The first conversation was with a clanmate I knew from an online game. Months ago, around the time of the first announcement.

Me: Hello Moon, have you got a moment?

Moon: Why?

Me: You know we talked about you trying a tabletop roleplaying game. A new M.A.G.U.S. core rulebook is coming out soon, so I thought I would ask in case you were interested.

Moon: I will pass. 

Me: How come? You do not even know it.

Moon: Hate me if you like, but I am still a feminist. ^_^

Me: And a budding hack. We love our friends with their faults. But what has that got to do with this? 

Moon: ^_^

Moon: If even you call something sexist, I look into why.

Me: And here I thought this would turn into an interview I could put on the site.

Moon: Lol

In the end, we did agree that this could be published. The lesson is that she reached the site because I linked her to the Mass Effect: Andromeda review. She read plenty, and immediately said something needed doing wherever the table of contents was on the right. That is how the template editing came about too. She looked around, saw my opinion, then searched for the debate, finding the original statements by András Gáspár and company on his own writers' forum. Let us say the publisher's products, and anything a few of the writers are involved in, are now a pass. Yes, the non-M.A.G.U.S. products too, even though some of the science-fiction offerings would otherwise have interested her.

But even that short conversation was not free... András Gáspár has said a damn lot of times that he does not understand roleplaying. On many issues, we hear that an attempt failed partly because of his opinion. In other cases, we see him become the “arbiter” in situations while overlooking things important to the game. Yet he became one of the faces of the M.A.G.U.S. brand, and to some extent Delta Vision. But let us look at another conversation. By then a few things were known about the system, since an event had already discussed it. The result was clear: 

Me: Guys, the new M.A.G.U.S. is coming. Maybe we ought to try it.

T: I do not much feel like it. It is d6-based.

Me: That has advantages too, and it does not bother you in Shadowrun.

T: But M.A.G.U.S. ought to be d100-based...

Judit: Do we have to argue about d100? 

T: It is part of M.A.G.U.S.

Me: But 00 and 01 come up too often, so a “special roll” is not even special anymore. And it naturally comes with d10 skill checks and the “portion above ten.”

Judit: We fixed the latter ten years ago.

T: And all those 00s and 01s define the atmosphere of M.A.G.U.S. adventures. If I wanted a different atmosphere, I would play a different game.

The face of M.A.G.U.S. is made up not only of people, but of many “flaws” too. The question is whether the community really sees a fix as a fix, or as M.A.G.U.S. losing its identity. But on to the next conversation, very recent, from the last few days. 

Me: Have you heard about the new M.A.G.U.S.?

Gyuri: And Sólyom, and Ronan Air. Or Lunír's M 2*0. 

Me: All right, suppose it gets published...

Gyuri: Then I have heard of ÚTK and d20 too. They can fire the developers anytime. And neither Új Tekercsek nor Summarium 1 got a follow-up. I would not buy a ticket for Ronan Air just because its first flight took off.

He was right. Despite all the above, the system in development may of course be good. It may be better, and even faithful to Ynev in many respects. The question is how far it can win over the skeptics.

There was another conversation too, about irreconcilable differences and the fact that certain news really ought to appear on many websites. Up to a point, differences need to be set aside. The question is whether that is enough to buy and support the system. Many decisions about it are already final, including the d6 question and much else. But questionnaires, playtesting, and the development blog aim to make us feel ownership of a system whose many decisions we will disagree with—and are not asked about—and where many people will have various problems with many individuals and many aspects of the business. So are we for or against DV when we write about it? Does entering this game mean supporting that? I think the focus should be neither DV nor many of the creators, but the players and game masters who play M.A.G.U.S., among other things, for the same reasons I do, and whom we try to support through this site and by administering Facebook groups, pages, and so on. The decision is not about reconcilable or irreconcilable differences, but about those players and game masters: you, our readers.