Article Index

The general view is that group members must work for clues. In reality, they receive some for free. It is easy to imagine clues leading characters between every pair of locations. In practice, placing clues toward every nearby pub merely so the PCs can ask whether patrons have seen strangers in the village would be very difficult. Movement between locations is often determined not by clues but by the adventure's surroundings and the playing area's physical structure. At other times, the very absence of clues prompts PCs to search more widely. Although clues ultimately point to the real perpetrator, in the short term we see them forming independent structures.

We can present clues to players in many ways. Giving information directly after a roll is the most immediate option; hiding it in descriptions is another. We can hand players counterparts of documents existing in the world, which make excellent clues, as do pictures and maps. 

In the previous article, I suggested that if characters fail to find something, you basically still have six options.

  1. Get them to search the place again because they suspect something must be there.
  2. Many other pieces of evidence point in the same direction, so losing one clue is no problem.
  3. The chain breaks there, but they see both halves and can infer what is missing.
  4. The world is alive: someone else may find the object, and the characters can obtain it through them.
  5. Not every adventure must be solved completely; they can bear the consequences.
  6. You can cheat in their favor.

I would not recommend the last option even in fantasy, let alone Call of Cthulhu. Putting information in unrealistic places for this purpose, rather than where the person would have hidden it, creates a serious problem. Players either gloss over “How did this get here? It belongs somewhere completely different,” learning that many things can and should be ignored—a very dangerous direction in a series of investigative adventures—or interpret the relocation itself as a clue. Option five is not particularly good either, but is permissible despite the disappointment. Call of Cthulhu is not about superheroes, after all, but people whose chances of success are not high to begin with.

But hold on a moment. The clue pyramid, like many other approaches, provides substantial redundancy to ensure progress. In most adventures, you simply will not design an element that can cause failure at a single point. Genuine choices also mean PCs will not resolve every branch. Option two therefore deserves emphasis: where the group failed to persist, steering them back is not ideal either. But we discussed several ways to present clues. Some clues will appear both in the description and in the displayed picture or map, while a successful roll also draws the player's attention to them. NPCs knowing about them provides another reserve. This degree of backup is more than enough unless the PCs go completely astray. 

The redundancy mentioned here also means pictures and descriptions convey atmosphere as well as information. As a Call of Cthulhu GM, few tasks are more important. Which aspect of Call of Cthulhu you are trying to convey matters too. We readily call Lovecraft's work horror, but much of it is weird fiction, where the important point is that the story need not be bloody and the opponent need not be invincibly, incomprehensibly powerful. What matters much more is that the result is strange. An encounter with the inexplicable confronts the PC with the unknown. 

Option four can fit if the adventure does not rely on isolation, there is a suitable person, and it makes the story more lifelike. But players dislike an NPC solving too much for them, even as a consequence of their mistakes. Much information, however, is available from several people by design. Someone saw something, someone heard something, someone found something, so this sort of plan B follows from the clue pyramid's construction. I feel option three fits Call of Cthulhu or a fantasy setting, since some details will remain unexplained. Here, sufficient evidence is enough. 

There is, however, a cheating method that works. In an investigative adventure, pictures, maps, and objects placed in players' hands—found letters, records, and so on—are good ways to convey information. These remain in the PCs' possession between adventures too. During a break in play for food or anything else, you can let the player of a more intelligent character derive new information from clues already received, within realistic limits. A little conversation about whose character might notice what can guide them toward a few details.