Article Index

Many M.A.G.U.S. rules were unnecessary if you merely wanted to “go adventuring” and were thinking of the legendary AD&D adventure modules. But they mattered greatly when the world provided a solid foundation for the characters' research and stories, which could slowly influence that world. This too defined M.A.G.U.S.'s market position, alongside its appeal as a widespread Hungarian RPG to people who did not speak English. Or those who could not afford every important supplement for the systems dominating the international market, but did not want to remain at the level of pirated PC action RPGs.

NotBoobRaider

And we get a usable tabletop roleplaying game cheaply. The emphasis is on tabletop, and on having a GM. Back when Mass Effect 3 appeared, we heard how much its ending was an “artistic vision,” and that its inconsistencies were no worse than those we see in many other places. The problem is that even in a computer game, we would expect our own conception of our own character to prevail. Since then we have had Mass Effect: Andromeda, some criticisms of which also concern the creator imposing their vision. And that is an action RPG. But even there I had to write that the game consists not only of what we see, but also of what we must imagine alongside it. It is about freedom and creativity. M.A.G.U.S., with few “mandatory” supplements, offers the freedom of a tabletop RPG cheaply. 

It was also a good foundation that literary Ynev and the roleplaying game's world were somewhat independent, and even literary Ynev's contradictions could be explained through multiple versions. This produced an interesting mix: the literary Ynevs presented possibilities that the GM could adopt where justified if they gave players fertile ground, while the party could remain the protagonists and those events serve as examples. Examples to develop further. If the game receives a single canonical Ynev also based on contradictory and often unreadable novels, freedom shrinks. Yet precisely this is valuable: we can shape the story's ending, its later continuation, and its continuation elsewhere. 

The new M.A.G.U.S.'s premise differs here too. Of course, creation remains possible within these boundaries; the shift turning many inspirations into restrictions and foundations into walls does not yet kill creativity. Not even though many criticized GMs treating the mass of rules and literature as scripture precisely for restricting creativity. For killing many creative ideas. And now everything will be like this. Because there are “creative” ideas I too would shoot down. Others, however, fitted perfectly well before and will not afterward.

A New Spell, a Knightly Order

The history of Facebook's M.A.G.U.S. group also includes an interesting debate about female knights and paladins. Someone thought it a good idea to bring the argument to Delta Vision's page and the publisher's forum behind the participants' backs. My position was entirely straightforward. There are documented examples of female knights on Ynev. And creating many kinds of knightly order may be necessary for one simple reason: M.A.G.U.S. is about life-path campaigns. 

It does not matter what the creator imagined or what the GM prepared for. We play tabletop roleplaying games so players can do and achieve things neither the GM nor the creator anticipated. If we give that up, PC RPGs would be better.

Making history in a life-path campaign need not mean saving the world or “battling gods.” It can also mean seeing the spell we invented or the knightly order we founded and made successful return after years of play. Saying that a player is unfamiliar with them is no argument against playing such characters. Nor is their rarity, if the adventure takes place there.

And yes, I dislike PPL; in many respects it does not even reach the standard of homemade online supplements. I disagree with its priestess of Ellana, because Ellana is, among other things, the goddess of infidelity, whereas loyalty matters in a spy. Handing fertility and much else over to her was, I think, a mistake that undermined fidelity to the world. But it happened. And if someone wants to play a priestess of Ellana, I have to allow her. Her published background and combat knowledge are facts within the game world. 

Where there is no class system and anything can be put together, this will be even more true. And if she is just as good in combat as other adventurers, she has just as much chance of attaining rank and titles and attracting followers through her example. Arguing about which creator imagined what and how, contradicting what was written and taking digs at someone else, initially behind their back too, is a rat's attitude. 

It is also fundamentally incompatible with one defining feature of tabletop roleplaying: that players can do and achieve things neither the GM nor the creator anticipated. With freer spellcasting, the PC will not invent some new, ingenious solution allowing them to do something previously impossible.

And I have a concern: whatever a character establishes or achieves, the freedom sought at the system level runs into a problem when you seek a solution—András Gáspár and company's attitude remains unchanged. They recognize neither that roleplaying must support things they never considered... Nor that if someone receives weapon-use skills beyond a priest's basic abilities—even at basic proficiency—I will not say such a priest never learns to fight.

If they did not learn, they could not acquire weapon-use skills, would receive none among a priest's basic abilities, and would have worse combat values too. 

The “only we are allowed” and “your character should not try to achieve anything” stance contradicts what Rúna magazine's article on life-path campaigns said. 

This, however, is a fundamentally different arrangement from what M.A.G.U.S. has been about, and that has consequences. I disagree that it removes all room for creativity. Just as we contrast the writing team with truly creative writers, we can contrast players who are not particularly creative in a constrained world with those same writers and many GMs and players. At the same time, we can say that a more constrained world and system do not provide the ideal foundation for certain ideas of theirs. 

Because on that basis we would have to override every new restriction and rule. And not just the rules: we would also have to handle the player's very different expectations. But I will go further: as I wrote, mosaic magic's limitations underpinned many creative ideas. They were not unnecessary restrictions at the system level, but an approach to the world described so far that was advantageous in many ways. If mosaic magic's limitations matter to my story, there is no point choosing a system that removes them. If I want to give players opportunities to research and invent, I will not necessarily start from “why bother, when complete freedom was already available without effort?” 

Gorvik's situation and numerous other questions tell us whether M.A.G.U.S. and Ynev are the right tools for realizing a particular idea. I will go further: they establish whether edition X or Y is the right tool. Arguing about which edition is better can easily become entirely pointless if only one is suitable for achieving our particular goal. But what is the right tool, anyway? After all, the system's obstacles can be overcome in every case! Well, the right tool is the one that does not throw dozens of entirely unnecessary obstacles in our path.

I have often said that making many unnecessary rules optional could produce a smooth-running M.A.G.U.S. system. Then sourcebooks could remedy its greatest flaw: many characters become “NPCs only” simply because players do not know enough about Ynev, its natural laws—including the laws of magic—its cultures and education to portray them. A new system with a world that is new in many respects does not solve this problem. Giving the wizard such freedom is pointless if it still does not make them a magus and many research possibilities disappear. This flushes much work already invested down the toilet, and talk of how this or that can be transferred into the system is pointless if their places in the world, goals, and stories are lost. Making what once distinguished them commonplace tomorrow can be enough.

For me, one of the greatest disappointments in D&D's history came when we were told that D&D 3 would let us create every kind of character. Most of my already-written characters could not be made. Not even across the whole 3.x series. They invoked balance, which nevertheless accommodated unkillable super-builds. Taking away a good character who fit the world in the name of nonexistent balance smelled rather like a con. I have never been able to view D&D the way I previously viewed AD&D since.

But there was another side to the story: “Now you can have a dwarf wizard.” Well, we had an example of that in AD&D too. A stubborn dwarf whose nature was so opposed to magic that it affected him less readily kept turning everywhere for someone to heal a friend, until he even promised the goddess of magic that if his friend recovered, he would learn wizardly magic. Needless to say, his training required everything from a wish spell to dozens of adventures. But the dwarf wizard surprised his enemies.

What did they invoke when anyone could now have a dwarf wizard? The fact that D&D serves several worlds. There cannot be restrictions everywhere. Yet resistance to magic because of a nature incompatible with it remained, minus the restriction. And a longsword costs the same everywhere across those many worlds... Many discovered spells are identical too. Indeed, imagine that: the racial pantheons appearing among the religions, alongside the world's own human religions, are universal as well. In other words, the argument treats us like idiots again.

The promise of freedom does not mean complete freedom, thanks to the slogan of balance. The promise of balance does not deliver balance, because that is impossible. Instead, many special characters who fit the world cannot be created this way or remain special. And here in M.A.G.U.S., if the concept that a wizard should imitate all empirical magic remains, then, for example, the historical precedent of an empirical magic-user creating something genuinely new through research falls away.

And the biggest problem is that they want to release it this year. Without publishing plans mentioning literature that would help show us what changed over a hundred years. They point to no breakthroughs, offer no justification for the changes; they simply happen because they do. And if you discard things built through much hard work for this, you cannot know when you will have to discard this too. Because how supplement X describes the followers of a religion means nothing to András Gáspár and company.

And if the tendency toward contradictory writing and much else remains, people will hardly dare give players room to shape the world and be truly creative in many areas under the new system. This is far worse than creativity being constrained merely by strict interpretations of rules and a snapshot of the world. And yes, the risk created by the creators' ad hoc pronouncements is the worst kind of unnecessary rule that can restrict GMs and players.