Contrary to the claims still being loudly repeated, M.A.G.U.S. was only the second roleplaying game published in Hungarian; the first was a game released in two booklets as Harc és Varázslat. Yet M.A.G.U.S. has remained one of the defining players in the market ever since, and many people see the brand as a real cash cow. The question is why. And just as importantly, why can the devotees of its different editions not agree on so many fundamental questions? Our story begins in 1993, with the publication of the first edition of M.A.G.U.S.
M.A.G.U.S. — The first edition
Many people have tried many times to compare the numerous editions that make up the history of M.A.G.U.S. Most of those making the comparisons had never really familiarized themselves with the editions in question. And trying them out is not the only criterion; exchanging a few words with their creators is not enough either. You also need to know the circumstances in which they appeared. M.A.G.U.S. owed its publication to the fact that an AD&D translation could not be published. The available choices on the market were photocopied pirate translations of AD&D, Harc és Varázslat, and systems in foreign languages. Alongside M.A.G.U.S. there was a promise of Middle-earth Role Playing, but that appeared later and could therefore only compete with subsequent editions.
M.A.G.U.S. was thus almost alone in the market, at a time when the spread of fantasy literature, social changes, and a host of other little things already created favorable conditions for the system. You might say it was in the right place at the right time. But it also responded well to that favorable situation, although of course this does not mean a score of 100%. Many of its shortcomings and weaknesses are familiar enough. Some of its printing errors fundamentally affected the book's usability: it would be difficult to create a player character in the warrior main class, for example, if the method for rolling Astral were missing.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — First edition | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
Looking through the overview above, it is easy to see how the first edition of M.A.G.U.S. won over so many players. It had advantages that every M.A.G.U.S. player now takes for granted, but its incomplete setting description was already a drawback then. I do not just mean the blank spots, but the solutions carelessly tossed in without much thought in so many places. Everyone has come to imagine Toron differently since then. But the descriptions of many other regions have changed too. Areas left to the GM, the blank spots, offered good opportunities, as did descriptions whose connections the GM had to recognize for themselves; nevertheless, many shortcomings made it inevitable that errors would be corrected.
It soon became clear in the system that adventurers were stronger than the average person, and Nyul certainly had thought the system through as far as his earlier research and ideas allowed; games had been run in the setting too. But we can be quite certain that M.A.G.U.S. was rushed into print: a little care would have caught its serious printing errors. Of course, the book sold out anyway, and Rúna supplied the missing details. The game was more true to life than AD&D, beginning characters died less often, writing a backstory was more worthwhile, and players therefore put more emphasis on roleplaying. In the evolution of roleplaying games, this was a step in keeping with the spirit of the times. Every innovation supported it. At the same time, the possibility of an overwhelming hit meant there was still reason to fear for your character even at high levels.
Although many people made the M.A.G.U.S. core book the grand prize in AD&D "powergaming championships," since first-level characters were less vulnerable here and later on, thanks to overwhelming hits, it was easier to kill instantly, a general consensus soon formed that M.A.G.U.S. was a decidedly good game. That gave it enough active players that anyone who wanted to play could easily find a group. And plenty of available opportunities to play is something we would expect from a widely known system, and one of its defining assets.
As for freedom in character creation, characters in this system can be customized more than in the AD&D commonly played at the time, for example, but in this respect M.A.G.U.S. lagged behind both Rolemaster, another class-and-level system, and BRP, which defined character types. The main idea was that something available within the setting—a character studying at a particular place—should be possible to create, subject to its requirements. The system assumes that training in many places is complex enough that less adequate training would simply "not add up to first experience level," so this restriction on PC classes is justified within the setting. If we take that approach, the system hardly restricts us. One substantial restriction is that a higher starting age does not bring additional skills.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 5/10
- Consistency of setting description: 7/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 5/10
- Consistency of the system: 8/10
- Literary background: 7/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
- Execution: 4/10
- Total: 67%
Second and third editions
Two new editions appeared in 1994, doing nothing more than correcting errors. At the same time, numerous questions arose, and as we know, there is no accounting for taste... many people wanted many little things done differently, so a push for reform began. Needless to say, the system's structure did not change along with this, but its market position did: Middle-earth Role Playing came out in the meantime, for example, and the conflict with Bíborhold turned bitter. It is worth recognizing that this kind of warfare was already part of the M.A.G.U.S. scene and the character of many of its creators. In this new situation, roleplaying became much more mainstream.
Meanwhile, two other important changes were happening in the world. When Windows 95 came out, many people still joked about the number of installation disks, but the situation had nevertheless changed by then. You only needed one CD. And CD-ROM and CD-R partly settled the contest between PCs, Amigas, and other computers specifically intended for home use. On the one hand, many people saw a PC as a replacement for a separate CD player; on the other, once CD-R spread, you could compile your own music collections. PCs also suddenly became competitive in multimedia capabilities. More and more people could thus discover computer games and computer RPGs. And István Veér may well have preferred the easier victories available on a computer.
But however much the world was changing, a corrected reprint meeting customers' needs could not respond to these developments. The second and third editions of M.A.G.U.S. could therefore deliver exactly as much as they did. We could be happy with that. Addressing many of the shortcomings should instead have been the job of the eagerly awaited supplements. Their absence is all too familiar, but unfortunately it is not a phenomenon specific to any one edition.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — Second and third editions | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
It is clear that although execution improved in many respects, the increasingly legendary delays to supplements and novels did almost as much harm as the early printing errors, which could still be easily corrected or filled in. Meanwhile, Rúna often published answers of dubious value to questions and criticisms, with little time devoted to thinking many solutions through. This did not necessarily affect the system itself, since Rúna was not that decisive an influence, but it was nevertheless a warning sign and a reason for caution. The Bestiary fundamentally stirred things up. XP awards were handled differently, so even where its balance of power was well conceived, many people failed to adjust to it. No explanation was devised for why anyone would summon a weaker demon. In a world that had been human-centered in both its literature and its underlying concept, monsters suddenly became much more important.
Although Két Hold also brought heroes of a more human scale into M.A.G.U.S., the Aun adventurer set a dangerous precedent: from then on, the question of what would be accepted in a city no longer arose... Meanwhile, an attempt to break into the music industry also tied up the publisher's resources. An album associated with Két Hold was released, showcasing singer Lilla Vincze's work. And if that were not enough, the debut material of Carpe Diem, one of the successful bands of the 1990s, was also part of this music project. Consequently, one issue of Rúna came with a cassette.
And meanwhile, some players received their draft notices. Compulsory military service helped M.A.G.U.S. spread. On guard duty you could not use a computer, play soccer, or even party. Discipline in the army was not as relaxed as in the TV series Angyalbőrben, either. Boring guard duty, peeling potatoes, and so on needed something to liven them up. If a soldier knew the rules and their character's important statistics by heart, there was plenty of opportunity to play. So the game spread among soldiers and border guards.
I might add that, according to malicious tongues, today's contract personnel are not necessarily unfamiliar with livening up tedious guard duty in this way either. The game thus became fairly mainstream. Those who had played before and took worldbuilding and life-spanning campaigns a little more seriously naturally expected something different from Private Kovács II, the infantryman who wanted to spend guard duty slaughtering the Bestiary's monsters—in XP order, page order, or alphabetical order. Any resemblance between the name of the orc he was about to beat up and his sergeant's was purely coincidental.
If we include the Bestiary's minor contradictions but do not consider Rúna a determining factor, this is how M.A.G.U.S. should be rated at this point:
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 6/10
- Consistency of setting description: 5/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 5/10
- Consistency of the system: 8/10
- Literary background: 7/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
- Execution: 7/10
- Total: 70%
M.A.G.U.S. — Was 2.0 in the works?
There are all sorts of legends about what happened around the publication of the Second Rulebook, and how. One thing is certain: the M.A.G.U.S. creative team fell apart afterward. Another certainty is that many of the rules did not first appear there. And Csanád Novák, who was often inclined to agree with fan material, promised to adopt many ideas; he was also the one thinking about the deadline. Anyone who has held the CODEX core book and its Grimoire supplement, and knows that they were originally intended as a revised edition of M.A.G.U.S.—and that this revamped M.A.G.U.S. edition was originally supposed to be called the Second Rulebook—may begin to suspect that the Second Rulebook was only thrown together at the very last moment, or even later.
Perhaps largely out of defiance: "Here you go, Csanád, this is what something cobbled together from fan material looks like." On the one hand, it is a fact that many of the book's innovations are still widely used. On the other, the community would never dream of using many of its other innovations, so its reputation remains debatable. The Khál issue hit even harder at the time. Rúna was already dying. CODEX turned out better, but by then it was very far from alone in the market, and language was no longer such a major advantage. Frankly, though, even a perfect system reform would not have accomplished much: the parts of the M.A.G.U.S. system that existed could be better in many respects than most of its direct competitors. Even a moderately good explanation would have sufficed to deal with the disputed questions...
The problem that needed addressing was not corrections, but filling the enormous missing sections. Yet we had reached a situation where reform of the system was entrusted to one developer, while it remained unclear who would produce a substantial range of meaningful supplements. Or at least adventure modules featuring the occasional new spell or magic item. And I would venture to suggest that maps, brief descriptions, and the like would not necessarily have been difficult to publish. Descriptions of countries, either. Meanwhile, though, we could wait years for a promised novel: it soon became clear that the writing team was not particularly productive.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — With the Second Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
Looking at it, you notice that few people worked on filling in the missing details, even though there was plenty to flesh out. The question is whose responsibility that was. It would be easy to say the system had a lead designer, but he could primarily work on the countries where he ran games. Moreover, you cannot expect both that and system reform at the same time. The fact that the Second Rulebook had to appear in this half-finished, partly cobbled-together form was primarily because there was nothing else. Novels were late too; Rúna could not be filled with content, short stories could not make up for it, and there was little idea of what to fill with what. Meanwhile, some of the less productive members of the team wanted to borrow all sorts of things from here and there. People who merely interfered without producing much themselves held up the system reform.
The opportunities remained opportunities, unused. The problem was not that there were blank spots. Those let many GMs build their own city-states. A much bigger problem was that numerous other countries had not been fleshed out either. And even since then, contradicting Nyul's conception of Krán has remained more important than providing a proper description of a few major states of the Pyarronian Confederation, for instance. Meanwhile, numerous other roleplaying games had become available, and fewer and fewer people were frightened by a setting description or rulebook in English. The details that the creators still owe us had already become painfully conspicuous omissions by then.
Some of the new races created still more unanswered questions concerning player characters, questions that have no credible, precise answer to this day. But it cannot be said often enough: the Second Rulebook was a symptom of M.A.G.U.S.'s problems at the time, not their cause. Had the writing team been productive, had there been country descriptions, adventures, maps, many kinds of publications, and a thriving M.A.G.U.S. with plenty of fans getting good answers, it would not have seemed a matter of survival to publish a Second Rulebook that was half-finished in many respects and still had to satisfy a wish list. All right: let me not be unfair. Warriors, Barbarians, Gladiators came out too.
Many people talk about its "overpowered" classes—the Sirenar ranger is one example—its skills, and this and that, but these are not the important faults. What matters is that the gaps that should have been filled with content between the start of the M.A.G.U.S. project and this point remained largely untouched. It did manage to overturn the relationship between warriors and soldiers, however, and to launch the distinctly less-than-noble tradition of "characters starting with lunír weapons." It is strange that even the setting description of CODEX, published after the split, is better thought out and more complete...
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 4/10
- Consistency of setting description: 6/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 4/10
- Consistency of the system: 6/10
- Literary background: 6/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 6/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 7/10
- Execution: 5/10
- Total: 59%
Summarium: the unfinished project?
Frankly, Summarium's failure was a foregone conclusion. We can talk about how often it contradicts even itself, or how poorly it uses the space available. About how what they wanted to call a more grown-up system and worldview is a bit like a ten-year-old acting grown-up because, while Daddy was not looking, he watched two horror movies all the way through, but has wet the bed every night since. For heaven's sake: an adult can say they have a hobby, a leisure activity they know something about. If they want to stay mentally active outside work, they will certainly demand more both of themselves and of the system. Neither the hastily assembled "let's have five levels," nor a system devised around power words, nor flirting with horror amounted to progress.
But the direction of development, treating horror as a "step forward," and many other little things were not the problem. Oh, no. Even if it rewrote history and the setting, it could still have been a good dark fantasy/horror game worthy of praise. And if games set on Ynev, with different moods and correspondingly different systems, had competed for our favor, I think I can fairly say we would all have been—or could have been—happy. That was not the problem. It would not even have mattered much if Summarium's system had been awful. Most people would not have switched to it. The problem was time passing. Summarium's first volume appeared in 1996. By then computer games influenced the market so much that Diablo had already appeared. In fact, work had even begun on adapting its world as an AD&D supplement.
And roleplaying rests on immersion; Doom and Quake approached precisely that immersion from another angle, likewise through darker worlds. By then their creators were also in serious disagreement, and Romero was heading straight for Daikatana. Yes, he was a roleplayer too—according to legend, a real munchkin—and the associated "power fantasy," imagining himself immensely powerful, led him toward roleplaying, star affectations, and his successes with Doom alike. And '96 was the year of Quake, whose title, malicious tongues say, came from an overpowered barbarian. The spirit of the times had changed.
Previously, if little Stevie wanted to feel like a great warrior slaughtering monsters, he made a ridiculously overpowered AD&D or M.A.G.U.S. character, and you could always find people for that sort of adventure. After Diablo, little Stevie felt that he could slaughter more monsters per unit of time in Diablo, without all that reading. Nor was a game being "grown-up horror," like Doom or Diablo, a reason to switch: it did not make little Stevie feel like any bigger a boy than clicking his mouse did. Sorry, but at this point you either had to promise more exciting battles and sweeter victories—the direction D&D took—or say that you were serving lovers of the literature and the setting. In that case, contradicting beloved elements of the setting because of personal disputes was hardly wise. Plenty of new novels and descriptions of undeveloped regions would have mattered much more.
Then came 1997, with promises still flowing that Summarium II was coming, but in the meantime we received a First Rulebook. And, for example, Grand Theft Auto. Quake II. Dungeon Keeper, which attracted many roleplayers then and which many still revisit nostalgically today. Meanwhile, Ultima Online ushered in the MMO era. The spread of the Internet launched another part of the "geek revolution" that could have been responded to. And what was happening around M.A.G.U.S.?
Promises. Promises from guys who had already missed deadlines before, who had written excellent stories as authors—the publisher claimed at the time that these were based on other people's games—but had never been productive. Their supposedly imperishable achievements were always counterbalanced by the fact that deadlines often slipped because of them, things did not get finished, and neither did the Summarium project. The identity was lost, and contradictory writing may have bothered many people, but the worst part was that they took the system's fate into their own hands and produced very little worthwhile work. Still, let us try to assess that little.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — Summarium | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
I make no secret of it: I do not like Summarium. But I also make little secret of the fact that I nevertheless use much of it. However much the book contradicts even itself, much of it is supposedly a "source work": this person on Ynev thinks this or that about these races. Much of it clashes with the previously described history? So what? News sung by bards will not be particularly accurate even two villages away. Most of Summarium's system was left out, and what it does contain is largely in the nonsensical category.
I have explained many times why its description of power words is nonsense. If every language can express everything, and all of them come into existence, then the four languages described there serve no purpose. From that point on, you cannot run the system without the contradiction potentially becoming disruptive. Not because I would give a PC od, but because they may encounter an NPC capable of using power words. In many respects, the balance of power clashes with the previously described history and with M.A.G.U.S.'s more human-centered concept. This certainly is not good as it stands.
Of course, I have a different concept of power words. It can come into play if the group asks. But fundamentally, I think the intention that power words and aquirs should rarely appear, because that is not what they are for, deserves respect. If they rarely appear, however, I find it quite unnecessary to devote a nice long chapter to them while things used every day are missing. Time is largely spent on an almost pointless, self-contradictory patchwork, while players wait in vain for so many things. Many supplements could have appeared in that time. It is no secret: one of my favorite games is Shadowrun. In the same amount of time, Shadowrun Third Edition accumulated a whole little library.
People who had not been particularly productive before, to M.A.G.U.S.'s detriment, gained a decisive role during this period, and it is hardly surprising that they were no more productive then. A visibly ill-considered creation that contradicted itself and still divided the community represented a conspicuous worsening of earlier problems. Nor could this be a more "grown-up" version in the sense of a well-considered, corrected system that had outgrown its teething troubles: at the outset of the project, nobody even tried to think Summarium through thoroughly and soberly.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 6/10
- Consistency of setting description: 4/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 0/10
- Game balance: 0/10
- Consistency of the system: 0/10
- Literary background: 7/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 5/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 5/10
- Execution: 3/10
- Total: 37%
M.A.G.U.S. — The First Rulebook
Hooray! The First Rulebook solved the chronic shortage of core books and remained largely compatible with the system. Of course, Max is sorely missed; the illustrations are awful. Once again, entire tables are missing from the system. Understandably, the quality of the changes did not improve, and had little room to deteriorate further, so the book largely delivered what could be expected. Anyone familiar with M.A.G.U.S. generally knows this edition too, so I need say relatively little about it. Except, perhaps, that its writers failed to ask themselves even basic questions.
For example: the description of a witch's spell of union says the witch acquires an animal body... Then it says the only obstacle to stealing a human body is the two magic resistance checks. Yet it fails to consider that these do nothing to protect a peasant girl. Nobody thought through how a witch would function in a male body. Nor did they address regeneration/the water of life, which would be a major undertaking for a witch sect working in a circle, but not an impossible one. Another question is missing: what happens if one body wants to sleep? Does the other body need to sleep too? And many other little details are absent.
Why does a martial artist need more weapon skills than an assassin? Many martial artists use no weapons at all, whereas an assassin is trained to use any weapon... The questions could go on, and we can weigh up what to do about them.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — First Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
The picture above is not very positive, but the decline compared with what came before is not large. Many new rules can easily be ignored, and some of the questions raised can be answered. Many new spells, however, are good additions, and useful items have been added to the equipment list too. So we can also say it is worth putting alongside the earlier books. We can also say that it gave many groups the opportunity to start, with M.A.G.U.S. sessions thriving in countless barracks. Without it, the community would not be this large today.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 5/10
- Consistency of setting description: 7/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 4/10
- Consistency of the system: 5/10
- Literary background: 6/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
- Execution: 3/10
- Total: 61%
M.A.G.U.S. — New Scrolls
A worthy spiritual successor to the Summarium project. They managed to decide it could not be combined with the old system, but provided no new descriptions for the old races. They devised a new form of magic with no description. And many skills cannot be taken anyway because circular prerequisites forbid it. Many other little details about the system are legendary too. We are in 1999. Meanwhile, the world of computer RPGs has seen the arrival of Planescape: Torment, one of the most atmospheric and interesting computer roleplaying games of all time. Why does that matter? For several reasons.
The recurring complaint so far is still that the world is not developed even where it should be. Its lore, so to speak, is incomplete. By this time, however, an increasing proportion of players are already playing computer RPGs before they discover tabletop roleplaying. Although EverQuest is already around, spreading the MMO era further, that is not a decisive factor here in Hungary. Many players grow accustomed even in the simplest CRPGs to plentiful lore, with developers spoiling them with more and more text and story. That can be decisive in shaping the spirit of the times.
We say tabletop roleplaying is the real thing. Players' freedom and the ever greater detail they can discover are what make it offer more than a computer game. Then we reach a point where game balance, the group concept, and many other expectations leave them choosing between a handful of builds in either one. At the table, they rarely stray from the adventure either, because the others are not going that way. They do not feel the freedom, but they notice the missing lore. Alongside the dungeon-crawling power fantasy, lore became the other selling point. Although many tabletop RPGs build on classic dungeon crawls, hordes of slaughtered monsters, and the classic power fantasy, the game industry's other watchword is lore.
And somewhere in all this stands M.A.G.U.S., with incomplete lore, freedom sacrificed in many areas on the altar of balance, and an unnecessarily cumbersome system... Oh, and no powergaming: we are not competing in the power-fantasy league either. Then where are we competing? Contradictory writing is undermining M.A.G.U.S.'s traditional strengths. And yes, the lore is missing too.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — New Scrolls | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
New Scrolls is thus a system that is not even half finished, largely an amateur elaboration of Summarium. Fundamentally, though, it is clear that the original creative team brought in outside help here too: amateurs who introduced amateur mistakes. Recruiting from the fans has continued ever since. But apparently it is important that, alongside them, the system's custodians at the center remain the people who have so far mainly contributed novels or seriously undermined the whole thing. At this point we are entitled to ask: yes, they have written the occasional novel that could hold its own even internationally, but might we have been better off with writers of average ability, hired writers who did not undermine the game, were productive, and did not deceive us? We may begin to feel that M.A.G.U.S. would have been better off without a few famous authors, and that it would have gone further if good work rather than obedient nodding had been the standard.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 6/10
- Consistency of setting description: 3/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 4/10
- Game balance: 3/10
- Consistency of the system: 5/10
- Literary background: 6/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 5/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 3/10
- Execution: 3/10
- Total: 45%
M.A.G.U.S. — Once upon a time—or perhaps not?
Our story branches in two here. We could discuss how the two volumes of Priests, Paladins, Geoframia, Enoszuke, and many other official or unauthorized publications contradict the setting and affect the system. You could say that came first, since it dates to 1999. But the Northern Alliance came later. There is much to say about these, but what matters far more is that by 1999 M.A.G.U.S. had been revamped several times while very few useful supplements had appeared. Yet we had still not arrived at a substantive concept responding to the new editions. Once again, though, they managed to find some surprisingly peculiar people.
For example, someone responded to an argument invoking a pyramid diagram of social stratification and the way its layers build on one another—every history textbook had one in those days—by declaring that it was not a pyramid but a Gaussian curve. Well, no. A Gaussian curve concerns natural distribution and the way, for example, human height is determined by many "random" factors, such as genes and environmental influences. A pyramid diagram, by contrast, concerns fixed, regulated proportions between layers, with advancement also defined.
Promotion is one real-life example. Let us say there will always be fewer sergeants than the recruits they train. And fewer generals still, right? Well, someone who thinks this does not function as a pyramid of layers building on one another, but as a Gaussian curve with lots of people in the middle layer, is an idiot. As are those who lavishly licked his boots and agreed with him as a creator on the forum hosting the debate. But that is not the problem. The problem is that, for example, one basic premise was that they did not want idea magic, given the familiar situation. They also repeatedly said that M.A.G.U.S.'s creators were idiots and there was no need to understand what they had written or why.
The main problem is that M.A.G.U.S. was nevertheless the market-leading system for a while, and they had to solve many things to achieve that. More important still: a new M.A.G.U.S. edition is being made largely for people who liked the old one. If someone loudly calls that old game shit and has no interest in understanding why those people like it, how exactly will their new solution suit those players? And if they just want to use the logo to sell something you would not otherwise buy, that is hardly a nice way to do things.
If I had to score it, then with nothing published, what they delivered amounts to precisely zero. Against that stands the wasted time, and here it matters that the d20 System was born during this period. When we eventually assess the M.A.G.U.S. version built on it, and I have to conclude that it arrived too late, failed to exploit many of d20's advantages, and so on, that late arrival will not be the d20 team's fault.
Squandered opportunities and ignoring changes in the market matter too, but the story does not end there. I know there is little point belaboring it, because some things cannot get any worse... But this still managed to erode M.A.G.U.S.'s reputation and market share.
Contradictory writing in supplements
Once again, there will not be many tables or scores, because the range stretching from the two Priests, Paladins volumes through Enoszuke and Geoframia to the Northern Alliance is difficult to assess, whether separately or lumped together. It includes some highly atmospheric books, such as the Toron supplement. It would be difficult not to praise it, or not to say, "This is what has been missing all along." But I also have to say, "It came a little late," and ask where we stand when nobody knows who plays that country in what way, and the all-too-obvious borrowing in Geoframia and, partly, Enoszuke has put many people off. One swallow does not make a summer. Numerous areas are still only sketched out. However glad I am to see Toron, however much one can appreciate the work invested in it, and however much is known about what was finished when, the overall picture has not changed much.
Meanwhile, teams assembled from here and there released the two Priests, Paladins supplements. These managed to redefine many Second Rulebook skills in ways that both changed them and did not. They decided to insert od into the existing system, where it had not officially existed before. They produced an Ellana priestess optimized for combat, while occasionally explaining that these priestesses do not learn to fight, and which master-level weapon skill is unnecessary. Let me tell you: someone who does not learn to fight would receive combat values below a priest's basic values, and would not even gain basic weapon skills beyond the priest's basic skills. If she does receive them, however, you must address how that affects the world.
Regarding the latter supplement, let me ask: if the esteemed official author thinks so little about the consequences of what they write, much of their work is plainly overpowered, and—since everyone has been contradicting everyone else all along—those ideas could easily be discarded in a revision, how useful a foundation does it provide? You could call it a solid basis for everyone to play the same way, but M.A.G.U.S. is no longer unified. If we have to agree on things either way and there is no common foundation, the value of such works is questionable.
That is precisely the main problem: if a significant share of an already small body of work fails to meet the standard, we must ask how worthwhile it is to overturn a consistently run world and begin the work again for the sake of the occasional good book that might also fill a gap. However admirable a supplement's attractive, good, inventive, atmospheric but incompatible vision of the world may be, we have to ask. And it would be damned unfair, after all the contradictory writing in the new supplements, to dismiss the results as "too little, too late," say that the system now shaped by them has not become much better on the market, yet point out that much time has passed and it now lags significantly behind.
Since I am not reviewing each supplement separately, but would merely examine what the system became with them included, if they changed it at all, the overall picture would remain similar. The otherwise interesting Toron supplement would be at a serious disadvantage because it appeared late. I therefore have to settle for saying that this trend, taken as a whole, harmed M.A.G.U.S.
M.A.G.U.S. — The d20-based system
Our little country seems to be a superpower in roleplaying-game development. It is not just that every team is smarter than the former developer who has become an enemy; apparently even a multinational the size of Hasbro employs nothing but idiots in marketing. The professionally superbly prepared team of M.A.G.U.S. rights holders now working at Delta Vision, Inomi, and the other Hungarian interests know a thousand times better than the d20 System's creators how to use that system successfully. What a pity the market failed to appreciate this marvelous, exceptional talent, and d20-based M.A.G.U.S. was not a success. Let us say the slogan "Charge! Surprise! Flat on your face!" worked perfectly.
The d20 System was enormously popular worldwide, thanks to an open license that allowed substantial compatibility even with D&D Third Edition. This was a serious market. Many games used it to enter the international market and easily reach numerous players. The system was successful here too, and can still be called successful today, with D&D 3.x and Pathfinder both having substantial player bases. Ynev and many of M.A.G.U.S.'s achievements could have succeeded in the market surrounding d20 as well. But that did not happen.
Nor can external factors be blamed. What happened was simply that their egos were once again two or three sizes too big, and understanding just three things was beneath Delta Vision's creative team. First, why M.A.G.U.S. players had not already switched to the d20 System. Second, why so many successful games sought compatibility and access to the d20 market. Third, merely the strategy that Wizards and its parent company Hasbro had thought through for the d20 market, including how others could succeed by joining it.
Hasbro was not stupid. The shared supplement market was intended to let a supplement serve multiple worlds and games, making it easier to supply that larger market with profitable supplements. In other words, I could choose to realize almost all M.A.G.U.S.'s virtues—including ones this edition does not offer—on a d20 foundation, using available publications. The system would be compatible and international, with plenty of good supplements. Even if I do not own the setting, most interesting class concepts remain interesting without being so closely tied to that world, so instead of a fan site there is RPGnow... Or I could choose an inward-looking system with all the development team's limitations. And the system's closed nature is not primarily a matter of rules. It stems from the goal of preventing supplements usable with M.A.G.U.S. from appearing without the rights holders' consent and appropriate compensation.
This mistake leads straight back to the lack of productivity in setting descriptions, novels, and everything else. Even approved material was slow to be completed, so third-party supplements could have swept the market. The limitation lay not within Inomi's own system-development team, but in the surrounding circle of rights holders, writers, and world creators, so responsibility for its consequences is shared too. AND it remains a serious problem that proper support for Ynev could not be provided even today using an available open system, for precisely the same unchanged reasons. The people tinkering with the rules are not primarily responsible for that.
Where there is a choice between systems sharing the same foundation and serving the same world, there is no point comparing the system with earlier editions or another game. It is enough to measure it against what the d20 market offers without that particular book. And here there were few positives left, still less an easily communicated selling point. Do not misunderstand: this nevertheless remained a quite usable system...
|
M.A.G.U.S. — The d20-based attempt | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
|
The result was a foregone conclusion. Anyone who liked d20 had no need for the new book and could find faults in it. Anyone who disliked the d20 System disliked these rules from the outset. All right, there was a niche. Someone open to a more complicated system, a great deal of work and learning, yet too lazy to try books in a foreign language; who knew nobody who could help them past that obstacle; who liked d20's greater emphasis on tactics and was therefore willing to give up the finer resolution basic M.A.G.U.S. offered in many areas... Who also did not mind that few people played the system, that finding a group was difficult, and who accepted its faults just as readily as those of the others... Well, it could have suited that person. But that was not enough for market success.
Especially because the world had changed again. The MMO revolution was now complete, and groups that cared about lore and took roleplaying seriously were present on RP servers too. We could mention Neverwinter Nights and so on: computer games were increasingly strong competitors to traditional roleplaying, and the question increasingly became how a game's developer could respond to the challenges posed by that competition. This was certainly not impossible. Here in Hungary, nostalgia was not the driving force; the aim was not to bring people who remembered AD&D First Edition or the earliest D&Ds back to the table, now that the children had left home and they had time again. Many people targeted another community.
Conscripts. There were still no computers on guard duty, but there was opportunity to roleplay. This audience had little demand for overly serious play, so it could swallow the faults of many earlier solutions. Roleplaying was interesting when a player first tried it, and could still offer something new and interesting when their countdown tape measure was finally cut to its end and they were discharged. The masculine environment offered more opportunities for combat and slaughter, and nobody wanted to go too deeply into the details.
It is clear that the generation before M.A.G.U.S. reached the barracks and the generation who discovered roleplaying there had different needs and circumstances. Those who started early know more languages and games, but are a fairly heterogeneous group nonetheless. Barracks-compatible M.A.G.U.S. brought in a new generation, as did the rise of computers, which lured away some munchkins. But 2004 was a major turning point in Hungarian roleplaying: compulsory military service ended. Discovering M.A.G.U.S. as a way to pass tedious guard duty was therefore no longer on the cards.
The conscript often wanted to win, was less well read, less interested in discovering the world, and not necessarily an inquisitive sort who would read a thick book for the sake of a subject that interested them; the munchkin style of play therefore spread widely. By today, however, quite a few details have changed. Today, roleplaying attracts someone interested enough to tackle a thick book's worth of learning and capable of understanding it, someone for whom roleplaying offers something that computer games and cards do not. And here, a promise of freedom is not enough if it remains merely a promise.
The system was neither appreciably more nor less consistent than its predecessors. Its advancement model was interesting in character creation and provided some freedom, but skills worked very differently. That was a disadvantage for freedom. Moreover, many elements aimed at balance and challenge introduced the familiar d20 concept of builds here too: "the necessary self-restriction to choosing among effective templates in order to achieve the expected effectiveness."
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 6/10
- Consistency of setting description: 7/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 6/10
- Consistency of the system: 8/10
- Literary background: 7/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 2/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 3/10
- Execution: 4/10
- Total: 58%
M.A.G.U.S. — The New Rulebook
I make no secret of it: the New Rulebook will be both the best and the worst of the editions and attempts so far. The best because there are sensible people behind it, so we can expect them to listen to feedback. Much of what they have done could even be attractive, with problems large and small. Some problems are terribly subjective; others are objective. For instance, a representative of the publisher does not accompany every copy sold. It therefore does not necessarily help if three minutes of conversation reveal how one of the publisher's people would interpret a particular rule.
Grace points are one such issue. Many players and game masters interpret them to mean that, because they are not mana points, Destruction does not affect the spell in question. The head of the publisher behind ÚTK interprets it differently: he believes Destruction would indeed affect that spell too. We know from Ynev's history that gods can be defeated—more than one manifestation has met that fate—Ranagol teaches it too, and the solid arguments go on. There is also something called the ancient pact, which cannot be circumvented by a prayer or request, so this certainly cannot be the god's own creative and destructive power.
But which interpretation is decisive? The correct one also used by the publisher's head, or the one that overturns Ynev's history and that many defend on grounds of atmosphere? Obviously, whichever the player encounters more often, and the head of the publisher rarely sits at the table. It is not good for questions like this to interrupt play, so points come off regardless of the solution. I know: errata, the publisher's many plans, or a possible second edition of ÚTK would immediately solve this. But there is no second edition, the errata fail to reach many places, and the question can interrupt play even with them.
Nor is this the only case. There are many other little issues for which the publisher surely has an appealing solution, except that players do not play that way. A wizard learns every mosaic, but struggles to use them under pressure because it is hard to determine what they could achieve and how... That is why many skills are needed to use them meaningfully; all well and good. Except most people treat it as though wizard training were incomplete and did not cover more complex spells. The system also struggles with many kinds of specialization and organizing principle. A wizard specializing in the magical arts, for example, specializes in how magic is applied rather than in particular chapters of magic. What would the system allow them to do, and how, if they learned how to achieve an effect by combining painting and magic?
The concept behind the system could be good, but many characters plausible on Ynev will run into these snags. This means that despite the KAP system, severe restrictions appear. Usually these serve balance, but sometimes they arise unexpectedly, as consequences that were not necessarily intended. And I do not feel that the KAP system's allowing utterly implausible builds that the GM would never permit increases freedom. The system nevertheless works, is playable, and satisfies many people. Its many tournaments provide excellent support too, but this is precisely what has made ÚTK a strong challenger that divides the community more than its predecessors. As long as it has problems, that is not good news.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — New Rulebook | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
What the table does not show is that my real problem is with the concept. I am not saying it is bad. I am saying I do not like it. Its target audience is a little different, which is understandable given how heterogeneous the M.A.G.U.S. community is. We hear that this or that had to be restricted because people abused it in one way or another. There could have been a good explanation, a restriction that did not immediately wreck a class's abilities. Instead, the result is disheartening. Some say: martial artists already faced many roleplaying restrictions, and now many of their options have been taken away on the grounds that they would be abused. The problem is that this balances the class with would-be abusers in mind, but leaves it less balanced in the hands of those who evade the roleplaying restrictions.
Many also point to knight-versus-paladin balance and say there is none. They play more ÚTK than I do, so I would not argue with them even if I disagreed. Whatever the situation, though, I keep hearing that good players suffer because the system had to be optimized to handle munchkins. You can hack your way through an adventure at a tournament. No problem; some enormously overpowered abuses are impossible. True, utterly implausible builds and many other things are still possible, while restrictions kill off many believable character concepts built on good stories.
But it is good for playing in clubs and tournaments. I would venture to say that in that situation it is better than the patched-together ETK used by most long-established tournament-organizing groups. The trouble is, I do not like these adventure-solving competitions. A system rests on a multitude of compromises. Every decision that sacrifices the home-based, life-spanning campaign—more a "serious, time-consuming hobby than a children's game"—to make adventure-solving competitions and events work better hurts and repels me. Even if I say the best events and competitions of that kind use ÚTK. I cannot do anything with that compromise.
The publisher's head says that this solid foundation can later be relaxed through supplements. There is just one problem: munchkins use supplements too. Roleplaying that requires a solid foundation for its world needs that world's natural laws not to depend on whether those relaxing supplements are used or avoided. Otherwise, from the standpoint of setting and roleplaying, this is anything but a solid foundation. By contrast, many systems with a solid foundation for their worlds have introduced tournament rules for balance. We can say that Shadowrun Third Edition's core book does not offer much freedom either... But it does not impose such severe restrictions. It merely puts some of the content, and some good rules for extending it, elsewhere. Because space is finite, not for balance.
When my simplest response to munchkins is to explain why powergaming will not make them win, why it will backfire badly—and there are simple explanations, guidelines, and rules for this—the restrictions above are of no use to me whatsoever, because the munchkin problem they seek to solve can be solved more easily, unless the group specifically asks to let the munchkin in. But let us move on. I still suffer the problems the restrictions cause, and I do not believe there will ever be a package of supplements that remedies them. Even if there is, it will declare that the world's workings are anything but uniform, since they rest on a host of options.
So I gain nothing by choosing ÚTK over the existing edition, but unfortunately many problems and additional arguments remain. Oh, and I can throw out every existing adventure, NPC, homemade supplement, and everything else in its entirety. Well, thank you very much, but that is not a good offer. Not because ÚTK is worse, but simply because it starts more than a decade behind. I would certainly recommend it to a beginner who has a lot of trouble with munchkins but does not want to engage with many details of the world and therefore does not experience these problems. Overall, though, there is a serious issue: the factors I have mentioned throughout. PCs and the army still matter.
Today there are very few situations in which someone encounters roleplaying without other entertainment alternatives, such as computer games. The fact is that tabletop roleplaying still has several major advantages. An adventure requires less development work, so more adventures are made in a year than computer games. Thus we can say it also suits people who grew up on PC RPGs and want to powergame and win at any cost. D&D Organized Play can provide this too. But MMO games, Diablo III's mechanics emphasizing replayability, and many other things also tempt them. I feel that a powergamer or munchkin starting something today would rarely end up choosing M.A.G.U.S. unless we specifically invited them.
After all, a few dungeon tiles, monster libraries, and Pathfinder cover everything, and there you can really powergame. But it is not a given that munchkins will switch from Diablo to tabletop roleplaying. I know that Nyul, who produced CODEX as a demanding game fundamentally intended for discerning players, grew up at PeCsa, then notorious for undiscerning munchkins. It simply seems he developed a taste for more and better. Nobody starts out as a discerning roleplayer. I do not believe there are fewer munchkins today either.
It is simply easy for them to start with Diablo III today. When they see that roleplaying requires reading and is more complicated, hear what more it offers, but are told that it is not about powergaming, what will they do? Decide they need tabletop roleplaying, yet despite the Internet's size and all the recommendations from all those people, fail to seek a dungeon crawl specifically suited to them? Instead ruin everyone else's game in a story- and setting-focused game, with that group doing nothing about it? And this could not be solved? Or will they seek a game tailored to their needs? I believe the latter.
Most players play with an established group; their experiences at events and tournaments are secondary. A competition judged on solving the adventure distorts even the most roleplaying-focused player's behavior a little: they will powergame there too. I would therefore not even infer how a given player plays at home from tournament exploits. ÚTK is a M.A.G.U.S. with which you can organize excellent competitions for munchkins whose powergaming is being restricted at that moment. Being good at that required many compromises, accepting that it would be less good at other things.
The player looking for a more serious hobby, enjoying the game's depth and freedom, who might even learn invented languages or debate the philosophy of magical theory—and who, whether a humanities graduate, doctor, pilot, or engineer, has an inquisitive mind and books about probability, game theory, and so on on their shelves—will observe: for the sake of munchkins powergaming at tournaments, they gave up what would matter to me. This game plainly was not made for me. It is not for roleplayers like that.
And with a system made for tournaments, we will be no more able to reach someone on a Star Wars: The Old Republic RP server, in an RP guild, teaching apprentices how to interpret the Sith Code or taking a few people on a field exercise while issuing orders in Mando'a, than someone paying closer attention to roleplaying and characters' personalities in a forum RPG, even one set on Ynev. I would seek something else and consider something else good.
But suppose tomorrow or the day after brings a better solution to the problem, and many of ÚTK's creators consider it better too. We would still have to say that ÚTK had to be created using what they knew then and the models and examples available to them at the time. That leads here. Nor is that really the problem. If they created a genuinely simulation-based system for more discerning roleplayers, would the writers and worldbuilders at DV be able to deliver their share at a reasonable pace and quality? I do not think so.
If we look at M.A.G.U.S.'s problems in ÚTK's era, starting from this edition, 5% consists of genuine problems with the system, and 10% of easily corrected system problems. The writing team and community painstakingly built the remaining 85% for themselves over many years, independently of Tuan and ÚTK's creators. If ÚTK moved much further toward the sort of quality game CODEX once was, the 15% within its control might become 3%. But the other problems would remain. Even if we discard many developments of the past twenty years, the question remains: why not CODEX, why not something else, why not build our own world properly?
What dismays me is that many restrictions concerned with balance and game mechanics are described as simulation. Simulation would mean faithfully following the world's history, existing magical laws, and so forth at the rules level, without regard to game balance and other considerations outside the world. Bringing up such considerations currently leads to the situation where "you could find fault with anyone on that basis." When ÚTK began optimizing for certain problems and for play in certain situations, it chose a target audience. What suits that group inevitably puts others off. And it chose an audience for whom quality problems elsewhere in M.A.G.U.S., beyond the creators' control, would not derail the project.
However much one can point to its faults, inconsistencies, or anything else, those are not disruptive in this situation. It is a decent product... There are simply many other decent products on the market. And I could not recommend ÚTK to three groups: people who invested serious work in their own carefully developed solutions for traditional M.A.G.U.S.; munchkins drawing on many online supplements and the communities catering to them; and finally newcomers, because M.A.G.U.S. is no longer the best choice for that last group.
Although I considered scores, I found myself asking: if the Delta Vision-associated creative team supplying much of the literary background worsens ÚTK's position, how fair is it to mark Tuan down for literary support when this too is a source of dispute? If supplements are missing for legal reasons, is it right to punish the system for that? And... There will be no score. It would not be an outstanding one: the result is neither above 67% nor below 61%. Compared with today's expected standards, ÚTK's setting description is much worse than it looks alongside other M.A.G.U.S. editions. And it becomes increasingly difficult to blame decades of support problems on individual systems.
Precisely because the problem seems to be becoming permanent: the dispute between the rights holder and publisher erupted over books published without the rights holder's consent. Tuan wanted to publish more, because ongoing literary support and a supply of supplements are necessary. Authors who at other times approved even rubbish would not consent to many of these publications. And yes, preventing expansions without permission had arisen before too: this intention of the owners was what cost the d20 project the most.
If I count this against them, around 61–62% would be realistic; if I side with them, around 66–67%. That would depend on sympathy and faith.
M.A.G.U.S. — M.A.G.U.S. 2*0, or the Lunír attempt
My feelings are mixed. On the one hand, where the Lunír team answered questions, I liked their answers, whether about power words or the nature of adventurers. All well and good. There is just one problem: it will not be finished anytime soon. And I dislike their attitude toward playtesting groups just as much as the behavior of the creators around Delta Vision. The literary background's contribution is deteriorating. Suppose the guys overcome every adverse influence and release the best M.A.G.U.S. edition yet—at a time when most people already play other RPGs too, take out M.A.G.U.S. for nostalgia, and want to stick to their existing approaches, good or bad.
There is also one small problem: delays already are a suspicious sign. Supplements will face the same delays later. Many supplements, atlases for example, would not need to wait for the new system's release. Nor do I think whether the system is published has anything to do with the fact that we are not being flooded with one excellent novel after another. Support falls short of Tuan's level, so a disadvantage here is almost certain. Who will simulate the world's many details better if a release happens? We have no way of knowing. That is still in the future.
But as long as M.A.G.U.S. is often a cash cow, the M.A.G.U.S. logo can sell literary works of dubious value, and quality is not the most important criterion in selecting authors, even the best RPG creative team cannot simultaneously guarantee quality and fidelity to the world known from the fiction. Even now, 90% of the debate concerns which previous state to return to. The munchkin attached to their power-word-using character would choose differently from someone wanting to simulate many events concerning the spread of modern magic.
Unfortunately, the M.A.G.U.S. community's expectations are not uniform. Everyone using different options within a shared system would not unite the community either. In roughly twenty-one years, M.A.G.U.S. has not become a stable system making the most of its potential. Most disappointed people will no longer give it a clean slate, and however inspiring Lunír initially was, delays and uncertainty have largely erased this promising start too. And the situation looks disheartening for reasons beyond the delay.
The pace of development is problematic, but so is the way beta testers were recruited. This brings to the fore the opinions of people who irresponsibly sign blank contracts, raising questions about how carefully they think about game design and the like. Throwing together ideas from such sources and discarding a well-considered common foundation has caused problems more than once. Add that the team is insufficiently productive, that this much time and working time cannot be financed from individual books, and that neither the literary background nor RPG publications can generate steady profits without steady releases, and the whole project is unsustainable.
M.A.G.U.S. — Homebrew systems
The greatest criticism of M.A.G.U.S.'s history so far is that I mention this option, take it seriously, and am prepared to assess it to some degree. Normally, I would say homebrew systems and professional solutions do not play in the same league. Let us imagine three levels. The highest belongs to genuinely professional work, with a business plan and deadlines, for example, but also multiple levels of quality assurance. The company developing and publishing the system employs people with different competencies, and their expertise shows in the result.
Indie systems also tend to have a strong concept and some business planning, but not necessarily deadlines, so the supply of supplements is not continuous either. There is no carefully structured team, but there is an intention to ensure suitable quality. The means of doing so is sensible self-restraint. And if quality is the goal, developers read up on things, educate themselves, acquire the necessary tools, and build the world deliberately. The underlying attitude is that the developer works to benefit the customer. The developer does things the customer could do themselves on the customer's behalf, preferably to a slightly higher standard.
Then there is the amateur level. Anyone failing to meet the standards of the two levels above ends up here. With M.A.G.U.S., the very first moment a developer wanted to contradict another rather than serve the player's interests put them in this category. When projects were handled by writers unwilling to think through and learn what world design and game design entail, who consequently often produced worse work than a GM paying even a little attention, they made the decision: from then on, M.A.G.U.S. played in the amateur league. They developed it to please themselves, but it was not a professional product.
If we have covered these periods and creators capable of that level of work, why not discuss all the homemade solutions too? As I said, many people adapted M.A.G.U.S. to the d20 System. They were never official as M.A.G.U.S. But they knew the d20 System and how to build games on it, and might even have been better than the official development team at the time, whom the publisher also recruited from the amateur league.
There are many homebrew systems and conversions of the M.A.G.U.S. world to other systems, with numerous examples of "CODEX rules, but on Ynev" or "D&D/d20 System, but on Ynev." Evaluating them all separately would be impossible. They do, however, share certain features. Like many official editions, they are unsuitable as a foundation for players who do not know each other to play together with a more or less shared interpretation of the rules. Yet it is also true that while players often treat an official edition as a system where even their preferred interpretation is not good enough, merely less flawed, users of comparable homebrew solutions are generally satisfied with them.
If these are not substantially worse than several official editions, and some may even be better, and if they have the undeniable advantage that someone has thought them through and the current GM understands what they meant when writing each rule, why should they not be good for home use? They simply cannot be published or meaningfully handed over to another group. And someone capable of creating a system that remains competitive in other people's hands might also be capable of replacing Ynev, solving the problem of contradictory writing and destruction at the setting level.
I would add that the worst move many M.A.G.U.S. writers made was to say, as rights holders defending contradictory writing and ill-considered opinions, that this was how they had conceived M.A.G.U.S. from the beginning. Because that statement can then be cited. If they say the imaginative, beautiful solutions they are trying to eradicate were never part of M.A.G.U.S. in their view, those things may be easy to copy, and they would then struggle to assert their interests when those ideas and many solutions are borrowed. After all, they publicly declared that the idea in question was never part of M.A.G.U.S. They thought this through and stated it as certain fact in many arguments...
If someone uses those statements as evidence in a legal dispute, it will be difficult to explain that the ideas are theirs after all. M.A.G.U.S. became interesting not because Arel happens to be called Arel, but because of many connections, possibilities, and elements giving the world color. If a rights holder sometimes explains vehemently enough that a particular idea, consistent way of thinking, and so on is alien to M.A.G.U.S., and the strengths built on it are not part of M.A.G.U.S., then they certainly are not the rights holder of those ideas.
That is why destructive contradictory writing, accompanied by insisting "we thought this from the beginning," is dangerous to oneself.
Leaving a good homebrew system trapped in that legal situation instead of trying to turn it into an original game capable of spreading meaningfully wastes both the work invested and an excellent opportunity.
Anyone expecting a "test winner" and thinking it might be the First Rulebook is fundamentally mistaken. In many respects, the First Rulebook was a step backward from earlier editions, and its other innovations could have worked better as supplements, Rúna material, or other available support, such as online content. It was clearly a bad system reform, from the era in which almost all of M.A.G.U.S.'s problems originated. By comparison, the New Rulebook delivered a fundamentally usable system. We can discuss how mistaken interpretations of many rules have spread. We can point to many faults, but no flawless system exists or ever will.
The New Rulebook is largely ideal for competitions, events, and solving adventures where nobody wants to explore connections too deeply. The developers achieved what they intended, what was needed for success with their chosen audience. From that perspective, the system is a step forward. A more world-centered approach would have faced many problems from creators contradicting each other, and starting decades behind would not have been easy. Many of us have invested that much time in creating a coherent vision of the world that works well in play. One supplement could not replace this: it would have had to replace every correction, expansion, and so forth created over those decades.
For a new edition to be convincing, we must be able to assume there will be a solid foundation to which the writers also adapt, followed by a productive period in both fiction and supplements. That is practically impossible. M.A.G.U.S. is heterogeneous in many other respects too. Just think of its many tournament organizers and the teams behind different sites. I do not share the opinion that ETK tournaments fill only a few tables; I have seen crowds myself. ÚTK would nevertheless be better suited to tournaments in many ways. Yet I do not believe such groups would switch.
A switch like that would also wipe out the supplements created by the sites behind those tournaments. Those supplements are what brought the communities together. We can point out that one group or another collects every powergaming option, that many supplements are rubbish, and that many people rightly say so. Or that their "Ynev scholars" industriously gather every contradictory piece of writing like ants and build a great deal on it. They dislike drawing inferences or thinking through the original connections. Meanwhile, their different visions of the world remain incompatible. There will be neither balance nor fidelity to the setting.
The original core book, however, is damned incomplete, and analyzing it throughout, filling it out properly, and supplying missing explanations through analysis of its rules is not necessarily a dream task. My having good solutions is little use if two-thirds of them have never appeared here or on any other website and, since M.A.G.U.S. is not my only priority, are unlikely to do so. I do consider ÚTK worse than a system based on the original core book and put in order over a long time—but that system has a good many years' head start. ÚTK does what it does straight from the shop. Comparing the two in those states would be comparing apples and pears.
If we ask how well each served the needs at its release, what sort of product it was, the first edition was of course excellent. But winning a review through fortunate publication timing would not be ideal. ÚTK has certainly learned from several mistakes, inherited many weaknesses introduced by earlier contradictory writing, and may have a few faults of its own. Yet in many other respects it has improved.
Naturally, I will say that a consistently handled, carefully thought-out world is good and provides fertile ground for discerning roleplaying. Many people share their experience and knowledge, and you can ask questions here too. But the other playable solution is plainly the New Rulebook. And those two cannot be compared. The conclusion is that M.A.G.U.S. did not become popular by accident. But through years and decades of persistent destruction, we have reached a point where, however large a fan base the brand attracts, the inherited situation makes it difficult to unite that audience by developing a truly good product. Spending more on fighting over the rights than on creating and launching a good world is therefore not necessarily a well-considered strategy.
The New Rulebook is a good M.A.G.U.S. edition for tournaments and events. It simply occurs to me that D&D 5 has more worlds, supplements, and literary works, Organized Play is no foolish idea, and if we are not taking the world seriously anyway, its flaws will not bother us either. Knowing ÚTK's legal position and much else, the question arises: if problems with the quality of M.A.G.U.S. fiction, the quantitative shortage of meaningful literary support, and many other little things are disadvantages, why would I recommend M.A.G.U.S. and ÚTK over D&D 5? Or, for that matter, the earlier D&D 4.