The introductory installment of our series was primarily a collection of ideas and advice that you either agreed with or did not, but you surely asked why the advice was not structured and where the connections between its points were. The thinking ran in one direction: someone asked a question, answers appeared, and I am not sure the beginner was any less lost by the end of a debate jumping among many viewpoints than at the beginning. So let’s put a consistent perspective in one place, roughly working through those lists. Someone working on this right now ideally needed it yesterday. In the longer term, however, that would not be the right solution. But approached from another direction, the argument also had a very simple outline:
- Reusable locations and NPCs
- A reason to return: clues that build on one another
- A second reason to return: checking a false lead
- Typical interaction at a location
- This is not enough for everyone: allow for other interactions
- The next level of balance: gathering information through abilities
- How to stock the “clue repository”
- Where and how to present clues
- Inaccuracy and accidental false leads
- Tools
- Debugging
Some people followed that thread, others did not. It was not particularly prominent. Someone did note, however, that Delta Green is not a perfect example of a combat-oriented adventure, because... Delta Green only removed the ultimate descent into madness from Call of Cthulhu, and many of its adventures are strongly investigative too, but some let the group raid the Deep Ones. In other words, raids and combat-oriented adventures are possible. They are not a general requirement. A general requirement usually does not arise. There was an extremely simple reason I began with the difference between combat-oriented and investigative adventures: You can generally kill a person only once, but usually observe them, question them, and so forth many times. That leads to a very important consideration. Although not every investigative adventure is a criminal investigation, this simple example will concern that kind of case, partly because of the question that was asked.
To prevent an adventure module from stalling, people developed the idea that the clues advancing it need some redundancy. This was the Three Clue Rule. If you miss one and misinterpret another, the third clue still works. Node-based adventure design reversed this principle, assuming that, with three clues pointing in different directions, the characters would follow one of them. Obviously not the one they never noticed. But that leaves the misinterpreted clue and the correct one. The misinterpreted clue can therefore send them in any wrong direction, and this approach does not plan a clue leading back from those directions. Misinterpretation adds a new false lead to the system. But there is another possibility: faced with two definitely contradictory clues, the group can choose two further ways of examining them. One is investigating the two locations simultaneously.
The other is investigating the two clues further to establish which way to go. With the Three Clue Rule, it is easy to see that attempts to resolve the contradiction can lead the group to interpret the misunderstood clue correctly. When the rule is reversed, however, the additional clue does not correct the misinterpretation. Although this article will not discuss it, trying to reconcile the two clues can readily produce further mistaken leads: clues pointing in different directions will have no correct harmony, but an incorrectly perceived harmony—a false lead—may still exist. False leads are an inevitable part of investigative adventures, and a false lead created by a player's misinterpretation is equivalent to one deliberately presented by the GM.
From point A, the player could therefore reach not only B, C, and D, but also, say, point C', created by a misinterpreted clue, and point A', representing deeper examination of A. While C' is a misinterpretation, A' is not: it is an option arising from the adventure's design. In a combat-oriented adventure, after exploring A and B, C, C', and D would seem good continuations, but the clue toward D has been confirmed in two places. Hang on, though: articles presenting node-based adventure design left out a point here. The conclusion. There is also a route from B to E, the conclusion. Or perhaps to E', and there may be one to D' too. Even to B'. And the feeling that we missed something may lead toward A' as well. You can generally kill a person only once, but usually observe them, question them, and so forth many times. A location becomes reusable because the player can hope to discover something new by returning to it. The problem of following a route in an endless loop therefore cannot easily be excluded, since the clue leading to A' and the newly arising B' points always remains. There is no guarantee the group reaches point E, the conclusion.
Visiting a location more than once does not mean planning several substantive scenes there. A dungeon is a good example. Corridor A has doors opening into rooms B, C, D, and E, and into corridor F leading onward. If the group explores in the order A→B→A→C→A→D→A→E→A→F, it effectively uses the dungeon in the order A→B→C→D→E→F if returning to corridor A produces no new encounter. Such as a relief patrol, a party searching for the missing guards, or something else that would create a new encounter in locations A', then A'', then A''', altered by the wreckage of earlier battles and the bodies lying there. The group proceeds with dwindling resources through increasingly difficult terrain. In node-based adventure design, the graph formed by planned scenes and the lines connecting them is almost a virtual dungeon. Although you can say that scene order influences the scenes and makes the adventure's arc unique, the conclusion often says otherwise.
In an investigative adventure, you allow for a player character armed with new information to ask many new questions. Checking further information will therefore very probably turn scene B into scenes B', B'', and even B''' as well. And people react to the characters' behavior at every location and in every scene.