Article Index

Game balance and a little statistics

We know the basic concept: now there will be game balance. Someone will always complain. Uh-huh. In a "typical" adventure module with lots of fighting, combat values are truly valuable. But in an investigative adventure to be completed with "almost no combat", +10 TÉ is worth exactly as much as in an adventure whose main antagonist is called wind, rain or snow because the characters must contend with the weather. Until you know what kinds of adventures the group enjoys and what the game master will run, you have no chance of assessing the value of +10 TÉ. Good balance would be difficult on that basis. And we have not yet accounted for different combos, limitations arising from alignment or the players' many aptitudes. No wonder people argue back and forth about balance.

One player says their spells mainly deal damage, summon things and harm the enemy, whereas the priest can heal and fight a little too. It would be unfair for the priest to do similar damage with spells. The priest, meanwhile, sees themselves as poor at combat yet often forced into it, because they must reserve their magical power and the divine favour behind it for healing. On the very rare occasions they can deal damage with prayers, they should not lag behind a practitioner of experiential magic. The priest can easily argue that, when they finally get to do damage with prayers, it would be nice to stand out on that rare occasion; it is unfair that the warlock overshadows them even then. Both players' arguments are convincing. What would balance look like here? There will always be tantrums. 

You can, however, assess how often particular abilities generally come into play for characters at different levels and groups with different experience and needs. It is worth assessing how common the Time Gate spell is, given that it requires a level-22 priest. Most groups presumably do not often have high priests more powerful than Mogorva Chei in their vicinity. Likewise, some magic items are highly unlikely to be used in most groups. 

Make a table showing how often, on average, each ability, spell, magic item, skill and so on appears in one hundred hours of play for each typical kind of group.

Forget Dreonar

You can influence what players use and how often by the adventures you make available, perhaps bundled with the core book itself. Do not try to save money here: by the time the core book appears, have several adventures ready, some free and some as publications to buy. Before you say I have put the cart before the horse, or that I quickly moved from mathematics, statistics and foundations to inconsequential adventures, let me point out two things. First, working on adventures also helps you assess what will inevitably appear in play even in the short term. Second, you shape that for most of the community. More experienced players and game masters can decide whether to supplement the system for themselves.

The point is that a system includes more than what you write down. It includes how it is used. If many incompatible additions appear, and differently interpreted rules produce a tangled chaos where players can be sure of almost nothing, that would hardly be ideal. Equally, the number of people playing the system and the difficulty of finding a group are part of it too. If you need an example adventure, it is worth making a few sample characters and including simple descriptions of their spells and skills, plus a little straightforward rules explanation. But keep plan B in place. If you lose the rights, you should be able to bring most people over to your own world. The aim is for nobody to have an interest in taking away your rights, while you remain prepared for it. And not only legally. 

Look beyond the first book

There is Becoming One, there is the Kiss of Transformation, and a wizard can also "remote-control" an animal with some mental magic. But how well have they learned to use wings? How do they handle updraughts? Do they know that even a bird can stall? I have to say that skills suited to an animal body would be useful. So might descriptions of the simple skills learned by the character's cat, practically a member of the family. The ability to communicate with more intelligent-than-average animals would not hurt either. But it would be foolish to hold a new core book accountable for lacking this. Not everything belongs in a core book.

A New Bestiary, though? A different matter. It is more important there. Why? When creating a system, an important task is imagining which supplements make it "complete" and, once they do, where further expansion might fit. I know many people say there is always room for a book describing subclasses within classes, but even that need not operate at the level of Priests and Paladins. Above all, it need not give new names to existing skills, spectacularly demonstrating that the supplement's creators do not know the system they are contributing to. 

If a religion supplement's concept is not "there is a goddess of infidelity, but we call a different goddess unfaithful... there is a priestess who never learns to fight, but has a few Weapon Use skills on top of the priest's basic skills and can beat a soldier anyway", then divine emissaries, the properties of divine planes and related skills could come into play. If there will also be a creature-creation system here, its options belong here too. Much else can be planned. But not everything belongs in the same place. 

Initially, you should plan for at least five publications. The free introductory publication matters, as does the core rulebook. The latter need not contain a setting description or many other things, and a few schools will suffice, but it should contain the system's important rules with proper explanations. This leaves room for explanations, many details and a more carefully considered magic system. The core book needs character-creation rules, but only a little data. The next book—or two books, divided into North and South—would support character creation. It would describe races, cultures and schools at the level ideal for play. Players do not want legends that reinvent the world, nor for you to contradict yourself about a word of power immediately. They want to get to know the world and create a character on that basis. 
 
The next book could be a colour atlas. Then a Bestiary whose aim is not simply to add many monsters to a world where opponents are rarely monsters rather than NPCs, but which also includes rules for trainable animals and the different forms characters can assume through magic, for example. This line-up could readily be published within a year, with smaller adventures and map packs as additional supplements. Over that year, some further content could be prepared for the next. 
 
Initially, many low-level adventures could also get supplements for the free introductory package, containing the adventure and its characters advanced to the appropriate level.