Contrary to the claims still being loudly repeated, M.A.G.U.S. was only the second roleplaying game published in Hungarian; the first was a game released in two booklets as Harc és Varázslat. Yet M.A.G.U.S. has remained one of the defining players in the market ever since, and many people see the brand as a real cash cow. The question is why. And just as importantly, why can the devotees of its different editions not agree on so many fundamental questions? Our story begins in 1993, with the publication of the first edition of M.A.G.U.S.
M.A.G.U.S. — The first edition
Many people have tried many times to compare the numerous editions that make up the history of M.A.G.U.S. Most of those making the comparisons had never really familiarized themselves with the editions in question. And trying them out is not the only criterion; exchanging a few words with their creators is not enough either. You also need to know the circumstances in which they appeared. M.A.G.U.S. owed its publication to the fact that an AD&D translation could not be published. The available choices on the market were photocopied pirate translations of AD&D, Harc és Varázslat, and systems in foreign languages. Alongside M.A.G.U.S. there was a promise of Middle-earth Role Playing, but that appeared later and could therefore only compete with subsequent editions.
M.A.G.U.S. was thus almost alone in the market, at a time when the spread of fantasy literature, social changes, and a host of other little things already created favorable conditions for the system. You might say it was in the right place at the right time. But it also responded well to that favorable situation, although of course this does not mean a score of 100%. Many of its shortcomings and weaknesses are familiar enough. Some of its printing errors fundamentally affected the book's usability: it would be difficult to create a player character in the warrior main class, for example, if the method for rolling Astral were missing.
|
M.A.G.U.S. — First edition | |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|
|
| Opportunities | Threats |
|
|
Looking through the overview above, it is easy to see how the first edition of M.A.G.U.S. won over so many players. It had advantages that every M.A.G.U.S. player now takes for granted, but its incomplete setting description was already a drawback then. I do not just mean the blank spots, but the solutions carelessly tossed in without much thought in so many places. Everyone has come to imagine Toron differently since then. But the descriptions of many other regions have changed too. Areas left to the GM, the blank spots, offered good opportunities, as did descriptions whose connections the GM had to recognize for themselves; nevertheless, many shortcomings made it inevitable that errors would be corrected.
It soon became clear in the system that adventurers were stronger than the average person, and Nyul certainly had thought the system through as far as his earlier research and ideas allowed; games had been run in the setting too. But we can be quite certain that M.A.G.U.S. was rushed into print: a little care would have caught its serious printing errors. Of course, the book sold out anyway, and Rúna supplied the missing details. The game was more true to life than AD&D, beginning characters died less often, writing a backstory was more worthwhile, and players therefore put more emphasis on roleplaying. In the evolution of roleplaying games, this was a step in keeping with the spirit of the times. Every innovation supported it. At the same time, the possibility of an overwhelming hit meant there was still reason to fear for your character even at high levels.
Although many people made the M.A.G.U.S. core book the grand prize in AD&D "powergaming championships," since first-level characters were less vulnerable here and later on, thanks to overwhelming hits, it was easier to kill instantly, a general consensus soon formed that M.A.G.U.S. was a decidedly good game. That gave it enough active players that anyone who wanted to play could easily find a group. And plenty of available opportunities to play is something we would expect from a widely known system, and one of its defining assets.
As for freedom in character creation, characters in this system can be customized more than in the AD&D commonly played at the time, for example, but in this respect M.A.G.U.S. lagged behind both Rolemaster, another class-and-level system, and BRP, which defined character types. The main idea was that something available within the setting—a character studying at a particular place—should be possible to create, subject to its requirements. The system assumes that training in many places is complex enough that less adequate training would simply "not add up to first experience level," so this restriction on PC classes is justified within the setting. If we take that approach, the system hardly restricts us. One substantial restriction is that a higher starting age does not bring additional skills.
Ratings:
- Completeness of setting description: 5/10
- Consistency of setting description: 7/10
- Interest of setting description: 7/10
- Freedom in character creation: 8/10
- Game balance: 5/10
- Consistency of the system: 8/10
- Literary background: 7/10
- Support (Rúna, tournaments, etc.): 8/10
- Community (size, cohesion, opportunities to play): 8/10
- Execution: 4/10
- Total: 67%