The legal wrangling around M.A.G.U.S. has become a constant topic even among people who have not played it for years. Or perhaps never played it at all. Is it really that important? Is the sorry state of Hungarian roleplaying really the fault of a few individuals around M.A.G.U.S.? Why? Can we not play anything besides M.A.G.U.S.? Can we not try something else? If you call some of the figures around M.A.G.U.S. the ruin of everything good, then you are actually the problem. You are the one who thinks only in terms of M.A.G.U.S. and would scarcely give many other publications a chance, Hungarian or foreign. You too therefore keep the market small, and you too help make it impossible to publish many exciting products. And if many other creators, publishers and so on are jointly responsible for the lack of a good system, let me point out that any roleplayer could write one. You can prepare it yourself for Amazon-style print-on-demand publication. There could be a paper book, a PDF, whatever you want. 

The main problem is the people unwilling to try anything else. The people without whom the market is not large enough, and who therefore leave everyone else at the mercy of a handful of individuals too. And it is bloody wonderful to hear them then curse those individuals and their dear mothers. In many respects I like neither András Gáspár nor Zsolt Kornya, and I think they have done M.A.G.U.S. considerable harm. But they are far too few to harm Hungarian roleplaying beyond ruining M.A.G.U.S.'s prospects, even if you add their entire entourage and whichever publisher they happen to have. For that, you need lots of people interested only in M.A.G.U.S., looking nowhere else for salvation.

I overhear a foul-mouthed conversation:

— András Gáspár can suck it!

— Not mine!

— Why the fuck not?

— Because I'm not a fag...

A third person cuts in:

— Nice, throwing around "fag"... But you know what matters? Even if I were gay, I would still choose my partners more carefully. 

Perhaps the word "I" receives a little more emphasis than necessary in that last line. Some will say that the extra emphasis sounds like a veiled homophobic generalisation, as though gay men at the Rudas baths would do it with anyone... Yet "not mine" largely began as teasing too. Everyone knows oral sex is not actually on the cards here; they are simply slagging off one creator or another. Whether that is András Gáspár, the head of Delta Vision or one of Lunír's many leading figures makes no difference. 

Do you know what the problem is? It is very simple. András Gáspár cannot replace the income connected with M.A.G.U.S. either. How much chance do you think he has of building a new world at the speed he writes? Of choosing among stable jobs that would bring in his current total income, with these references? For him and those around him, this is their one chance. Of course he will litigate and cling to it. We can say that what he does with M.A.G.U.S. is bad, inconsistent in many places, and that his fellow creators often combine poor work with doing whatever they please. But we must accept that, if he wants to eat and meet the expectations of his family and friends, he must hold on to M.A.G.U.S.—and to M.A.G.U.S. being the kind of world in which he feels at home and knows his way around. One in which he has a chance to make a strong showing with a book. If many other alternatives become more appealing and another writer emerges who could succeed even with a new world, that is a problem.

If he acts accordingly, unfortunately that is not being a cunt; it is natural. It is a risk every publisher must assess. From there, they set traps too, and out come the backup plans and legal tricks. Why? Because spending X amount of time developing an edition of M.A.G.U.S. that never even appeared would not look good on the development team's CVs either. Capital invested, possible loans and so on all create obligations that empty mother-cursing cannot override. If people switched, stopped buying the next novels and so on, and András Gáspár lost a lot by following this path, that might matter. But what does Lunír lose? Nothing. If it did things differently, it would lose a lot. 

There are about four points in M.A.G.U.S.'s history where the course was not forced, yet the choice made contributed substantially to the present situation. Three clearly happened more than ten years ago... The fourth is that many people would not try anything that is not M.A.G.U.S., yet curse the game and its developers. What are the other three? Surprisingly, two fairly popular publications are involved. And a popular creative team too. 

Although Zsolt Kornya was forced along a particular path in many respects, he had a free hand in many things when assembling the Summarium. If there had been no need to explain that Summarium 1 was the first volume of the forthcoming new system's core rulebook... If the book had not been full of contradictions... If the other two volumes had not failed to appear... Then people could have invested in supplements, the M.A.G.U.S. community would have been healthier, more old players would have stayed, and later teams would not have faced the additional obstacle of an atmospheric, popular but extraordinarily inconsistent Summarium undermining solid foundations. Then there would have been no problem.

And nobody forbade him to investigate how the many things previously described could work consistently, improve the system considerably, even introduce five skill levels and publish it within a reasonable time. The uncertain waiting began with this. If the answer then had been a realistically developed and thought-through M.A.G.U.S., with regular supplements, plenty of published adventures and a project that could continue on modest profits, we would not be where we are today.

The next opportunity belonged to the Grey Hoods. After the Summarium's failure, they could easily have done much the same thing. They did not; time passed. The third was Priests and Paladins. By importing od, it connected the previously separate Summarium to the original M.A.G.U.S., producing a publication that was conspicuously ill-considered and inconsistent in many places. We thus reached a point where many fan sites had to choose: accept these sources and collect the rules and data into a source-based encyclopaedia, thereby building an inconsistent vision of the world themselves, whose faults also emerged in play... Or reject numerous official supplements too. 

In the eyes of the former group, every attempt to put the system in order and make it consistent is bad, because it throws the inconsistent rules and solutions of their cherished "holy scripture" into the rubbish. The latter sites, however, sometimes discovered connections that a later creator might miss. From there, they were bound to clash with any creator and would also torpedo attempts to unify the system. On this obstacle course, rights holders and publishers act largely along paths forced upon them by "vital" interests.

Yet the solution would have been simple: from the beginning, the community wanted M.A.G.U.S. improved, not transformed. If we want a different kind of game, we can publish a separate game under a separate brand. Unfortunately, the question has now reversed. If you have had enough of legal wrangling and missed deadlines, and know that wherever you supplement the system the next person will tear it down anyway, so you start thinking about a new game instead of M.A.G.U.S., it will necessarily be somewhat different. Even if the aim is to provide many things that M.A.G.U.S. itself once tried to provide.