Article Index

M.A.G.U.S. — The d20-based system

Our little country seems to be a superpower in roleplaying-game development. It is not just that every team is smarter than the former developer who has become an enemy; apparently even a multinational the size of Hasbro employs nothing but idiots in marketing. The professionally superbly prepared team of M.A.G.U.S. rights holders now working at Delta Vision, Inomi, and the other Hungarian interests know a thousand times better than the d20 System's creators how to use that system successfully. What a pity the market failed to appreciate this marvelous, exceptional talent, and d20-based M.A.G.U.S. was not a success. Let us say the slogan "Charge! Surprise! Flat on your face!" worked perfectly.

The d20 System was enormously popular worldwide, thanks to an open license that allowed substantial compatibility even with D&D Third Edition. This was a serious market. Many games used it to enter the international market and easily reach numerous players. The system was successful here too, and can still be called successful today, with D&D 3.x and Pathfinder both having substantial player bases. Ynev and many of M.A.G.U.S.'s achievements could have succeeded in the market surrounding d20 as well. But that did not happen.

Nor can external factors be blamed. What happened was simply that their egos were once again two or three sizes too big, and understanding just three things was beneath Delta Vision's creative team. First, why M.A.G.U.S. players had not already switched to the d20 System. Second, why so many successful games sought compatibility and access to the d20 market. Third, merely the strategy that Wizards and its parent company Hasbro had thought through for the d20 market, including how others could succeed by joining it. 

Hasbro was not stupid. The shared supplement market was intended to let a supplement serve multiple worlds and games, making it easier to supply that larger market with profitable supplements. In other words, I could choose to realize almost all M.A.G.U.S.'s virtues—including ones this edition does not offer—on a d20 foundation, using available publications. The system would be compatible and international, with plenty of good supplements. Even if I do not own the setting, most interesting class concepts remain interesting without being so closely tied to that world, so instead of a fan site there is RPGnow... Or I could choose an inward-looking system with all the development team's limitations. And the system's closed nature is not primarily a matter of rules. It stems from the goal of preventing supplements usable with M.A.G.U.S. from appearing without the rights holders' consent and appropriate compensation. 

This mistake leads straight back to the lack of productivity in setting descriptions, novels, and everything else. Even approved material was slow to be completed, so third-party supplements could have swept the market. The limitation lay not within Inomi's own system-development team, but in the surrounding circle of rights holders, writers, and world creators, so responsibility for its consequences is shared too. AND it remains a serious problem that proper support for Ynev could not be provided even today using an available open system, for precisely the same unchanged reasons. The people tinkering with the rules are not primarily responsible for that. 

Where there is a choice between systems sharing the same foundation and serving the same world, there is no point comparing the system with earlier editions or another game. It is enough to measure it against what the d20 market offers without that particular book. And here there were few positives left, still less an easily communicated selling point. Do not misunderstand: this nevertheless remained a quite usable system...

M.A.G.U.S. — The d20-based attempt

Strengths Weaknesses

 

  • Most of M.A.G.U.S.'s strengths could be realized with other d20-based publications, making it unnecessary
  • The setting description is still incomplete
  • It did nothing to address why many M.A.G.U.S. players do not choose d20
  • Deliberate incompatibility
  • A foundation designed for many supplements, without supplements
  • A community well acquainted with the d20 System's basic weaknesses
Opportunities Threats

 

  • "When is the next D&D coming?"

The result was a foregone conclusion. Anyone who liked d20 had no need for the new book and could find faults in it. Anyone who disliked the d20 System disliked these rules from the outset. All right, there was a niche. Someone open to a more complicated system, a great deal of work and learning, yet too lazy to try books in a foreign language; who knew nobody who could help them past that obstacle; who liked d20's greater emphasis on tactics and was therefore willing to give up the finer resolution basic M.A.G.U.S. offered in many areas... Who also did not mind that few people played the system, that finding a group was difficult, and who accepted its faults just as readily as those of the others... Well, it could have suited that person. But that was not enough for market success. 

Especially because the world had changed again. The MMO revolution was now complete, and groups that cared about lore and took roleplaying seriously were present on RP servers too. We could mention Neverwinter Nights and so on: computer games were increasingly strong competitors to traditional roleplaying, and the question increasingly became how a game's developer could respond to the challenges posed by that competition. This was certainly not impossible. Here in Hungary, nostalgia was not the driving force; the aim was not to bring people who remembered AD&D First Edition or the earliest D&Ds back to the table, now that the children had left home and they had time again. Many people targeted another community.

Conscripts. There were still no computers on guard duty, but there was opportunity to roleplay. This audience had little demand for overly serious play, so it could swallow the faults of many earlier solutions. Roleplaying was interesting when a player first tried it, and could still offer something new and interesting when their countdown tape measure was finally cut to its end and they were discharged. The masculine environment offered more opportunities for combat and slaughter, and nobody wanted to go too deeply into the details. 

It is clear that the generation before M.A.G.U.S. reached the barracks and the generation who discovered roleplaying there had different needs and circumstances. Those who started early know more languages and games, but are a fairly heterogeneous group nonetheless. Barracks-compatible M.A.G.U.S. brought in a new generation, as did the rise of computers, which lured away some munchkins. But 2004 was a major turning point in Hungarian roleplaying: compulsory military service ended. Discovering M.A.G.U.S. as a way to pass tedious guard duty was therefore no longer on the cards. 

The conscript often wanted to win, was less well read, less interested in discovering the world, and not necessarily an inquisitive sort who would read a thick book for the sake of a subject that interested them; the munchkin style of play therefore spread widely. By today, however, quite a few details have changed. Today, roleplaying attracts someone interested enough to tackle a thick book's worth of learning and capable of understanding it, someone for whom roleplaying offers something that computer games and cards do not. And here, a promise of freedom is not enough if it remains merely a promise. 

The system was neither appreciably more nor less consistent than its predecessors. Its advancement model was interesting in character creation and provided some freedom, but skills worked very differently. That was a disadvantage for freedom. Moreover, many elements aimed at balance and challenge introduced the familiar d20 concept of builds here too: "the necessary self-restriction to choosing among effective templates in order to achieve the expected effectiveness." 

Ratings:

  • Completeness of setting description: 6/10
  • Consistency of setting description: 7/10
  • Interest of setting description: 7/10
  • Freedom in character creation: 8/10
  • Game balance: 6/10
  • Consistency of the system: 8/10
  • Literary background: 7/10
  • Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 2/10
  • Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 3/10
  • Execution: 4/10
  • Total: 58%