Article Index

False leads in your adventure

One of the characters' main tasks is filtering out false leads. They also want to eliminate innocent suspects. An investigative adventure's difficulty is affected by what proportion of the leads currently being examined are false, and when their falsity needs to be recognized. It is worth examining the types of false lead and how checking or recognizing one can change returning characters' relationship with a location or NPC. 

Changes in the PC–NPC relationship are naturally mutual: NPCs react to the characters returning and questioning their word. The characters are also taking up their time again, which in most cases can become annoying. An interesting possibility also arises: an NPC may not necessarily remember their first statement. There can be many good reasons. Call of Cthulhu is a roleplaying game in which numerous scientifically grounded methods—drugs and hypnosis—and mystical methods of influencing testimony and memory can coexist.

Memory implantation and a little manipulation can even produce a false confession the person later does not remember making, yet which contains a detail the police believe is not public. Such methods and Sanity loss can often lead NPCs or PCs alike to give this kind of statement. An interesting opening for an investigative adventure is to begin after one PC, under such an influence, has confessed to something they did not do and remembers nothing. Because of earlier deeds, the group, including the affected character, is given a little time to clear the matter up. At the investigation's beginning, they receive the entire file collected so far, and for some questions they need not wait for the lab because results already exist. This is a substantial twist, but also shortens and simplifies the story.

Misleading testimony

It is a cliché that witnesses may lie but physical evidence rarely does. Since this page will be long anyway, I will begin with Gamingportal's recording of one of the first interrogations in Rockstar's L.A. Noire. There, of course, both the game's length and the structure of its gameplay justify generally collecting all evidence at a location on the first visit. But even it has NPCs you must return to, asking questions based on different evidence in your notes to obtain new information. 

The NPC is subjective

DAZ article, IRAY QVGAYou see the video and the image on the left. If an NPC describes someone as good-looking, which of the three women fits? What if I say they used the words slim and thin? You would rule out the middle one. Suppose you meet the witness's previous five girlfriends and none weighs under ninety kilograms. You know that is their point of comparison, and that even an eighty-kilogram woman is already too thin for them. You can then consider what it means that a witness thinking this way did not add “practically a skeleton” or at least “skin and bones.” The image you have in mind will probably change completely.

In an investigative adventure, subjectivity is the most important element of NPC personality. 

One interesting possibility is the character immediately following up “thin” by asking for an estimated weight. Another is returning after discovering the woman was not thin by the characters' standards. In the latter case, the edge to the follow-up question may affect the mood of the whole conversation and future cooperation. Of course, someone else may draw attention to the statement's inaccuracy too. 

The NPC is mistaken

On the previous page I raised the connection between mistaken identification and poor visibility, and the way the human mind influences what it adds to the information seen. For your world to be believable, not every NPC can be infallible. You need to include mistakes. Characters therefore often need to assess how accurate a claim may be. 

A few careful questions may suffice to check it; the NPC may even point out their own mistake to the group, provided the group lets them.

The NPC is prejudiced

If Lovecraft mentions his own racism, it is worth considering that there will be NPCs far more racist than he was, but also sexist ones, or people who simply dislike a particular family. Malicious gossip can also underpin prejudice. Truth's greatest enemy is not lies but prejudice. Since the NPC rejects most information contradicting their conviction and interprets compatible information as continual confirmation, their opinion becomes increasingly firm.

Prejudice is part of the NPC's personality, however, and probing it too hard can lead to confrontation. Returning to investigate it may therefore not be worthwhile for the group. Others, however, may know the NPC is prejudiced. 

The NPC tries too hard to help

If you motivate an NPC to give you information, they may strain their memory and create a false recollection, producing further incorrect information. This becomes increasingly likely as questioning is pushed further. The NPC then becomes confused, making even their earlier, previously accurate information increasingly difficult to use. 

The NPC protects someone unnecessarily

An NPC may protect loved ones even when they have done nothing, merely believing you might suspect them, or suspecting them personally. Challenging this can easily be risky. But the NPC may become disillusioned with their loved one, or realize the person has a genuine alibi, and initiate a correction to their statement themselves. 

The PC influences the NPC

In the TWA Flight 800 accident, FBI investigators asked witnesses whether they had seen the missile hit the aircraft. Many saw the trail of burning leaking fuel after noticing the stricken plane, but that certainly could not have been a missile. The wrong question, however, led everyone to believe what they saw was a missile because the interviewer, who knew more than they did, said so. That is why our discussion of questionnaires and the related series also address influence. A PC can have the same influence through a direct question, but also when obtaining information from many people through a questionnaire. In the latter case, even an NPC-created questionnaire may contain this flaw.

This can permanently add to the memory or information fixed in the NPC's mind, so the problem must be accounted for from then on. If the characters question the NPC's honesty on that basis, it is a very serious problem indeed. 

The NPC has been deceived

Anything that deceives player characters can deceive non-player characters. The manipulative methods raised at the top of this page—deception, hypnosis, manipulation with drugs, and so on—are possibilities. So is entirely ordinary deception through misleading information or exploiting someone's gullibility. 

The NPC has a reason to lie

They may be guilty or protecting the guilty party. They may have another secret. If they lie, their resistance must somehow be broken, but how helpful they would be afterward is questionable. Returning to confront such a character may therefore be justified when the group no longer expects much other help from them and has sufficient ammunition. Otherwise, the NPC may later actively influence or obstruct the investigation, and the PCs may reveal how much they know. 

Misleading clues

They say evidence does not lie, but that is far from certain. I will try a few examples to illuminate situations where evidence certainly lies, at least partly. A location does not take offense. Someone unable to enter their home, denied a loved one's body for burial, or annoyed by harassment caused by an investigation following a false lead certainly may. And locations change with time and ordinary use. 

A deliberately planted false lead

A deliberately planted false lead is particularly interesting when it is placed after the location was first searched, but the person planting it does not know that. It is equally interesting if a witness saw the location between the act and the later planting of the false clue. Deliberately planted false leads are relatively straightforward to handle.

The PC is mistaken

I could call this the result of a failed roll, but in many cases it does not depend on a roll. When I referred to the Three Clue Rule building redundancy around one missed clue and one misinterpreted clue, we could infer that players and player characters sometimes misunderstand a clue. That is natural. 

A false lead based on prejudice

As game master, you are your players' eyes and ears, describing what they see and how they see it. This also matters when comparing what they see with something else. A discovered clue often resembles something, creating a “perhaps it is this” situation in which you can freely draw on the player characters' possible prejudices. 

Irrelevant evidence

The simplest case is evidence unrelated to the matter being investigated. They are investigating murder, but the evidence belongs to a different theft, smuggling case, or something similar. Or to an event that does not belong in crime fiction at all. Those happen too. Someone can be injured in an entirely everyday situation and leave blood traces. 

A failed test or faulty scientific evidence

There will be failed tests and critical failures too. The wildly misleading evidence produced by these will also appear. Evidence may be contaminated or unintentionally falsified in the process.