Article Index

Populating the clue pyramid

As noted earlier, five provable facts stand at the top of the clue pyramid: a conceivable and demonstrably possible narrative, a confession that may be obtained, the discovered murder weapon or object linking someone to the event, the opportunity approached through the absence of an alibi, and finally motive or motivation. When creating an investigative adventure, your first decision is obviously what happened and what must be discovered. You therefore know the perpetrator and have at least one correct version of every fact at this level, making it relatively straightforward to populate. But recognize that an individual piece of evidence or lead does not point to only one place. Why? A profile establishes motive, can underpin the story of a possible narrative, and may enable the characters to extract a confession. Almost any evidence of motive may help obtain a confession. A possible narrative depends heavily on skillful, creative use of evidence obtained in other connections. Crucially, a possible narrative need only be a story people can be brought to believe, with no evidence against it; it need not be true.

A possible narrative is also the easiest thing to overturn with exculpatory evidence. When I said you could begin with one PC accused, the accuser probably has a possible narrative they believe proven to some degree. One of the group's first tasks is then to overturn it. The second is to disprove opportunity and motive. For the latter, it suffices to show that although the character may have had a motive, knowing their personality, it would never have been enough for murder. An important foundation of investigative adventures is always providing several pieces of information the PCs can pursue. Always maintain sufficient redundancy. Saying that three of the five top-level criteria must fit was a useful guide. But only two of the three useful leads pointing to each need be recognized. At this level, the player needs only 40% of the leads. If, one level down, they need three of four, they need only 30% at that level; then two of three is plenty, bringing it to 20%.

The first guarantee that characters can solve the adventure is redundancy. 

Because you know what happened, you can easily imagine what traces the perpetrator left. When discussing consistent resolution and new information, a small detail soon arose. 

The room we are discussingWhat consistent resolution looks like naturally varies from person to person. Suppose you start from the idea that a player character is human and can handle roughly seven pieces of information in parallel at once. As GM, you therefore give them six to eight. What happens when they first enter the room in the picture on the left? What are the six to eight important pieces of information? Darkness or dimness, the fire still flickering in the fireplace, the darker brownish colors, the screen in the corner, the cabinet, the sofa. And finally, the person on the sofa, because after their first impression of the room they will focus on her. 

The information about her is that she is a woman, white, tall, attractive, brown-haired, wearing comfortable clothing primarily intended for home that nevertheless reveals quite a lot, and sitting comfortably on the sofa. The next information you provide under your consistent six-to-eight rule concerns her behavior and what she says. We can guess that, out of those twenty-one pieces of information, players will deal with at most seven.

As you can see, although one subject remains at six to eight details while the characters focus on it, focus changes within a scene. Giving twenty or thirty pieces of information while walking through a crime scene is therefore quite possible. Ten or twelve may be usable evidence. Once these have been noted and collected, the characters begin searching, revealing less obvious evidence. Obtaining the first several elements of the clue pyramid requires little effort. But the description can repeatedly specify that character X notices thing Y, so communicating observations, interaction, and roleplaying can already take more time here. 

If you inserted every detail in the description into the clue pyramid as a further level of observations and assumed that many would be discussed, you would calculate a very high time requirement. But the wall's color surely will not produce more than two sentences of communication. All right, with the previous page's communication based on emphasizing a single word, perhaps one one-word sentence per PC could fit. The point is that what they can learn immediately can be placed at the appropriate level of the clue pyramid, giving it a source there. For some noticeable details, however, also note that a particular witness saw them, when they would mention them, and when the players can learn them from that source.

Next you can fill in the alibi database, accounts from potential eyewitnesses and people who heard something, and statements from those who discovered the crime. Testimony often contains not only observed facts but deductions too, providing leads to higher levels of the clue pyramid. That is why I said the group possesses a substantial proportion of the clues at the beginning. You have some guesses about what they will pursue next and can devise answers to their likely questions. Many deductions can fill gaps, and where information is sparse you can supplement it.

Call of Cthulhu covers several periods. The game appearing in the late 1980s also addresses the then-present day, and a supplement covered the 1990s. Any information source you could have used in that period is available to the characters too. Questionnaires appeared in several Criminal Minds episodes. We recommended them as an investigative tool in the first article of our questionnaire series too. Many searchable databases contain enormous amounts of information. Getting to know real files is worthwhile: it shows you what data characters can find and can also inspire excellent NPCs. If you do not feel like visiting archives... Ügynöksorsok offers excellent examples of the details accessible records can reveal today. 

On December 10, 1958, Major Imre Erdei submitted a summary report on his three meetings with “Ibolya” up to that point. At their first meeting, he assigned her to visit the writer Miklós Szabó and inquire about the possibilities for her husband's return. He also instructed her to visit a lawyer, but the woman “firmly refused to comply and declared that she had no intention of accepting the financial assistance her husband wished to send her through [...] a lawyer.” Her handwritten report, signed in her own name and bound into the M-file, confirms that she nevertheless visited the lawyer. Concerning their second meeting, the operational officer wrote that “Ibolya” had completed some of the assigned tasks and had visited Miklós Szabó in person.

Source of the quotation: Ügynöksorsok – Ügynök? Sorsok? – A hálózati lét sokfélesége és a megismerés korlátai [Agents' Fates – Agent? Fates? – The Diversity of Life in the Network and the Limits of Knowledge] — Authors: Katalin Kónyáné Kutrucz and Ida Petrikné Vámos

The clue pyramid can also contain information indicating many NPCs' characteristic traits. As long as an alternative scenario exists, the prosecution's narrative often rests on shaky ground. For the narrative, motive, and opportunity, it therefore needs to be shown that the perpetrator had a better opportunity and stronger motivation to commit the act. You can accordingly place exculpatory evidence concerning other suspects at different levels of the pyramid.