Many people say we must give it a chance if we want to see a modern system for M.A.G.U.S. The main problem, however, begins with the fact that the most serious problems concern the world, not the system. Almost every player and game master can point to one version of Ynev they like and at least five they cannot stand. Decades of contradictory writing also mean that there is no consensus on numerous fundamental questions about the world. Back then, among the differences between the first few editions of M.A.G.U.S. and the Első Törvénykönyv offering an “almost identical system,” alongside the rise of the “a largely unnecessary rule for everything” approach, one small detail was just as prominent: alignments acquired little labels, and their meanings expanded a little with them. Where corrections were needed, they were rarely made.
A cliché: with a good GM, you can have a good game in any system. So we can predict the answer in advance: the new M.A.G.U.S. will be no different. We do not need to read the book to know this; it is enough to know that whatever it contains, the GM can override it and must do so when necessary. In other words, if a new book began with this and then merely listed the previous and current creative teams' most ridiculous mistakes, giving us something to laugh at and learn from at others' expense, the response would still immediately arise: there are no unplayable systems, only bad GMs. Yet there are better and worse systems, and for some reason many people want a modern system without even saying what that means. Meanwhile, of course, there is also a strong retro, “old school” movement, and some people want that. So the system does matter after all. And it matters that since ETK there has been a “demon alignment.”
I Like Mathematics...
Having to divide or multiply does not bother me. I also refer to concepts such as the normal distribution. And I know that the pyramid in a diagram of social stratification is not the same as the bell curve of a normal distribution. I do not want to correct people from one to the other without reason. A little probability calculation is fine too.
But I also know that most educated players are less bothered by a book not being in Hungarian. For the less educated, however, mathematics is unfamiliar. Division, but also probability. The main advantage of d100- and d10-based solutions was that probabilities were easy to calculate, making it easy to design adventures and challenges.
In discussing a 2d10 proposal that corrected many flaws, I even met a player training for a career in IT who did not understand that, in probability calculations, rolling 1 on the blue die and 3 on the red is not the same outcome as rolling 3 on the blue and 1 on the red.
The d6 is a fine thing... We will get to calculate with plenty of nonterminating decimals.
Anyone who thinks it is a joke that I singled this out as an important change forgets two things. One consideration, important in my view, is that we have heard ever since that an up-to-date, modern system rejects the rule-for-everything approach. The other is that conflicts in stories can follow many character traits, going beyond a simple “good versus evil” opposition. The original alignment system offered an interesting picture by putting one's attitude toward the value of life first, instead of good/evil, and establishing priorities between alignments along the two axes. With a few examples, of course. But once the “demon alignment” appeared, it immediately became a pigeonhole. M.A.G.U.S. aged considerably. Thanks to mandatory ÉP loss, the combat system now offered some lovely division too. Magical exhaustion meant paying attention to bookkeeping for every spell; quickly counting mana points with counters was no longer enough. The effects of wounds also allowed numerous things to be continually recalculated. The system became much slower and aged about ten years.
Many changes introduced in the name of balance were better described as destruction. All because perhaps the GM might not be creative enough to describe a 14 FP wound inflicted by, say, a two-handed sword. Or a 41 FP (0 ÉP) wound caused by a fire eruption. With the latter, I could describe perfectly well how the heat of the tongues of flame stopped at the boundary of the personal aura burned, how painful it was... And I conveyed that if this protection disappeared, the flames of the spell's raging inferno reaching and gnawing at the target's body could easily kill. One of roleplaying's most important distinguishing features is that you can leave the prescribed path and surprise the GM, but the combat system can also produce surprising situations. These can only be resolved with creativity. Period.
The additional bookkeeping, however, cannot be reduced through creativity alone. That required changing the rules. And because many people only obtained a book after ETK, while many earlier players had stopped playing M.A.G.U.S., ETK became the benchmark. It is precisely why we so often hear that X or Y fails to play the stereotype described under their alignment, and even deviates from a sufficiently unreadable novel they have never encountered. Yet they use the original core book's framework honestly and creatively. One hallmark of modern systems is that unnecessary rules impose no additional restrictions, and the system's self-serving mathematical tricks do not make the GM's job harder.
Even GMs who met this requirement less well had to show more creativity than it takes to surprise readers with “a bolt machine gun after the repeating crossbow.” Something we had previously understood to be impossible for good reason. I am not saying the average GM is the pinnacle of creativity. But they show more than this. And anyone saying literature needs greater freedom should remember that famous and prolific crime writers, for example, did not need it. I single them out because two or three books—even ones that become mandatory core reading—do not require freedom for the sake of still surprising readers after all the others. With detective novels following an established structure, however, the question becomes more difficult. Natural laws and historical facts often provide not merely restrictions, but a foundation for imagining the world.