Anyone expecting a "test winner" and thinking it might be the First Rulebook is fundamentally mistaken. In many respects, the First Rulebook was a step backward from earlier editions, and its other innovations could have worked better as supplements, Rúna material, or other available support, such as online content. It was clearly a bad system reform, from the era in which almost all of M.A.G.U.S.'s problems originated. By comparison, the New Rulebook delivered a fundamentally usable system. We can discuss how mistaken interpretations of many rules have spread. We can point to many faults, but no flawless system exists or ever will.
The New Rulebook is largely ideal for competitions, events, and solving adventures where nobody wants to explore connections too deeply. The developers achieved what they intended, what was needed for success with their chosen audience. From that perspective, the system is a step forward. A more world-centered approach would have faced many problems from creators contradicting each other, and starting decades behind would not have been easy. Many of us have invested that much time in creating a coherent vision of the world that works well in play. One supplement could not replace this: it would have had to replace every correction, expansion, and so forth created over those decades.
For a new edition to be convincing, we must be able to assume there will be a solid foundation to which the writers also adapt, followed by a productive period in both fiction and supplements. That is practically impossible. M.A.G.U.S. is heterogeneous in many other respects too. Just think of its many tournament organizers and the teams behind different sites. I do not share the opinion that ETK tournaments fill only a few tables; I have seen crowds myself. ÚTK would nevertheless be better suited to tournaments in many ways. Yet I do not believe such groups would switch.
A switch like that would also wipe out the supplements created by the sites behind those tournaments. Those supplements are what brought the communities together. We can point out that one group or another collects every powergaming option, that many supplements are rubbish, and that many people rightly say so. Or that their "Ynev scholars" industriously gather every contradictory piece of writing like ants and build a great deal on it. They dislike drawing inferences or thinking through the original connections. Meanwhile, their different visions of the world remain incompatible. There will be neither balance nor fidelity to the setting.
The original core book, however, is damned incomplete, and analyzing it throughout, filling it out properly, and supplying missing explanations through analysis of its rules is not necessarily a dream task. My having good solutions is little use if two-thirds of them have never appeared here or on any other website and, since M.A.G.U.S. is not my only priority, are unlikely to do so. I do consider ÚTK worse than a system based on the original core book and put in order over a long time—but that system has a good many years' head start. ÚTK does what it does straight from the shop. Comparing the two in those states would be comparing apples and pears.
If we ask how well each served the needs at its release, what sort of product it was, the first edition was of course excellent. But winning a review through fortunate publication timing would not be ideal. ÚTK has certainly learned from several mistakes, inherited many weaknesses introduced by earlier contradictory writing, and may have a few faults of its own. Yet in many other respects it has improved.
Naturally, I will say that a consistently handled, carefully thought-out world is good and provides fertile ground for discerning roleplaying. Many people share their experience and knowledge, and you can ask questions here too. But the other playable solution is plainly the New Rulebook. And those two cannot be compared. The conclusion is that M.A.G.U.S. did not become popular by accident. But through years and decades of persistent destruction, we have reached a point where, however large a fan base the brand attracts, the inherited situation makes it difficult to unite that audience by developing a truly good product. Spending more on fighting over the rights than on creating and launching a good world is therefore not necessarily a well-considered strategy.
The New Rulebook is a good M.A.G.U.S. edition for tournaments and events. It simply occurs to me that D&D 5 has more worlds, supplements, and literary works, Organized Play is no foolish idea, and if we are not taking the world seriously anyway, its flaws will not bother us either. Knowing ÚTK's legal position and much else, the question arises: if problems with the quality of M.A.G.U.S. fiction, the quantitative shortage of meaningful literary support, and many other little things are disadvantages, why would I recommend M.A.G.U.S. and ÚTK over D&D 5? Or, for that matter, the earlier D&D 4.