Stupid stereotypes exist. For example, the many depictions of armor emphasizing the shape of breasts. Or the physics-based arguments of people protesting against them: physics would make many imagined suits of fantasy armor like these lethally dangerous in reality, so surely they would not exist. Why? Was smearing wounds with excrement in many cases not lethally dangerous? Yet superstition led many people to try it. In an age of deadly medical treatments, unrecognized relationships would supposedly deter someone from wearing the armor. Of course they would. 

When we think of full armor, most people immediately mix together armor intended for battle, tournament armor designed for particular events, and ceremonial armor and associated weapons worn primarily as decoration and signs of status. I find it a curious argument that, for ceremonial or decorative armor with no combat function, the decisive design consideration should be what is optimal in battle according to physical principles unknown in that world. Here, the danger is supposed to be an absolute constraint, while the period's deadly medical treatments continue to spread.

Armor needs thick clothing underneath, if we are talking about realism. Even if the design shows bumps where the breasts would be, their function is decorative. Little of the breasts would show through the thick woolen cloth in the first place, so they are not what fills those visible bulges in the armor. Whether there is also a “wedge shape” on the inside, or whether the inner surface is smoother and distributes the load evenly, is something we cannot see from outside. Invoking this makes a resounding argument, but there is little basis for talking about the wedge when we do not know whether one is there. Assuming it is therefore unnecessary. 

The question of where armor directs an attack does matter to some extent, even if the attack usually does not penetrate the armor in such cases. Apparent vulnerability, however, shapes the fight. For a unit of women warriors whose unusual fighting style surprises many opponents, such armor also serves recognition. If many fear them, demoralizing the enemy can provide an advantage too. Regarding armor-piercing attacks that threaten the heart, let us ask what protection is provided by a substantial amount of extra padding between two metal plates over the heart, which may stop the attack.

Because the “breast-shaped” plate merely supplements the “unisex” layer beneath it. This shape, stuffed with thick padding inside, can provide some protection and cause some harm. If the armor's shortcomings “kill” someone, many will regard that as a flaw in that particular piece. If the extra layers of the women's order's armor stop an attack, they will undoubtedly see it as an advantage of the design.

And there is a small problem with the question of what directs a weapon's point where: either engraving or the edge of a raised decoration can direct the point somewhere. If armor is decorated, there will be concave areas in bad places, and an attack guided between the ribs toward the heart is no better than one guided toward the sternum. Yet ornate armor, which likewise gives a weapon places to catch and can sometimes create life-threatening problems, is accepted. Of all the dangerous decorations, why do we concern ourselves only with the breast-shaped one? 

Advantages and disadvantages appear in different proportions in battle, in tournaments, and in situations where wearing armor is merely part of protocol—a status symbol, a piece of jewelry. But they also depend on fighting style, the enemy's weaponry, and psychological effects on the opponent. Armor that protects its wearer thirty times where conventional armor would not—sometimes by frightening an enemy away, sometimes by stopping a projectile headed for the heart—but once dangerously guides an attack into the sternum still has a positive balance. This differs from finely worked dwarven armor with engravings and therefore sharp lines. Its pattern can guide a blade that would otherwise slide off in various directions, but would rarely stop an attack the way the bulge described here might.

Would someone be wise to single out a few disadvantages of one decoration while ignoring the disadvantages of other decorations and the advantages of this one? Even when the physics is unknown in their era, they do not understand it, and have no reason to account for it? In other words, they completely disregard what people in that world would realistically base decisions on, and the fact that, for armor primarily intended as decoration and a status symbol, many risks would not be considered anyway because they are not known. 

The argument above applies to low fantasy, even without magic, allowing only the differences in society, history and the development of weapons and armor needed to raise the question. In a more magical fantasy world, numerous natural laws may work differently; even the strength of the creative will behind armor and weapon may clash. On Earth, however, the considerations are mostly different. 

By the time rigid armor developed, counters to it existed too, and its safety was nowhere near proportionate to its cost. Female weapon-users were rare, and even when valuable in that role, such heavy armor would not necessarily have suited them. By the time many forms of rigid armor appeared, other, better options were available... There was simply no reason for women's armor to develop. Unisex armor worked as well as needed, and there were not many women warriors who required it. If we think of antiquity, armor was not rigid in most cases, so the clothing underneath left little opportunity for feminine curves to show. Where armor was rigid, a simple shape was important there too. They could not have made anything else. 

The only period on Earth when women warriors appeared in large numbers, some kind of armor protected them, and both physical and anatomical knowledge existed to weigh all the consequences of the design is the modern era. Modern armor is made not from steel but from Kevlar, ceramic inserts and non-Newtonian fluids. The last of these has a role in close combat. 

Here too, impact forces are distributed, a wedge pressing into the sternum is avoided, and many other details are considered. But we see that specifically female armor has indeed appeared. Eighty percent of this is not about breasts but about a different skeleton and the anatomical adjustments it requires. Yet because less clothing is worn underneath, and designers want to distribute loads evenly over the bones, the shape of the breasts is often taken into account too. 

Armor matching fantasy stereotypes was never developed: its inner and outer form never became established, centuries never refined it, and there is no long experience of its use. We cannot easily assess its psychological effect when associated with a famous or infamous military force. In an alternative history that allows such armor, we do not know which would happen more often: attacks guided toward the sternum, or ranged weapons penetrating the outer layer but being stopped—with a sufficiently thick, well-padded section, even a bullet's energy could be absorbed. So it is utterly pointless to declare whether armor must be unisex or not.

But hold on a moment. Most arguments break out when someone remarks that a woman wearing rigid armor is also a difficult proposition because good female full armor may not have developed in that world. That is not about whether forging those two bumps is difficult. It is about three or four things:

  • The answers to the questions above may not be known in that world. Armor made for a woman could be lethally dangerous. Yes, even because of the wedge mentioned by opponents of fantasy armor, whose danger nobody in that world considers... But the craftsman wants to produce beautiful work.
  • If we want bumps like these on the armor, they are not hard to make. But women's different proportions, different skeletons and different load-bearing capacity can trip up the armorer. That is the difficulty with women's armor. Steering the discussion toward the bumps is evasion.
  • Even if many tomes contain the answers and explain how to accommodate the skeleton, does the available smith know them? Have they read every such work?
  • Since such things are rarely made in many worlds, if there is a 150-year-old description accounting for the different skeleton and answering every question above, a smith working from it gives the wearer precisely a 150-year disadvantage...

And one small observation to finish: in many cases, the model used as a basis for drawing is itself a rendered image. In many available tools, such as Poser and DAZ Studio, clothing follows the body's contours and morphs, making feminine armor easier for the artist to draw. Different worlds, artistic freedom and so on are also reasons, but many of the points above are enough for such armor to be made in the world and therefore appear in pictures.

But there is a more important consideration: the player does not necessarily know what a world considers “a feminine warrior in feminine armament.” To create that impression of a character, the description or picture often needs a little sleight of hand, bringing the character's and player's natural impressions closer together. This lens can also justify many depictions regarded as fundamentally unrealistic. 

For most claims, it is not enough to recognize that there is a situation in which they are true; we must also assess when they are true. If we say the typical women's armor in fantasy pictures is nonsense, that applies if it is not decorative armor; the risks are known and seriously considered, more so than with other decorations; yet a wedge-shaped interior still appears unnecessarily; anatomical knowledge reveals no other differences; and the design dangerously guides attacks the wrong way more often than it catches projectiles... That is a lot of conditions.

And honestly, I find the assumption that “they know the danger but are too stupid to reinforce the armor in the right place and make it smoother inside” unlikely. Still, if that condition is met too, it is easy to see that there is a perspective from which armor like this is nonsense. But by selecting strange boundary conditions that largely contradict one another and adjusting the viewpoint of the assessment to the desired result, you can demonstrate quite a lot of things. In this case, however, what you can say is that a deliberately stupid smith is always dangerous, and choosing their work is always nonsense. 

But let us ask: if someone knows that the wedge-shaped part inside is dangerous, knows the underclothing makes it unnecessary and that the breast shape is merely decoration, would there be a wedge? Would they not reinforce the armor in preparation for many “weapons guided that way”? Would those weapons really penetrate it there? Would the extra padded layer really stop no other life-threatening attack? Would it actually guide the attack all the way to the sternum, or would other decorations also direct the attacking weapon so it could be handled safely, perhaps even broken? That padded cavity could also contain grids to help with this. 

Suppose a character says the armor is flat inside. The breast-shaped decoration is attached separately; it is openwork, with numerous grid structures behind a flesh-colored insert to catch and break weapons heading for the heart, elastic layers between them for padding, and so on. The armor is reinforced in the appropriate places, there is no wedge, and many flexible attachments help absorb the force of blows... They have thought about it, have a creative idea, and there has long since ceased to be a wedge inside. If another player then invokes talk of the wedge, their “experience” or a “weaponsmith,” the creative player will be right.