Before the weekend event, the head of Delta Vision gave an interview to a cultural magazine. It contained a damn lot of interesting and important things, and I would like to respond to some of them. He said he had told many groups that they welcomed attempts, would publish something good, and that more than one M.A.G.U.S. system might get a chance. For a long time, games such as Legend of the Five Rings and Call of Cthulhu ran d20 and their traditional systems in parallel. With World of Darkness, the trend also became parallel operation of two worlds and systems, so I have to say the statement is forward-looking. And many people would have the opportunity to answer that call.
He also made this offer to a group in which I am one of the leaders, so I have to take personally the justified observation that nobody appeared at their door with a finished solution. I fully agree that putting the system in order requires precision and that the work we release must be of a high standard. In a recent article, I mentioned a debate about how belonging to humanity's top half percent is not a truly outstanding result, not rare enough in many respects. If we added up how many people we see on an average day, on the roads and on television, the figure would be in the thousands. To stand out really and truly, someone needs a better result. But looking at a curve, half a percent certainly seems very low, and we call what it represents “damn rare.”
In another sidebar there, however, I made an important statement:
It does not matter what the creator imagined or what the GM prepared for. We play tabletop roleplaying games so that players can do and achieve things neither the GM nor the creator is prepared for. If we give that up, PC RPGs would be better.
Making history in a life-spanning campaign does not only mean saving the world or “battling gods.” It can also mean seeing the spell we invented, or the knightly order we founded and made successful, return even after years of play. “The player does not know them” is no argument against playing such characters. Neither is their rarity, if the adventure is set there.
One important solution is that most good roleplaying systems provide a framework in which players can always find room for their own little order or spell in such cases: a solid, readily expandable foundation. That takes enormous work even for the simplest system. People are reluctant to invest that work when a return is unlikely. And not because the finished system would be bad.
There is a simple reason. Delta Vision and the authors allowed us to make supplements for the system. But the rights holder's permission does not extend to revising the existing core rulebook and posting the modified book on a website as free fan material. If Delta Vision does not want the solution, it is being made for the trash, not for our own website.
It would be good to cut material from the existing system and modernize it, but the important things can also be handled through supplements. Yes, even a complete reform of the skill system. The game is fundamentally playable. If I have x hours to create something, supplements, criticism, articles for here or elsewhere, and my own non-M.A.G.U.S. system all take priority over anything that might not even be allowed onto the site.
Why do I believe even a good system would not get the green light at Delta Vision? Essentially, I have four good reasons:
- They have managed to fall out with a damn lot of creative teams. It is hard to believe “the other side is always at fault.”
- They have managed some ugly falling-outs with quite a few fan-site teams holding different views.
- Their relationship with me is not positive either.
- And I can see clearly that we have failed to agree on matters of principle too. Without that agreement, I do not like what many creators do, and they would not like what I do. The same applies in many other relationships.
Against that stands the publisher's representative's position that they welcome good solutions. I would readily believe it, but alongside the considerations above, I think it is understandable why that is not enough when there is no plan B, not even posting a PDF as a fan publication if things fall through. And disagreements can concern not only the system, principles, and setting, but money too. If you put a finished system on the table this way, you would expect payment for your work and the risk you took.
But all this is merely theoretical, because the system's creators and the circle around DV are not known for apologizing to the other side or wanting to work with them after a dispute if they produce something good. Given the bungling so far, and at the very least all the promises, every potential creative team involved has already had arguments with Delta Vision and the creators' circle that descended into personal attacks. The way so much was released that should not have been, and so many people ignored, was enough to make people's blood boil.
András Gáspár, Zsolt Kornya, and many others have enduring merits: as writers they helped bring M.A.G.U.S. into being, and good novels have come from their pens. But however appealing it was when they previously said literary Ynev was independent of gaming Ynev, and an article in Rúna magazine said the goal of a life-spanning campaign should be for PCs to become Ynev's defining heroes, insisting on a unified Ynev today is equally unappealing.
It is a little troubling that readers have repeatedly been surprised with innovations that not only seem unrealistic—an arrow machine gun, for example—but make an idiot of the GM who previously banned them for a reason, because look, they do fit Ynev after all. Worse still is how often earlier established concepts have been contradicted.
Worse even than that is the way they formulate responses in certain disputes. So much so that their enduring sins in this area now outweigh their enduring virtues by a considerable margin. M.A.G.U.S.'s success depends primarily on whether they are willing to make sacrifices and act to reverse that balance. IT DEPENDS ON THIS ALONE! Even the worst system can be explained in a way that makes it playable, and even the best system can yield enough flaws under a fault-finding approach for a flood of hostile articles to sink it. The relationship between creators and opinion leaders determines which direction dominates.
Unless that correction visibly happens, it is entirely understandable for the other side, knowing the system, publisher, and team, to deny it even a chance and criticize it in the spirit of “once again it is not wearing a filter-tipped cap.” It is easy to produce good arguments for such criticism, and very hard to contest everything on every forum and in every group. Even the best system is not enough against that headwind. DV and the creators ought to take a few steps to improve the situation.
- Accept the risk of making the old core rulebook available even if it competes with the new one. A 25th-anniversary reprint based on the third corrected edition, produced in 1994.
- Extend permission for homebrew supplements to homebrew core rulebooks and so on.
- If the system now in development works well for the guys in science fiction, let us see it with a science-fiction setting... Let us see many good systems, even with other worlds.
- Hold regular open days with the publisher's specialists where many world and system concepts can be explored. Solutions being developed as universal systems could then be told, “Let us make a M.A.G.U.S. concept from this too.” Many other concepts could appear with other settings.
- Accept that D&D 5's testing took a year and a half in a much clearer situation. If major issues need clarifying here even at the conceptual level, it will take two or three.
- Apologize to customers, online authors, and others who were deceived, treated as fools, thrown out, and so on, so that as many people as possible want to participate in the project.
Without those steps, it would be very difficult to prevent some opinion leaders from looking for that filter-tipped cap on the system. I would back this up with the louder story behind my own conflict:
In my opinion, few supplements are worse than the two volumes of Papok, Paplovagok. We often “got a second skill for the same thing”; elsewhere, concepts previously separate and belonging to Summarium's system were blended into this one. I consider mixing in od problematic, for example, because neither the Bestiárium nor the assassin was calculated with od in mind. But even that standard, familiar from some netbooks, was further lowered by Ellana's priestess.
Anyone laughing about master-level weapon use when even fighters and the battle goddess's priests do not have it can sit down. Errata fixed that. But she receives weapon use in addition to a priest's basic weapon skills, and was given a spy role. Of course, many intelligence organizations would trust the loyalty of ordained priests of the deity of infidelity. That is about as ridiculous as seeking that same deity and her followers for marriage ceremonies. But the system nevertheless works this way; the character can perform heroic deeds on that basis, earn rank, and inspire others.
Naturally, that led to an argument, because I believe that if this happens in a group, play must continue consistently and with continuity. So when András Gáspár explained in a related debate the range of whores he had imagined as parallels for Ellana's priestesses, the debate immediately split into three questions that could be discussed in parallel:
- What Ellana's priestesses are like in some imagined world. This was András Gáspár's argument.
- What the priestesses described by the system are like, and what stories the system produces. This shows why the first question is not decisive.
- What matters more: particular creators' ideas or those of the players the system must serve. This determines the quality of the game as a product and its associated service.
Let us look at my position on all three questions.
True enough. Ellana is also the goddess of infidelity, so why would they occupy the roles of wife and mother? Starting from that premise, the range in which their role is realistic would indeed consist of various forms of prostitution. But this also means they must offer quality within that range. The esteem enjoyed by Ellana's followers would be rather meager if an ordinary whore of Toronian descent provided many people with a better service. In other words, an Ellana temple would do well to have many kinds of girls, showing people the many faces of beauty and love.
There are women warriors, in novels and elsewhere. Yes, even in knightly armor. A warrior who has seen many battles arrives in town and enters Ellana's shrine. He tells them how aroused he was by a woman warrior who was an officer, but how unattainable she was. What happens then? Will Ellana's church have a girl for such desires? One who is not flustered even if the guest's fantasy is to strip her during sparring, because she can actually handle the implements she is holding? Or will they say, “Son, go to the Toronian brothel if you want the woman of your dreams”?
Had the superspy from Papok, Paplovagok not intervened, this would surely have formed the basis of an adventuring priestess of Ellana too: she wants to get better at this, her adventurer's blood drives her, and the guest can thus have a more experienced girl. One who, of course, caters to him in many ways that evening. So filling the role of a fantasy prostitute depends primarily on the group's imagination. I can certainly imagine that, defending her temple, friends, or others, a luxury whore who learned to fight for such fetishes, with a little adventurer's blood, would stand among the city's defending heroes. And when news of the heroic deed spreads, and many guests want to unwrap similarly warlike heroines from their armor, decorative armor will be made that can be removed more enticingly.
And yes, recognizing possibilities like that has more to do with creativity than “let us put a faster-firing crossbow in the novel.”
That is why, if I began a M.A.G.U.S. reform and the issue arose that, since priestesses of Ellana have already been PCs, they should at least be put in order, I would establish this direction too. Precisely for that reason, I would state that many kinds of training can exist, even in unlikely places. András Gáspár, however, sticks to his view that Ellana's followers do not really have weapon use. Another conflict on this question is therefore guaranteed.
Raise your hand if it bothers you that, in that case, some priestesses of Ellana might know how to use a whip or lash. Or that their lovely studded leather armor is not particularly functional in battle, being more about ensuring that, if the church sticks to prostitution, they are Ynev's best whores, with an answer to every demand.
But until András Gáspár and company's attitude changes, this is precisely the first area I can attack in any M.A.G.U.S. reform, whoever launches it. It is clearly a catch-22. Has Ellana's priestess been dumbed down? In light of the above, why are they less capable than ordinary girls in many brothels? Where can existing characters continue? Is there room for the direction I mentioned, or do the priestess superspies remain? But András Gáspár wrote that they never learn to fight! And he would write that against the books again! Closing the gap is on the agenda precisely so this does not happen. Dear me, poor new rulebook, once again you will not have your filter-tipped cap.
On the second question: a priest receives weapon use by default. Ellana's priestess receives it separately too. Saying she would never learn to handle weapons or fight is a ridiculous position. And even then, combat values on the level of ordinary people could enter the picture. It is worth checking where, say, a hedge wizard stands in the NPC chapters of the core rulebooks published in 1993 and 1994. See? That priestess of Ellana can fight after all.
Yet in this debate, neither András Gáspár, Zsolt Kornya, nor the PPL creators had enough backbone to acknowledge that last point. And yes, someone who lies about an issue while abusing the customer deserves no respect from then on. Contradictory writing and treating as an idiot the player who trusted what they wrote are so unacceptable from a company, and so dishonest on their part, that afterward I have to say a mutually bad relationship is guaranteed.
The problem is that I know perfectly well that standards about what to lend one's name and face to exist not only at the publisher, but among many developers too. Treating customers this way on the publisher's forum and shutting down such matters by decree is what most people consider a service beneath contempt, one they would not lend their name to. And I have heard complaints like this about Delta Vision from others as well.
Anyone who thinks knows perfectly well that this provides another opportunity to look for a filter-tipped cap. If characters thought incapable of combat can have weapon skills, the system exposes players to this treatment and runs into countless problems because of it. If it rules that out, however, existing priestesses cannot be converted, and little comes of the planned break with overly restrictive classes. Third, I will immediately add that most hostility toward M.A.G.U.S. has always concerned the “NPCs only” power options, and the way the system stroked creators' egos instead of serving players.
Of course, if the gentlemen writers say they did not think these things through, were idiots, apologize, accept criticism for the contradictions and destruction so far, and take responsibility, then we can talk about giving them another chance and trusting that something good may emerge and things will be different this time. But if that is not a given at the project's outset, not a basic principle for the publisher and writers, it is a problem.
My own grievance is easy to bring forward, not because it is interesting but because I know it. I do not know how many other people who put work into maintaining the system were left with similar thorns. But I do know that after this, distrusting new developments is natural. Not wanting to throw away previous work or support such authors and such a publisher by buying their products is natural; so is going through a borrowed book in fault-finding mode. Post a list of flaws instead of explanations, fixes, and questions, and the reception immediately becomes odd. If M.A.G.U.S.'s success is not worth enough to the gentlemen rights holders for them to apologize for past dirty tricks and be willing to discuss properly where they went wrong, then the foundation for an edition intended to unite the fan base does not exist.
I could say they should not have published garbage, should not have deceived and ripped off players by putting a logo on garbage. And if DV condemned that behavior, the people removed from its forum would not be those who dislike it. EA is a somewhat larger publisher than Delta Vision, and BioWare is a substantial team. Amid a damn lot of criticism, we hear how the game contains over a hundred hours and so much good material, yet flaws are singled out when even worse ones go unnoticed elsewhere. Because EA and BioWare previously angered their fans, and that is how those fans now approach the system. The M.A.G.U.S. creative team is in no better position. And yes, many people were anticipating Mass Effect too. Super Deluxe, preorder, and so on.
Some people are anticipating M.A.G.U.S. too. There is rejection in advance, and there are aggrieved players who are guaranteed to be critical. And excuse me, but we are talking about the past and present, things that do not require waiting for the new book to appear. Yet they fundamentally determine many people's attitudes. I would paste in a Facebook comment here:

How much do widening the divide and behavior like that mentioned above contribute to many people not looking forward to the new book at all? If there is a measurable baseline of rejection, every site's team and administrators have to decide which side of the divided community to take. Based on personal experience, if Delta Vision and the authors show nothing, the arguments of those rejecting it must be given more space than those of the hopeful. DV should be dismantling that headwind. Anyone can be challenged: despite your own grievances, how can you stand alongside DV? That is a more justified argument than “Why are you so negative already?”
Every gamer has heard of the uproar around Mass Effect, and one key question is known to be whether the creator's vision matters more than the player's. The work is only completed by what the latter imagines into it, and the game is supposedly about their character, their decision, their vision. Even if I forgot the previous two approaches and said Ellana's followers never learned to fight and had combat values below a hedge wizard's, a problem would remain. We do not know the PC's level, or what they roll. Tabletop roleplaying can produce surprises.
Through that, someone can defeat dozens of attackers, become a hero, and inspire people. That is psychology. The player who achieved this also deserves continuity of play, and the creators' ideas—and in many cases their open sexism—must not override it. I do not believe a game must be politically correct, because many people and traditions in the world are decidedly not, and that needs representing. But the creator's thoughts about “why there should be no female knights even though they existed in history and literature,” and their sexism in many other areas, should not take precedence over consumers' interests.
Again: if the system opens up but I see no change from the creator, it can be attacked for the contradiction. If it does not open up, it can be attacked for failing to learn even from such conspicuous examples. There are a million and one situations in which the attacker would be right, even if the essence of the criticism is that, once again, the system was not wearing a filter-tipped cap. However hurtful it may be to say that many will look for that cap, if conflicts of the level described above produce a camp of rejecters, it is in that camp's basic interest for as many people as possible to reject the new system. They will therefore adopt the most critical tone possible. In many places.
If those problems did not exist, a completely repaired system could be published this year. It would not be such an enormous job, because many people have played their own such systems for a long time. But given the situation above, it is no exaggeration to say that whoever is around DV now, however good or bad they are as system designers, these problems mark M.A.G.U.S. and are independent of what the book will contain. Nor is it an exaggeration to suppose that people who have already had bitter disputes over the world concept or other issues, and do not believe they can reach an understanding with the teams there, will not have their solutions and opinions seriously considered during creation. If that makes the system one-sided, testing will not help, and it will increase division rather than reduce it.
These authors have the final say. However much DV or the developer might want something else, the problem described above is a serious constraint on the system.