The trigger-warning measures appearing in Vampire's 5th edition have often prompted the accusation that we are no longer meant to play vampires, that the horror no longer comes through, but instead... And anyone pointing out why all this would be alien to many vampires is absolutely right. But so is anyone saying this outlook is nothing new. After all, combining one vampire per 100,000 people with playing in your own familiar surroundings led to a situation where Miskolc, say, could have two vampires, three including its surrounding urban area, or, if the whole region counted, the five or six bloodsuckers making up the group. As starting characters, none has been a vampire for more than a few decades, and they still carry the habits of people today. 

So under this concept, we could immediately forget that most vampires were born in another age, and why that poses a problem. But it also occurs to us that this vampire did not previously spend decades as a ghoul. They would have different skills then, and perhaps more of them. Fine, though: we forget not only that, but also that when vampires are this rare, are not all Embraced at the same time, and do not all select candidates for the same trait, a vampire looking for intelligence can Embrace someone still available as a candidate after another vampire seeking strength or beauty considered them earlier. In other words, the new vampire is not the best out of 100,000 people, but potentially out of several million. Someone who would lose a bright future through the Embrace.

What do we get? Roughly the picture an average young person would write down about themselves. Of course, if they actually modelled themselves, play would reveal how many little one-point skills they had forgotten, so what we use is a truncated, simplified picture of an average student. And certainly not a third-year student somewhere with serious expectations. Rather, someone firmly convinced that demanding performance and objectivity is the work of the oppressive patriarchy; someone admitted through a diversity quota to a gender-studies course who represents the pinnacle of scholarship partly because they have published so much in journals that will print any rubbish on the subject. We are entitled to ask: why would we expect genuinely good roleplaying from this person, and why would their character be a truly well-played vampire?

The vampire stories used as source material, however, drew not on legends or harder horror stories, but on a few books whose homoerotic content appeals to young women hungry for romance just as much as it does to the female author. This tells us who Vampire's traditional target audience would be. That audience, however, can easily bring themselves into the game. And let us ask ourselves: if they see expectations of objectivity and performance as oppression, racism, sexism and so on, why would we expect any roleplaying performance from them in an RPG? If they are playing not a vampire but a teenager aspiring to study gender studies, do not want horror, and expect safe spaces and the heavy censorship that comes with them not only in literature classes but also at the gaming table, then this game mechanic is already justified.

The problem is that many people, having bought a bad product or service, or voted for the wrong party, tend to rationalise. Rationalisation can easily turn into fandom. A hell of a lot of people have therefore played the various editions of Vampire without belonging to this target audience, simply because they were unwilling to face the system's flaws and weaknesses. And of course fans readily build echo chambers, retreating into opinion bubbles made up of fellow fans defending the system. This kind of fandom can shatter when a new edition arrives. Some changes will be too much for part of the community, who begin criticising the new edition inside the bubble, and the echo chamber now echoes the negative opinion. As the pendulum swings back from the formerly overoptimistic, overly positive picture, the exaggeration remains; only now, many will emphasise the negatives to an irrational degree.

With D&D's 4th edition, the player community loudly criticised the designers' view that D&D is about killing terrible monsters and taking their treasure. After all, there is roleplaying, freedom and so much else. The criticism seemed justified and was loud. Except that the criticised statement had been made during the development of 3rd edition. That was when streamlining the game came to mean emphasising this concept and cutting away the "frills" that carried other values.

Of course, Hungary's M.A.G.U.S. has a characteristic problem too: although the concept behind the system has also changed over the years, a substantial part of its player community is trying to play a game whose real target audience they are not. It was the first game to appear, making it more or less everyone's default. In its more human-centred world, many wanted to beat up monsters, expected something different from the combat system, and had no interest in the magical theory or much of the concept behind its magic system. The result? They reshaped the system in their own image through house rules, until the collection of house rules was thicker than the official core book. 

The demand for safe spaces often arises beyond political questions: most people also cling to opinion bubbles around their favourite game, sports team or musical style. In roleplaying, though, preferences about play style matter. Some people find roleplaying boring, others combat. Some prefer winning, others feeling a chill. Some want powerful characters, others detailed ones, and others want to achieve things with weaker characters. The aim is to keep the balance between the positives and the necessary negatives optimal for the players and the GM. 

A trigger warning can also be about making the game more enjoyable for its players by reducing the proportion of disturbing elements. Which triggers must be avoided for that, and to what extent, is not about the players or the system-level options that help with this, but about the players. If trigger warnings come up and you need to flag something that might trigger the other person, with a concern that they could not tolerate it in the game, that depends on them and on the subject, rather than on the system. Blaming Vampire's 5th edition for this is therefore just as mistaken as criticising it for featuring the same kinds of characters as earlier editions. It is simply that this information, this cold reality, has now broken into many fans' subjective reality and upset it a little. Otherwise, not much has changed.