M.A.G.U.S. — Was 2.0 in the works?
There are all sorts of legends about what happened around the publication of the Second Rulebook, and how. One thing is certain: the M.A.G.U.S. creative team fell apart afterward. Another certainty is that many of the rules did not first appear there. And Csanád Novák, who was often inclined to agree with fan material, promised to adopt many ideas; he was also the one thinking about the deadline. Anyone who has held the CODEX core book and its Grimoire supplement, and knows that they were originally intended as a revised edition of M.A.G.U.S.—and that this revamped M.A.G.U.S. edition was originally supposed to be called the Second Rulebook—may begin to suspect that the Second Rulebook was only thrown together at the very last moment, or even later.
Perhaps largely out of defiance: "Here you go, Csanád, this is what something cobbled together from fan material looks like." On the one hand, it is a fact that many of the book's innovations are still widely used. On the other, the community would never dream of using many of its other innovations, so its reputation remains debatable. The Khál issue hit even harder at the time. Rúna was already dying. CODEX turned out better, but by then it was very far from alone in the market, and language was no longer such a major advantage. Frankly, though, even a perfect system reform would not have accomplished much: the parts of the M.A.G.U.S. system that existed could be better in many respects than most of its direct competitors. Even a moderately good explanation would have sufficed to deal with the disputed questions...
The problem that needed addressing was not corrections, but filling the enormous missing sections. Yet we had reached a situation where reform of the system was entrusted to one developer, while it remained unclear who would produce a substantial range of meaningful supplements. Or at least adventure modules featuring the occasional new spell or magic item. And I would venture to suggest that maps, brief descriptions, and the like would not necessarily have been difficult to publish. Descriptions of countries, either. Meanwhile, though, we could wait years for a promised novel: it soon became clear that the writing team was not particularly productive.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — With the Second Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
Looking at it, you notice that few people worked on filling in the missing details, even though there was plenty to flesh out. The question is whose responsibility that was. It would be easy to say the system had a lead designer, but he could primarily work on the countries where he ran games. Moreover, you cannot expect both that and system reform at the same time. The fact that the Second Rulebook had to appear in this half-finished, partly cobbled-together form was primarily because there was nothing else. Novels were late too; Rúna could not be filled with content, short stories could not make up for it, and there was little idea of what to fill with what. Meanwhile, some of the less productive members of the team wanted to borrow all sorts of things from here and there. People who merely interfered without producing much themselves held up the system reform.
The opportunities remained opportunities, unused. The problem was not that there were blank spots. Those let many GMs build their own city-states. A much bigger problem was that numerous other countries had not been fleshed out either. And even since then, contradicting Nyul's conception of Krán has remained more important than providing a proper description of a few major states of the Pyarronian Confederation, for instance. Meanwhile, numerous other roleplaying games had become available, and fewer and fewer people were frightened by a setting description or rulebook in English. The details that the creators still owe us had already become painfully conspicuous omissions by then.
Some of the new races created still more unanswered questions concerning player characters, questions that have no credible, precise answer to this day. But it cannot be said often enough: the Second Rulebook was a symptom of M.A.G.U.S.'s problems at the time, not their cause. Had the writing team been productive, had there been country descriptions, adventures, maps, many kinds of publications, and a thriving M.A.G.U.S. with plenty of fans getting good answers, it would not have seemed a matter of survival to publish a Second Rulebook that was half-finished in many respects and still had to satisfy a wish list. All right: let me not be unfair. Warriors, Barbarians, Gladiators came out too.
Many people talk about its "overpowered" classes—the Sirenar ranger is one example—its skills, and this and that, but these are not the important faults. What matters is that the gaps that should have been filled with content between the start of the M.A.G.U.S. project and this point remained largely untouched. It did manage to overturn the relationship between warriors and soldiers, however, and to launch the distinctly less-than-noble tradition of "characters starting with lunír weapons." It is strange that even the setting description of CODEX, published after the split, is better thought out and more complete...
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 4/10
- Consistency of setting description: 6/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 4/10
- Consistency of the system: 6/10
- Literary background: 6/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 6/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 7/10
- Execution: 5/10
- Total: 59%