There are programs I certainly would not have bought on their commercial merits alone. At $30 on sale, this program is not expensive, but it is not the cheapest on the market either, since permanently free solutions also exist. And the various content packs soon follow. Wilderness support costs another $25, effects appropriate for magic $10, then music, this and that... Yet the program is still an alpha version, an Early Access offering we may have confidence in, and hope is heading in the right direction, but cannot know for sure. Testing it and trying it only costs time. When I happen to have some free. That is immediately promising. I go through registration and all the important steps. Download, then updates. I have a good hour to think.
PC and Mac: great, at first glance it is very cross-platform, and I am not the sort of person who immediately asks what about Linux support. Besides, I may prefer FreeBSD or OpenBSD to Linux anyway. My problem, however, is that when you dash off somewhere and put a screen on the table, there is a good chance it will be a tablet. Yet mobile platforms such as iOS and Android are not on the horizon for now. So while web-based solutions and those supporting a web client work in this situation, neither Arkenforge: MastersToolkit nor Fantasy Grounds nor Skwyre does. Roll20 supposedly does, and we have seen something similar with ScreenMonkey.
You would need a Windows tablet or a two-in-one with a dedicated graphics card. Older, lower-resolution devices will not do, because even the launcher would extend beyond the screen. So far this does not seem particularly appealing. Fortunately, AnyDesk, TeamViewer, Twitch, VNC and many other solutions can help you access an application running on a remote PC from a tablet or a TV. And of course you can build an old TV into a table. Just not an HD Ready one, because anything below Full HD still lacks the resolution. But the next blow soon arrives:
| Feature | Paper map / image file | Single-computer VTT | Networked VTT |
| Fog of war | Generally none; the game master can cover sections | Party-wide | Party-wide or per character |
| Moving miniatures | Anyone can move them | Depends on the input device | Everyone can control their own |
| Saving the current state | If you leave the table as it is, or make notes | Automatic | Automatic |
| Zoom | No | Yes | Yes |
| "Scrolling" | Move the map or lay out another section | Yes | Yes, with individual visibility |
| Works without power, for example in the woods | Yes | No | No |
| Works without internet | Yes | Yes | If it supports LAN play |
| People can sit around a "large map" on a table | Yes | Yes | One extra client |
| Individual copies of the map | Yes, as handouts | Exported... See left | Depends on the licence, or exported |
As we can see, the game master will be moving the miniatures, because there are not many affordable touchscreen solutions that allow an alternative. Of course, the second display can show the players' map and the first the GUI, but if we have one screen and the players' own devices do not supplement it, line of sight and fog of war will not be tied to individual characters. We understand the difference. We feel the extra work and the extra restrictions.
For players to make plans on some of the maps, such as the map of their estate, they need to own the program too. In fact, they need all the purchased content as well. All content is tied to the program and comes in its format, creating strong platform lock-in in many cases. The question is how significant the price difference of less than $10 compared with Fantasy Grounds really is. Is it worth the differences above?
Talking to the developers, of course, I hear that they are cheaper than Campaign Cartographer. It may do more for mapmaking, but it has no music and lacks some other VTT support. Granted, there is no rules-system handling here yet either, but Arkenforge: MastersToolkit does other things too and is cheaper. True enough: between $30 with the discount, $35 without it, and Campaign Cartographer 3+'s price of almost £30, or almost $37.50, the difference is roughly the price of a gyros. And with the GM moving tokens around, you have to save the image again and share it to the display in question, while the music comes from YouTube.
What costs money everywhere is content.
What costs money everywhere is content. $25 for wilderness art assets? £14.95 for a Symbol Set pack, or £27.95 for something as powerful as City Designer 3. And its PNG symbols can easily be moved into other programs. In Early Access, this is nine dollars cheaper than the mature Fantasy Grounds, including basic, SRD-level support for a few systems.
What Arkenforge can do, however: although the import dialog is currently quite awkward, inserted content can be an .mp4 animation or movie as well as a PNG or JPG. Important, relevant information for anyone thinking about animation: animated GIFs are not supported. By the time you have thought all this through, patching is complete. Especially since it became much faster after I complained about it.