Article Index

Summarium: the unfinished project?

Frankly, Summarium's failure was a foregone conclusion. We can talk about how often it contradicts even itself, or how poorly it uses the space available. About how what they wanted to call a more grown-up system and worldview is a bit like a ten-year-old acting grown-up because, while Daddy was not looking, he watched two horror movies all the way through, but has wet the bed every night since. For heaven's sake: an adult can say they have a hobby, a leisure activity they know something about. If they want to stay mentally active outside work, they will certainly demand more both of themselves and of the system. Neither the hastily assembled "let's have five levels," nor a system devised around power words, nor flirting with horror amounted to progress.

But the direction of development, treating horror as a "step forward," and many other little things were not the problem. Oh, no. Even if it rewrote history and the setting, it could still have been a good dark fantasy/horror game worthy of praise. And if games set on Ynev, with different moods and correspondingly different systems, had competed for our favor, I think I can fairly say we would all have been—or could have been—happy. That was not the problem. It would not even have mattered much if Summarium's system had been awful. Most people would not have switched to it. The problem was time passing. Summarium's first volume appeared in 1996. By then computer games influenced the market so much that Diablo had already appeared. In fact, work had even begun on adapting its world as an AD&D supplement. 

And roleplaying rests on immersion; Doom and Quake approached precisely that immersion from another angle, likewise through darker worlds. By then their creators were also in serious disagreement, and Romero was heading straight for Daikatana. Yes, he was a roleplayer too—according to legend, a real munchkin—and the associated "power fantasy," imagining himself immensely powerful, led him toward roleplaying, star affectations, and his successes with Doom alike. And '96 was the year of Quake, whose title, malicious tongues say, came from an overpowered barbarian. The spirit of the times had changed. 

Previously, if little Stevie wanted to feel like a great warrior slaughtering monsters, he made a ridiculously overpowered AD&D or M.A.G.U.S. character, and you could always find people for that sort of adventure. After Diablo, little Stevie felt that he could slaughter more monsters per unit of time in Diablo, without all that reading. Nor was a game being "grown-up horror," like Doom or Diablo, a reason to switch: it did not make little Stevie feel like any bigger a boy than clicking his mouse did. Sorry, but at this point you either had to promise more exciting battles and sweeter victories—the direction D&D took—or say that you were serving lovers of the literature and the setting. In that case, contradicting beloved elements of the setting because of personal disputes was hardly wise. Plenty of new novels and descriptions of undeveloped regions would have mattered much more. 

Then came 1997, with promises still flowing that Summarium II was coming, but in the meantime we received a First Rulebook. And, for example, Grand Theft Auto. Quake II. Dungeon Keeper, which attracted many roleplayers then and which many still revisit nostalgically today. Meanwhile, Ultima Online ushered in the MMO era. The spread of the Internet launched another part of the "geek revolution" that could have been responded to. And what was happening around M.A.G.U.S.?

Promises. Promises from guys who had already missed deadlines before, who had written excellent stories as authors—the publisher claimed at the time that these were based on other people's games—but had never been productive. Their supposedly imperishable achievements were always counterbalanced by the fact that deadlines often slipped because of them, things did not get finished, and neither did the Summarium project. The identity was lost, and contradictory writing may have bothered many people, but the worst part was that they took the system's fate into their own hands and produced very little worthwhile work. Still, let us try to assess that little.

M.A.G.U.S. — Summarium

Strengths Weaknesses
  • A literary background
  • The reworked orcs are atmospheric
  • The setting description expanded a little
  • A source for legends and worldviews
  • The setting description is still incomplete
  • A half-finished system
  • It contradicts itself (on od)
  • Reworking the races overturns many things; the result contradicts Ynev's known history
  • No well-considered underlying system
  • Much content that "ideally you will never use anyway"
  • Overturning the previous adventurer-centered, human-centered concept
  • Ignoring demand for a usable core book
  • No sensible deadline
Opportunities Threats
  • Missing details are easy to fill in
  • Parts of it may be adopted

I make no secret of it: I do not like Summarium. But I also make little secret of the fact that I nevertheless use much of it. However much the book contradicts even itself, much of it is supposedly a "source work": this person on Ynev thinks this or that about these races. Much of it clashes with the previously described history? So what? News sung by bards will not be particularly accurate even two villages away. Most of Summarium's system was left out, and what it does contain is largely in the nonsensical category.

I have explained many times why its description of power words is nonsense. If every language can express everything, and all of them come into existence, then the four languages described there serve no purpose. From that point on, you cannot run the system without the contradiction potentially becoming disruptive. Not because I would give a PC od, but because they may encounter an NPC capable of using power words. In many respects, the balance of power clashes with the previously described history and with M.A.G.U.S.'s more human-centered concept. This certainly is not good as it stands.

Of course, I have a different concept of power words. It can come into play if the group asks. But fundamentally, I think the intention that power words and aquirs should rarely appear, because that is not what they are for, deserves respect. If they rarely appear, however, I find it quite unnecessary to devote a nice long chapter to them while things used every day are missing. Time is largely spent on an almost pointless, self-contradictory patchwork, while players wait in vain for so many things. Many supplements could have appeared in that time. It is no secret: one of my favorite games is Shadowrun. In the same amount of time, Shadowrun Third Edition accumulated a whole little library. 

People who had not been particularly productive before, to M.A.G.U.S.'s detriment, gained a decisive role during this period, and it is hardly surprising that they were no more productive then. A visibly ill-considered creation that contradicted itself and still divided the community represented a conspicuous worsening of earlier problems. Nor could this be a more "grown-up" version in the sense of a well-considered, corrected system that had outgrown its teething troubles: at the outset of the project, nobody even tried to think Summarium through thoroughly and soberly. 

Ratings:

  • Completeness of setting description: 6/10
  • Consistency of setting description: 4/10
  • Interest of setting description: 7/10
  • Freedom in character creation: 0/10
  • Game balance: 0/10
  • Consistency of the system: 0/10
  • Literary background: 7/10
  • Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 5/10
  • Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 5/10
  • Execution: 3/10
  • Total: 37%