Article Index

In truth, I do know one solution. Computer-game developers realised that, although 3D puts greater strain on our machines, it makes development cheaper and easier. We have a multitude of models available that can be customised with all sorts of morphs, and with a nicely posed warrior we can switch the material to marble at any time. Not just a hundred different statues are possible; even a thousand is no problem. If the level designer is not lazy and the models and morphs are good, there is room for variety and visuals closer to what we imagine. If we work with prerendered content instead of beautifully drawn content, and have settings for a number of programs that let us render new content at any time, with plenty of assets that can be extended, resized and distorted gracefully, those boundaries can be pushed outward.

And nobody forbids us from using elements created this way, whether in this program or another. In that case, though, the ready-made content becomes less valuable, and almost every other program will be suitable too. Of course, I am not claiming with 100% certainty that you will agree with me on this. Simply because there will be three kinds of player. Some will dislike the easier route towards 3D in the first place. Some will have no problem with that, but, like me, will complain about the disharmony of mixing different styles. And some will marvel at seeing several different statues on the same battlemat: it signals variety, reflects the culture and so on. No fantasy map is perfect, and despite the inconsistent style it gives them more than they expected. 

What we expect here matters a great deal when it comes to extensibility. 

It would be easy to say that 3D is merely the easier route, since so many game developers choose it for that reason. But making a bar counter built out of walls and flooring behave differently from walls and floors for fog of war and occlusion, allowing differences in elevation between parts of a map, and showing those differences on the map would require more than a 2D approach working with prerendered images. That is where 3D enters the picture. 

Around a table, we have models, paper models and many ways to build simpler terrain, and can easily account for many of these considerations. Yet numerous VTT solutions are predominantly 2D. In many cases the visibility system does not know what would obscure what, because it lacks 3D models. What we see can therefore be misleading, and we have to work around this conflicting information to reach an intuitive understanding of what our character actually sees. Here the VTT solution is often not just a help but a serious complication too.

Arkenforge: MastersToolkit is a new program, with the opportunity to eliminate mistakes made by so many others. It can learn from those mistakes and from unique possibilities, and its engine can inspire the developer. But it is equally possible for it to become the umpteenth program retaining the same limitations for the same reasons, because its developers learned less from others' mistakes.

And make no mistake: even when an old program moves to a Unity-based solution, the old content was made according to the old design principles. It is very hard not only to replace the program, but also to open it up to handling other kinds of world and recreate successors to the existing content under entirely different design principles. So many things about the future of such a program are already decided around the release of its first version. Because changing the foundations would be too expensive and too difficult.

Arkenforge: MastersToolkit has chosen a difficult path. Most VTT solutions help when a group cannot or does not want to meet physically. There is no table, no opportunity to build a terrain table, no paper maps and no personal miniatures. Since there is no physical table, we cannot say, let us put a few books, boxes or anything else under the map's higher sections to help handle differences in elevation. We cannot say the room is 2D but the furniture consists of models... Arkenforge: MastersToolkit accepts that it will be used precisely when physical solutions may be its competition.

And excuse me, but here comes the brutal criticism: a hell of a lot of programs carry years or decades of burdensome legacy that restricts their concept, yet here, with a new program, we see no leap forward. Underneath it is a game engine that could handle destructible environments, which would be an enormous advance over paper, many other 2D programs and a host of other solutions. But the ambition does not reach very far, and even the things planned, such as regional maps, raise the question of how well they will be implemented. 

Because in my experience, a regional map can be harder than a world map, city map or encounter map. In many places, a mountain can be represented by a "mountain symbol", and these combine into beautiful mountain ranges. The trouble begins when that symbol would cover a quarter of our map: then we need a different tool. Contour lines capturing the mountain's shape, or many other options, come to mind, with waterways and many other layers overlaid, but achieving an acceptable result here is an awkward business. If we avoid relief, or the landscape is sufficiently flat, making the map interesting can be challenging, and the question is which tool we will use. The program would need to offer very good solutions for that. But that is still a long way off. 

From this perspective, making a 2D approach the program's basic concept is a very risky step. Naturally, there are advantages too. It serves beginners better while their tasks remain simpler, many people prefer the visual style it offers, and over the longer term, after optimisation, it will have lower hardware requirements. Within LEGO's range we expect different things from Duplo, LEGO City, LEGO Technic and LEGO Mindstorms sets. Each has its market. For people who do not want to GM online and are a little wary of VTT solutions, an entry-level solution and its simplicity will surely have value.

With this you learn part of the process of designing an environment, and can use other programs for the rest. Arkenforge: MastersToolkit is attractive, new, modern and easy to use, and does many beautiful things others cannot. It is the best of its kind in a market that looks as if everyone is making Duplo sets except one manufacturer who has reached LEGO City, while many people are waiting for Technic and Mindstorms. Perhaps using a few other solutions alongside one program would be enough for that, but we would need the ability to move a detail from one place, one map in a campaign, to another. The latter does not currently seem possible, while the former would require at least support for a resizable window. 

Let us hope the next versions will be prepared for this too.