M.A.G.U.S. — The First Rulebook
Hooray! The First Rulebook solved the chronic shortage of core books and remained largely compatible with the system. Of course, Max is sorely missed; the illustrations are awful. Once again, entire tables are missing from the system. Understandably, the quality of the changes did not improve, and had little room to deteriorate further, so the book largely delivered what could be expected. Anyone familiar with M.A.G.U.S. generally knows this edition too, so I need say relatively little about it. Except, perhaps, that its writers failed to ask themselves even basic questions.
For example: the description of a witch's spell of union says the witch acquires an animal body... Then it says the only obstacle to stealing a human body is the two magic resistance checks. Yet it fails to consider that these do nothing to protect a peasant girl. Nobody thought through how a witch would function in a male body. Nor did they address regeneration/the water of life, which would be a major undertaking for a witch sect working in a circle, but not an impossible one. Another question is missing: what happens if one body wants to sleep? Does the other body need to sleep too? And many other little details are absent.
Why does a martial artist need more weapon skills than an assassin? Many martial artists use no weapons at all, whereas an assassin is trained to use any weapon... The questions could go on, and we can weigh up what to do about them.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — First Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
The picture above is not very positive, but the decline compared with what came before is not large. Many new rules can easily be ignored, and some of the questions raised can be answered. Many new spells, however, are good additions, and useful items have been added to the equipment list too. So we can also say it is worth putting alongside the earlier books. We can also say that it gave many groups the opportunity to start, with M.A.G.U.S. sessions thriving in countless barracks. Without it, the community would not be this large today.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 5/10
- Consistency of setting description: 7/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 4/10
- Consistency of the system: 5/10
- Literary background: 6/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
- Execution: 3/10
- Total: 61%