Contradictory writing in supplements
Once again, there will not be many tables or scores, because the range stretching from the two Priests, Paladins volumes through Enoszuke and Geoframia to the Northern Alliance is difficult to assess, whether separately or lumped together. It includes some highly atmospheric books, such as the Toron supplement. It would be difficult not to praise it, or not to say, "This is what has been missing all along." But I also have to say, "It came a little late," and ask where we stand when nobody knows who plays that country in what way, and the all-too-obvious borrowing in Geoframia and, partly, Enoszuke has put many people off. One swallow does not make a summer. Numerous areas are still only sketched out. However glad I am to see Toron, however much one can appreciate the work invested in it, and however much is known about what was finished when, the overall picture has not changed much.
Meanwhile, teams assembled from here and there released the two Priests, Paladins supplements. These managed to redefine many Second Rulebook skills in ways that both changed them and did not. They decided to insert od into the existing system, where it had not officially existed before. They produced an Ellana priestess optimized for combat, while occasionally explaining that these priestesses do not learn to fight, and which master-level weapon skill is unnecessary. Let me tell you: someone who does not learn to fight would receive combat values below a priest's basic values, and would not even gain basic weapon skills beyond the priest's basic skills. If she does receive them, however, you must address how that affects the world.
Regarding the latter supplement, let me ask: if the esteemed official author thinks so little about the consequences of what they write, much of their work is plainly overpowered, and—since everyone has been contradicting everyone else all along—those ideas could easily be discarded in a revision, how useful a foundation does it provide? You could call it a solid basis for everyone to play the same way, but M.A.G.U.S. is no longer unified. If we have to agree on things either way and there is no common foundation, the value of such works is questionable.
That is precisely the main problem: if a significant share of an already small body of work fails to meet the standard, we must ask how worthwhile it is to overturn a consistently run world and begin the work again for the sake of the occasional good book that might also fill a gap. However admirable a supplement's attractive, good, inventive, atmospheric but incompatible vision of the world may be, we have to ask. And it would be damned unfair, after all the contradictory writing in the new supplements, to dismiss the results as "too little, too late," say that the system now shaped by them has not become much better on the market, yet point out that much time has passed and it now lags significantly behind.
Since I am not reviewing each supplement separately, but would merely examine what the system became with them included, if they changed it at all, the overall picture would remain similar. The otherwise interesting Toron supplement would be at a serious disadvantage because it appeared late. I therefore have to settle for saying that this trend, taken as a whole, harmed M.A.G.U.S.