoiling them with more and more text and story. That can be decisive in shaping the spirit of the times.

We say tabletop roleplaying is the real thing. Players' freedom and the ever greater detail they can discover are what make it offer more than a computer game. Then we reach a point where game balance, the group concept, and many other expectations leave them choosing between a handful of builds in either one. At the table, they rarely stray from the adventure either, because the others are not going that way. They do not feel the freedom, but they notice the missing lore. Alongside the dungeon-crawling power fantasy, lore became the other selling point. Although many tabletop RPGs build on classic dungeon crawls, hordes of slaughtered monsters, and the classic power fantasy, the game industry's other watchword is lore.

And somewhere in all this stands M.A.G.U.S., with incomplete lore, freedom sacrificed in many areas on the altar of balance, and an unnecessarily cumbersome system... Oh, and no powergaming: we are not competing in the power-fantasy league either. Then where are we competing? Contradictory writing is undermining M.A.G.U.S.'s traditional strengths. And yes, the lore is missing too. 

M.A.G.U.S. — New Scrolls

Strengths Weaknesses
  • Mosaic magic can be carried over
  • The theory of magic can be carried over
  • The dual health system is untouched
  • Designed for life-spanning campaigns 
  • A huge number of serious errors
  • An incomplete setting description
  • Problematic ability checks
  • A huge number of ill-considered skills
  • The system is not complete on its own
  • Odd classes, etc.
  • Little prospect of continuation
  • The five-tier system is not good
  • Classes alien to the setting
  • Ill-considered race descriptions
Opportunities Threats
  • Missing details are easy to fill in

 

New Scrolls is thus a system that is not even half finished, largely an amateur elaboration of Summarium. Fundamentally, though, it is clear that the original creative team brought in outside help here too: amateurs who introduced amateur mistakes. Recruiting from the fans has continued ever since. But apparently it is important that, alongside them, the system's custodians at the center remain the people who have so far mainly contributed novels or seriously undermined the whole thing. At this point we are entitled to ask: yes, they have written the occasional novel that could hold its own even internationally, but might we have been better off with writers of average ability, hired writers who did not undermine the game, were productive, and did not deceive us? We may begin to feel that M.A.G.U.S. would have been better off without a few famous authors, and that it would have gone further if good work rather than obedient nodding had been the standard. 

Ratings:

  • Completeness of setting description: 6/10
  • Consistency of setting description: 3/10
  • Interest of setting description: 7/10
  • Freedom in character creation: 4/10
  • Game balance: 3/10
  • Consistency of the system: 5/10
  • Literary background: 6/10
  • Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 5/10
  • Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 3/10
  • Execution: 3/10
  • Total: 45%