Article Index

Many say little knowledge is necessary: the world's god of magic may be good, giving everyone reason to trust that magic entails no Faustian bargain. Is this true? If even one kind of “evil magic” works in the world, more may work too, and a spell constituting a Faustian bargain may appear at any time. Someone who knows only black and white can easily be convinced that even dark gray is not black, and readily enter a very dangerous Faustian bargain.

Do we doubt it? One real-life example suffices. Someone driven by faith to send—or force—their child to a church school, without asking questions or even believing children's complaints, can easily find themselves discovering only afterward that their children were molested at the elite school. How many deeply religious parents accepted a church school's perceived or real benefits even at an unknown price? Their children paid that price. Did their faith protect them?

PriestA fantasy world can, of course, have priestly magic. Religion there is not merely a matter of faith, since individual gods' existence can be proved. Faith and evidence-based knowledge are not necessarily identical. Explaining what faith means in such circumstances, how a church can be corrupt—if a priest receives no power, that becomes apparent—and what a believer's or priest's faith means there is interesting. A difficult question. For now, however, let us ask differently: would this certainty rule out such Faustian bargains? That largely depends on the church, priests, and gods they honor.

If the church checks every spell every wizard learns using priestly magic, while being certain its own magic is pure, such traps can be avoided. But where is that monitoring? For every new piece of research? And surely the church's all-seeing eye and total control would hardly help create a good world. We would prefer many friendly priests who do not suspect every wizard and do not seem prejudiced. In other words, even with the best intentions, tight ecclesiastical and divine control seems unworkable. That leaves the other solution: a wizard who checks their own magic, knows magical theory, and can debate it.

We accepted that the best case makes naming the target, substance, and effect an important element of magic. A magical system of symbols grasps objects, substances, and effects through function and name. Such magic can not only target and identify, but “recall” and summon, create, or shape the named object or effect from existing objects. Naming-based magic, the gift of tongues, idea magic: we can list concepts built precisely on this, as is the focus used in Mage. The systems resemble one another, but are far from identical.

Animals mark their territories with urine. Humans give them names. Changes in place names matter for precisely this reason: whoever can rewrite a place's name also rules it. One curious feature of contemporary politics is renaming public places after major changes in power. Costs do not matter then. Even amid the greatest economic troubles, time is found for this ritual. Does a regime care about “ruling” through its own naming, or merely overwriting a name given by someone else? There are examples of both.

Naming, understanding, ruling... This ritual extends to numerous things. It is said that knowing a spirit's true name lets us rule it too. In many mythologies, every object, living being, and place has a spirit. The names used naturally depend on the particular faith's teachings. These mythological “beings” appear in many roleplaying worlds too, though they do not necessarily constitute objects' essence there; sometimes they are merely ordinary entries in a monster book. If, however, these spirits are objects' essence, and affecting a spirit lets us affect its object—its worldly embodiment—we have already reached a foundation for magical theory.

If natural phenomena also possess ideas, we obtain the primal elements and their associated elementals. There is one familiar point, though certainly not the last. We now see that shamans too speak, in some form, of “local spirits” constituting beings' essence. Japanese Shinto practitioners know them as kami (神), while Sanskrit calls similar spirits or deities deva (देव). Hinduism applies this term to all good spirits.

Does “devil” derive from Greek diabolos, or rather from deva's feminine form, devi? A good question; I have heard good arguments for both explanations. Where did Christianity encounter Indian myths? With the arrival of Roma tribes, for example. They already used devla rather than deva, and also spoke of gods as Devel and Del. To Christianity, devel represented a “false, pagan god.” Diabolus, its derivative deofol, or teufel in German-speaking areas—a name known from more than Macskafogó—often sounded similar too. And “Satan” was indeed a false god.

The site will eventually discuss the origin of the Hungarian word ördög, originally “őr dög,” a kind of guardian spirit; someone else is writing that article. Names become distorted and acquire new meanings. If beliefs and names' meanings change, does that somehow affect the spirit and, through it, the phenomenon appearing in the world? Does the practice of newer “good” religions portraying earlier “good” powers as evil have a rationale?

I must say that according to most fantasy worlds' reality, it does. Indeed, we often hear that a world's gods owe their existence and power primarily to their number of followers. How is this possible? Many say belief unites the person with the concept they embody. In a typical fantasy game, this is why one deity rules lightning and another fire. Indeed, they do not merely rule it; they constitute that thing's idea. We see an interesting aspect of possession and dominion through names.

This also explains priests' most important duty, and why most priests spread the truth about their religion. Not necessarily, though: the religion can be presented as greater, or even “the only one,” and that connection built. It will simply be relatively difficult to challenge other faiths in doing so. This makes polytheism and monotheism coexisting conceivable. Although a prayer must be sufficiently true to strengthen the god, shaping belief can also expand—or narrow—the deity's power.

This concept fits many games, and interestingly also helps explain what a good priest does for their god, why they study, and what they receive for it. Even why priestly and wizardly magic work similarly in many systems. It also explains how deities can be defeated, even through magic.

An interesting feature is that an object need not have only one idea. A latch exists independently but is also part of a lock, door, house, and even the world. The spirit giving an object its essence may be an unconscious essence, an intelligent local spirit, or a nameable, knowable deity or totem. Strangely, a latch involves not only these spirits, but its material's spirit too. If the material consists of elements, their spirits enter as well.

Elements compete with one another, while many other ideas affect matter... Many systems distinguish materials somehow and make creating “nobler” materials harder. There are two explanations: economic and magical-theoretical. Economically, I would say useful materials harder to create will also be more expensive and valuable. The other explanation is more interesting: a weaker, less powerful spirit is less able to “claim” an object exclusively, which will characterize apparently composite materials such as wood or stone. Stronger spirits may lead to purer, more ordered, nobler materials. Stronger spirits are harder to summon or recall.

Viewed this way, the relationship many systems establish between materials' value and the difficulty of creating them can be explained on this basis. Whether M.A.G.U.S.'s material groups, gold-value limits for material creation, or something else, any can derive from this concept. It may also explain why so many magical devices, religious relics, and so forth are made from such materials.

Interestingly, composite materials do not require complete dominion over the material present. Despite contamination, imprecision, and other remaining influences, wood remains wood, only a little different. With diamond, errors would have more serious consequences. That too is why a material spirit must dominate the matter more thoroughly for everything to be perfect. Stronger dominion, stronger spirit, and such materials are harder to affect magically.

But will such nobler materials also be rarer? That primarily depends on what we believe about spirits' strength. Two views are possible. One holds that, as in many places, a normal distribution applies. Most materials are average. Far-below-average “cursed” materials are as rare as those with favorable properties. Only the latter, however, cost more than ordinary materials because of their rarity. The second assumption is that all material spirits “start” equally strong, but some develop further. Basic strength is most common; every strength above it grows progressively rarer. We see not a bell curve but a pyramid diagram representing social stratification.

The point remains the same: truly good material is probably rare and correspondingly expensive. Monetary value and properties are related. Even spells “capable of creating X gold pieces' worth” have some rationality. These relationships provide the foundation a wizard needs. Questions of matter's structure can effectively be bypassed. We need only accept that the wizard affects these spirits or ideas, and the rest follows automatically. Without this, even creating a piece of wood would be difficult, would it not? Apparently this knowledge suffices. Individual spirits may nevertheless have secrets, and the wizard's knowledge may have gaps. Mysterious details may remain.

But what does the wizard know about the structure of matter? Can technology rival magic? More on the next page.