Article Index

My first example is Shadowrun, using third-edition terminology but also referring to supplements from second edition. A curious concept exists: astral background count. Strangely, it is an almost perfect example even when it does not appear directly. Many say background count interferes with magicians. But what else does it do? It can strengthen other magicians, for example! Magic may even be generally unavailable in the world, yet available in particular places and at particular times precisely because of their associated background count.

Astral background count is probably simply a manifestation of the world being shaped by people's beliefs. Where people endure many horrors, they see the world as far worse and crueler, perhaps imagining “demons” behind it... Thus they place the location under toxic spirits' dominion and strengthen darker idols and traditions. For others, however, the situation is somewhat alien. Interpret magical theory's foundations as above, and background count works precisely as described. It even explains pre-Awakening magic. Or something harder still: how the Great Ghost Dance worked.

Thanks to the internet and cable channels created by market demand, news of any perceived or real paranormal phenomenon could reach wider audiences, leading more people to believe in the mystical forces behind them. Magic began to return. Native Americans in “concentration camps,” envisioning angry spirits and turning more strongly to traditional beliefs as they fought for their identity against reeducation, could easily generate increasingly strong background count and magic across an expanding area.

Meanwhile, “mining” raw materials becomes profitable even where it was previously too risky. People therefore perceive angry nature as a mystical force behind more accidents. Interest in every accident, storm, and natural disaster grows, favoring similar magic globally too. The Great Ghost Dance becomes possible. And convinces everyone that magic has returned. Belief and magic change in the blink of an eye.

I do not claim this is the only explanation, or even that the creators would explain it this way. I do claim almost every supplement and adventure story fits. We understand why Harlequin can discuss the Horrors' return, and why everything from cinema onward shapes magic. Numerous adventures can build on magical research. For anyone exploring magic's nature within a magical campaign, this approach can provide an excellent explanation.

Background count familiar from Shadowrun can therefore be a useful reference when running many other worlds, and excellent adventures can build on this concept in numerous games. It easily connects to time-related superstitions and astrology, which can create background count similarly. I mean not only comets, but monsters or ancient gods waiting among the stars until the right conjunction, kept away from our world, and numerous other things from many similar games.

Spellcasting then need not be mysterious; often it concerns understanding and deliberately exploiting interactions between ideas, spirits, metaplanes, and so forth. Of course, no magic-user knows everything, so some mystery remains. Even more remains around ancient spells and magical items whose workings and reasons are unknown. Magic, if sufficiently rare, can indeed be wondrous.

The workings of many ancient forms of magic may be unknown, bringing the Faustian bargain back into the picture. As does someone deliberately shaping the world to make their own spellcasting easier, building on fear and pain. Numerous darker stories can be built on this. Creating adventures from such situations does not seem difficult.

Religious wars in fantasy worlds primarily concern which religion's ideology should govern the world's workings, and which deity the world's “idea” should resemble. This resemblance allows the deity's power to reach fulfillment throughout the world. The deity itself may change meanwhile, of course. The ability to change the world can be the true measure of power in many settings: a natural, simple measure. In classical monotheism, control over the world means connecting the world's “idea” to that faith and its laws, extending the laws dictated by belief throughout the world.

Ideas can encompass races and peoples as well as the world, making racial or cultural pantheons readily acceptable. An object may connect to several deities, or two similar objects may fall under different deities' influence simply because they were made or located in different places.

Most ideas are partly constructed by belief. Some think primal earth consists of spectacular crystals; others think it is polished smooth like a pebble. Both thoughts affect primal earth's idea. This makes wizardly magic uncertain, but says something relatively important about priestly magic. Faith does not primarily mean believing a deity exists, but believing the deity and its influence to have a particular nature.

Important questions include how much we believe the deity is right, how good we think its rule is, and how much we want to entrust control over particular objects and ideas to it. This faith and trust often require some credibility. Since deities rarely appear directly, maintaining that image is largely the church's job. But preaching water while drinking wine does not work here. A priest does not please their god through words or mere ecclesiastical service.

Mere ecclesiastical service makes the deity impersonal. Believers would cease truly believing doctrines and principles. They would believe that if they went to the temple, the priest would help them. Instead of the god, they would try to attach influence over the world to the church's idea, and many priests would become priests of the church instead. Priests need followers to see what their god is like: which principles and person belief should connect to the world's things. Thus priests of real gods represent their deity more than they perform ecclesiastical service.

But belief can plainly attach ideas not only to deities, but to church teachings and influence. There, the priest, church, and name behind it—many naming a deity while thinking of the church—bestow favor in exchange for donations and service. A system of service and grace may emerge. Pacts with other beings and Faustian bargains may influence the church; dark secrets may exist. People may kill and sacrifice humans, sometimes to a demonic helper, in a nonexistent figure's name, turning the church into a deity functioning as one enormous mass.

Such a church instinctively fears magic-users, who might recognize the magical laws sustaining its power and expose or even replicate its fraud. Do we know such a deity from a game? Perhaps. In some, the concept supposedly “present from the beginning” describes the same religion first as a false faith with no god behind it, then invents something that exists but is not what they discuss, and finally says monotheism claiming “exclusive” power is true after all—truer than the others, even. There can be much confusion, with everyone claiming the current concept is the original.

The beauty of the concept developed here is precisely that it describes numerous worlds and answers troubling questions. It explains a false faith's possible secret and what supplies priestly magic in such cases. Why would a god's followers not fight? Make no mistake: independently of the above, two situations are possible. Either they deliberately avoid learning to fight and shun combat, their priests preferring death to becoming weapon-wielders who no longer represent their god, so almost none become adventurers viable in combat. Or they accept priests learning to fight and representing the church as fighters too. In that case, however, this example and characters becoming heroes through it affect the world.

A world's creator can take either direction. But when a writer or writer-turned-developer claims a third mutually contradictory concept is the original, offering only their own authority as its justification, I struggle to believe they are developing their world consistently. This applies equally to GMs and amateur and professional developers. And I will not call it “unimportant.” These fundamental magical laws and conceptions of primal elements, gods, and totems define roleplaying magic-users and priests. The relationships analyzed here can matter to such characters.

Naturally, we could discuss the relationship between outer planes and belief, pair magical-theory foundations with the alignment system, or ask whether Drizzt truly has a good alignment. We could discuss ideological wars in individual worlds, or explain how the disturbing contradictions players notice arise. We may reach the point where this brief introduction to magical theory helps prevent many mistakes. Of course, much remains to add. The question of age-related ideas, for example. We could discuss a consequence-oriented method of worldbuilding and many other details. But those belong to subsequent articles.