Following the earlier outline brings us to an important question. The title previously given was “The next level of balance: gathering information through abilities,” which is not very descriptive. So far I have discussed locations changing, revisiting them for new information, the importance of sharing information there, and communication as a basis for gaining it. For investigations, The Wire is almost required viewing, and it has a striking example. Two characters receive a cold case and look for previously undiscovered evidence at a scene already searched by others. Interestingly, their communication uses no particularly large vocabulary. There is a reason many refer to it by the repeated word as the “fuck scene.”
The two detectives understand each other from barely a word. Tone and many other details make their communication quite expressive. When the tone suggests “I've found something” that may be interesting, the other detective can try again from a new perspective, and they have time for many attempts until the matter is resolved. Checking new information, a fundamentally new attempt, can readily mean another roll. Sooner or later, several characters can take turns rolling at Easy difficulty. This is a typical situation in which the d20 system offers “take 20,” while Call of Cthulhu, like many other systems, says no roll is needed. Call of Cthulhu also has the Luck roll for chance, so “let's roll to see what you found” would not arise. What matters, however, is having the relevant skill at a level that would permit the roll.
Social situations such as questioning witnesses rarely allow repeated rerolls, so when a test is needed there, the dice may come into play more.
The holy trinity of Know, Idea, and Luck immediately arises, along with how much they should be rolled. I have a few observations, and this is an important balance question. A high characteristic makes a Know roll easy for one PC, but they know nothing about this particular subject. Another PC is generally less educated but knows this subject precisely. How does the system handle that? Such a general test is not tied to a specific action. When you want a Know, Idea, or Luck roll, it effectively covers the scene, and one such roll will not give you seven or eight clues.
Skill use, however, can occur action by action, and the GM may order an additional roll when you might recognize something. In a situation where “you could roll many times, and it is recognizable even at your level,” perhaps also “it would be Easy,” you readily receive extra information during the sequence of actions. But these advantages of skills go hand in hand with communication that creates examinations from ever more perspectives and ever more opportunities to test. Skill use, action, and the instinctive communication described alongside it—even merely a change in the emphasis of “fuck”—arise from an ability used within a social situation.
An action and its natural reaction, seen and heard by another character who reacts in turn, establish a typically nonverbal communication channel among PCs, an important part of these scenes. Asking a follow-up at the right moment and many other small things may depend on Psychology. One character can spot when another becomes uncertain or when something might be added to the findings so far. And it is often important to note that persistence—not giving up—is among a character's greatest assets during investigation and information gathering. Motivating companions to persist with a well-timed question or sentence can help enormously.
Characters designed more for combat-oriented adventures usually have persistence too, since it is advantageous there as well. If a character is dexterous because their player partly designed them for combat, that dexterity may let them reach evidence or objects the others cannot. They may enable a new attempt with a new method, or create the situation where repeated attempts make a roll unnecessary: success is achieved. The spotlight is shared between them and the character with some relevant training. The three more universal rolls do not solve everything; abilities and skills receive more room.