Article Index

B TesztV6Back then, wizards could do many things, but quite a few spells explicitly said that wizards did not yet understand them. This was about more than game balance: it meant there were things to research, things to try to understand. The mosaic principle also appeared in Ynev's history, making many limitations comprehensible. Now, by contrast, the idea is to make the wizard capable of doing anything. I think of World of Darkness and the various incarnations of Mage, where magic has a completely different explanation and freeform magic is damned well nothing new. In fact, a precursor of freeform magic use was that in AD&D we could design new spells relatively freely too. It simply took time. Mage gives us a supernatural explanation of what is quick and why. Mosaic magic provided a rational explanation.

Until now, mosaic magic was a feature, not a bug. Even if M.A.G.U.S.'s most disagreeable trait arose from labeling many supposedly overpowered things “NPCs only.” And gradually grinding away the idea that in a life-path campaign, the aim was for the PC to become like the heroes of the novels. Mosaic magic's constraints often provided a foundation rather than a limitation. Of course, CODEX and the third-circle wizard can be mentioned too. Except that first, you had to become a second-circle wizard... Now it will be different. Nearly a hundred years will pass, and much can change in that time.

World and System

One of the biggest flame wars in this site's history arose from a very simple question: what is rare, and how rare? When are we talking about an interesting, creative character idea, and when about a “fucking special snowflake”? What makes a character realistic if some selection takes place, and how good should the character be in the attributes involved in that selection? 

Remember the picture at the beginning of the article? The first column represents 1%, the last 100%. You would call the 1% a flat coin, not a column. And say it is rare. Sometimes we are talking about only “half a percent,” or one in a thousand. Sometimes someone has searched among a hundred thousand people for the greatest talent. If I plotted a frequency of 1:100,000, the wafer, thinner than a hair, would look almost the same.

Yet those two almost identical wafers would differ by a factor of a thousand, while the current first and last columns differ by only a hundred. The 1:100 rarity, the thin little wafer, is something “you encounter every day,” perhaps more than once. If your warrior's strength or your witch's beauty is like that, it means little. If we are around 1:100,000? There is a good chance the character could be one of a city-state's champions.

And if the declared aim were for PCs to become heroes of Ynev comparable to the heroes of the novels, we would need the latter. 

A hundred Ynevian years, moreover, corresponds to more than 140 Earth years. Just look at how much even our own world changed between 1877 and 2017. Maps, power relations, and countless everyday objects were replaced. Such a jump is enough to count as a soft reboot. New Pyarron is no longer quite so new; it is not being built now. It may have had a considerable influence on the surrounding area's development and redrawn the map, to give just one example. But much time has passed in Yllinor too... For younger countries and cities, the geography changes as well. Different things are taught, the balance of power changes, we see different things. In other words, breakthroughs in magical development may occur too. Thus abandoning mosaic magic is acceptable if it is not retroactive.

Although until now it was understandable that someone emerging as a warrior from an army or fighting school wielded different power from someone emerging as a priest or wizard from an elite institution, a system seeking balance could be backed by a suitable concept within the world, even through literature. But right now we are not talking about literature serving the game, novels adapting to a conception of the world tailored to the game. We are talking about the opposite. About how a lack of creativity and individual solutions has often been patched over with ideas gathered here and there, with an “even more overpowered version” of a solution, and how the system wants to move toward that. Retroactively, I suspect.

But they do not want to throw away novel projects in progress or have a truly different world, and one suspects that bringing the world and the novels closer together is problematic given these considerations. All right, there is no Eighth Age, and the Flag War has not even begun. But the Manifestation War does not last that long, and if we follow the novels and the authors' previously described concepts and visions of the future, the map of southern Ynev has indeed been redrawn. The world envisioned for the end of the Manifestation War included, for example, the idea that Gorvik would largely cease to exist while Shadon's influence grew. But there will be a conversion to fit a Gorvik adventurer into an era in which they could not necessarily exist. If we discard the previously described future instead, however, we fail to bring the two points closer together. All right, a hundred Ynevian years could also be enough for a “New Gorvik” to emerge. But we are not seeing creative ideas about that, or short stories introducing such a world.

Forgive me for speaking a little programmer: mosaic magic is rather like a framework that is difficult to develop further, even harder to refactor, and whose workings we do not fully understand. Anyone not tied to this principle develops anything much more slowly, but does not have to contend with the framework's restrictions. Anyone who sticks with mosaic magic gets results faster—a spell does not take months—but must accept the limitations of the available elements. Where people saw the future, what they considered right and good, what they respected: this enriched sufficiently creative players' characters. Meanwhile, we could complain about the novels' sometimes rather one-dimensional heroes.

Under these circumstances, abandoning mosaic magic can certainly produce some fine arguments. Some say it grants freedom and serves creativity. Others point out that most people never even tried to use the mosaic principle truly creatively. Yet if we add its entire linguistic foundation—the spell is a sentence, we write down sentence fragments for the mosaics, see how the wizard tries to fill the gaps, allow research and the discovery of concepts—that makes room for creativity. Precisely because it was not “I saw or heard something, and my character just does it,” but required clever, creative solutions to many problems. And there was a goal. That mattered. So did the GM daring to say during a story: the player characters' story continues the writing of history.

And they were special. When people compare M.A.G.U.S. to AD&D or D&D, I usually point out the classic situation in which the (A)D&D character starts out very weak and does not stand out. Looking at NPC and PC combat values in the original core book, we see that here the adventurer was chosen from the outset. Their story was being written in that monastery for a reason. This too is a foundation of the M.A.G.U.S. feel, and precisely why many of us dared to be special. Yes, the stereotypical practitioner of empirical magic does not research, only uses it. But empirical magic was an important milestone in magical research. Its free and slow research, the associated goals, and numerous other things contributed to characters just as much as outstanding attributes did.

Giving wizards freedom instead of mosaic magic immediately kills these ideas. There is no need to choose among paths, and the character cannot be rare in where they end up. And in my view, if spells come quickly and freely, it becomes very difficult to maintain the idea that they really are terribly complicated, immediately raising the question: if it is this simple, why has everyone not become a wizard? Many new supernatural explanations can follow, of course... But this immediately changes the essence of Ynev and the game. 

Continuing to Write History