Several ideas affect an object. When we create it, all appear; we have “recalled” every spirit. If they influence one another and their surroundings, magic-users will sooner or later discover how these ideas work. Among the recognized ideas will certainly be those of numerous natural phenomena and particular properties of objects. These primal ideas, rarely occurring independently, belong to the primal elements. Most worlds' mythologies contain primal fire, air, water, and earth. They recur because they cover most properties of objects.
Pure energy not yet turned into matter, not “under material spirits' dominion,” can appear as a single form or with two polarities. Many would connect life force to a “wood” element, which may or may not be separate from pure energy. Usually it is not, partly because the idea creating a “spirit,” and through it matter, from pure force may also relate to life. Stronger and weaker spirits can be considered here too.
We know ideas express themselves in the world. Thus creatures of nonmaterial planes acquire material forms when entering material planes. The material manifestations of primal ideas behind simple phenomena may be the “primal elements.” Heat, with all its properties, may become primal fire, and creatures of the material world experience it this way even on nonmaterial planes.
These properties and ideas appear in matter, so to a wizard matter is composed of primal elements. If we disregard deeper magical relationships and retain only interactions between spirits and ideas, using these to produce changes, we arrive at alchemy. Does chemistry exist alongside alchemy? Can alchemy exist alongside chemistry?
Many people may begin understanding matter, associating ever more concepts with it. They discover cells within wood and recognize their parts. Eventually they may reach concepts such as atoms and molecules. These concepts and ideas also acquire “power” over matter, creating modern chemistry's foundation. We organize atoms' ideas into a system, understand their workings, and try to divide them into parts. This creates new ideas. At this point, modern chemistry and magic begin to intermingle.
But we cannot “disintegrate a particular group of atoms,” because we cannot name each atom precisely or know exactly where it is. We can target only larger ideas we can grasp. Thus whole objects and modern chemistry can become compatible. The possibility exists in both Shadowrun and Mage. This allows a Sixth World alchemist to create magical materials impossible according to modern chemistry.
We must accept, however, that these ideas, like polytheistic gods and so forth, are likewise artificial and depend partly on people's generally accepted system of symbols or paradigm. Water will not consist of hydrogen and oxygen in every world. Indeed, in many places it does not even consist of molecules, but may be a continuous medium. This often makes it impossible for a wizard to create “atomic bomb,” “black hole,” or similar spells. Simply because even the “foundations” of the missing ideas are absent.
If they cannot introduce those ideas and have “belief”—interaction between spirits—support and strengthen them, they will not suddenly invent such things. Magical science too develops only gradually. Many groups shape the world in different directions, introducing different ideas and concepts. Competition among those shaping the world takes many forms. It happens differently in a fantasy world, differently in World of Darkness, and so on. The list continues. Sol's introduction to Mage explains more about the WoD example.
In any case, seeing multiple structures of matter appear is interesting. Materials and objects must nevertheless obey every structure-of-matter law characteristic of the world. Energy cannot be purer than pure energy merely because many people see the world differently. Many see it differently, recognize different elements, and try to construct things differently.
Magic faces a serious problem: it is not available to everyone. Over long periods, it changes society. Mortality becomes less troubling, people learn more, and society will not be truly medieval. This pace of development, even if catastrophes occasionally slow it or push society back to an earlier level, eventually leads to methods available to the masses.
Herbalism and medicine appear, then simple and more complex mechanics. Sophisticated siege engines are built, warships improve, and new forging procedures emerge. Peoples learning about matter can use more chemical reactions, and the world gradually changes. Everything magic cannot make available to everyone, but sufficiently simple technological tools can, slowly spreads. Conversely, where even technological means do not make something available to a broad public, less efficient new technologies appear less often. This strongly restrains technological development.
So does the brain drain toward wizard schools, which offer most intelligent people their best chance to prosper. These factors suffice to slow development considerably. A truly technological civilization therefore emerges only with great difficulty. This affects many things. It is why many fantasy worlds remain fantasy worlds for millennia, and why magi fearing technological civilizations may defeat or rule them. The world is static to this extent.
Of course, this does not last tens of thousands of years either. A world on the brink of collapse for so long is unlikely to remain unchanged in many respects. Technological development generally accompanies social change too. I know, I know: some games maintain stability despite all this, without visible reason. The world's characteristics must remain for the player's sake, since the brand promises particular values. Concepts, play styles, and so forth also attach to that brand.
Yet overall I say it is realistic to assume the world changes. Sometimes that change happens strangely indeed. We should discuss not primarily the odd changes introduced by new editions, but their consequences. Change appears step by step. Take an example without naming the game system. If someone recognizes it, that must surely be coincidence. Or simply because the observation fits the system.
Initially, the world's creators do not intend every religion's priests to be playable, believing certain priests or priestesses would make poor player characters. Combat is alien to that deity's followers; they do not learn to fight or possess knowledge worthy of adventurers. They simply would not survive or become heroes while remaining faithful to the world. But players complain that particular religions are the creators' favorites and others are unfairly neglected. Some later editions heed the criticism and change things. Followers of certain religions become viable adventurers, even excellent fighters. Even if someone says that although they wrote this, they did not mean it that way. Player characters' actions are shaped by their abilities and adventures, not developers' unwritten thoughts.
The problem is not that this temporarily sets an example, or that such characters acquire a follower or two. It is that the faith's heroes thereby become more martial, changing the religion. Along with faith, the church changes, as do the ideas associated with that deity. This can often lead to rivalry between churches, religious wars, even the pantheon's disintegration. A developer saying they did not want or imagine such a world is pointless: individual changes' consequences must also be considered. Someone unable to account for consequences is unfit to be a developer. That simple. Just as a good developer's most important characteristic is the ability to account for every consequence of their written ideas and accept them without reservation.
Just as belief creates gods in many fantasy worlds, elsewhere—for example Shadowrun—it defines idols' and totems' traits, while in other cases it influences the world differently. Even one small event or change can then initiate unpredictable processes. In this situation, a priest serves their deity less and represents it more, directing followers' belief in that way too. It matters that when followers speak their god's name, they truly think of that god and its domain.
Is this only about priests? “Gratuitously bashing” two or three creators? It is far more about the world itself changing: different ideas and spirits stand behind the same object in different eras, often requiring spells to change too. This highlights an important point: wizards' science must keep pace with changes in the world. If a wizard adapts more slowly than the world changes, their power diminishes. Wizards may consequently have been mightier in ancient times. In antiquity, this might have let one race prevail over another, while today wizards' advantage is less clear.
Much instinctive magic adapts almost immediately, but potentially stronger—or more readily strengthened—conscious magic requires serious research to develop. If wizards devote insufficient time to it, they regress despite continual improvement. Technology that everyone understands and believes in, however, does not change; progress there takes fewer twists and turns. The “knowledge of ordinary mortals” ensures stability and safety.
As the world changes, previously safe forms of magic can become dangerous; spells describing the world incorrectly may “tear holes in reality's fabric.” One system knows this as demons—CODEX—another as paradox—Mage—while elsewhere using uncertain but sometimes stronger spells is treated as a separate school. Numerous further examples could be listed. But magic's limitations are clear too. It is not especially stable. This is why studying earlier magical forms interests wizards: though they cannot be applied directly, understanding their relationships may bring a discovery still usable today closer.
An important question is how a character perceives these changes. What does the wizard see of them?