Article Index

M.A.G.U.S. — Once upon a time—or perhaps not?

Our story branches in two here. We could discuss how the two volumes of Priests, Paladins, Geoframia, Enoszuke, and many other official or unauthorized publications contradict the setting and affect the system. You could say that came first, since it dates to 1999. But the Northern Alliance came later. There is much to say about these, but what matters far more is that by 1999 M.A.G.U.S. had been revamped several times while very few useful supplements had appeared. Yet we had still not arrived at a substantive concept responding to the new editions. Once again, though, they managed to find some surprisingly peculiar people.

For example, someone responded to an argument invoking a pyramid diagram of social stratification and the way its layers build on one another—every history textbook had one in those days—by declaring that it was not a pyramid but a Gaussian curve. Well, no. A Gaussian curve concerns natural distribution and the way, for example, human height is determined by many "random" factors, such as genes and environmental influences. A pyramid diagram, by contrast, concerns fixed, regulated proportions between layers, with advancement also defined.

Promotion is one real-life example. Let us say there will always be fewer sergeants than the recruits they train. And fewer generals still, right? Well, someone who thinks this does not function as a pyramid of layers building on one another, but as a Gaussian curve with lots of people in the middle layer, is an idiot. As are those who lavishly licked his boots and agreed with him as a creator on the forum hosting the debate. But that is not the problem. The problem is that, for example, one basic premise was that they did not want idea magic, given the familiar situation. They also repeatedly said that M.A.G.U.S.'s creators were idiots and there was no need to understand what they had written or why.

The main problem is that M.A.G.U.S. was nevertheless the market-leading system for a while, and they had to solve many things to achieve that. More important still: a new M.A.G.U.S. edition is being made largely for people who liked the old one. If someone loudly calls that old game shit and has no interest in understanding why those people like it, how exactly will their new solution suit those players? And if they just want to use the logo to sell something you would not otherwise buy, that is hardly a nice way to do things.

If I had to score it, then with nothing published, what they delivered amounts to precisely zero. Against that stands the wasted time, and here it matters that the d20 System was born during this period. When we eventually assess the M.A.G.U.S. version built on it, and I have to conclude that it arrived too late, failed to exploit many of d20's advantages, and so on, that late arrival will not be the d20 team's fault. 

Squandered opportunities and ignoring changes in the market matter too, but the story does not end there. I know there is little point belaboring it, because some things cannot get any worse... But this still managed to erode M.A.G.U.S.'s reputation and market share.