When M.A.G.U.S. reached the market, every AD&D fan said how overpowered the whole game was. One obvious consideration was that even a wizard survived several ordinary melee hits, could cast multiple times daily, and already possessed such powerful spells as a fire eruption. But that was nothing! Open the Non-Player Characters chapter and it becomes clear that most characters can beat several soldiers without much trouble. Where was that lovely world in which characters feared dying from two blows... only to be counted among the world's greatest heroes a year later? Yes, the complete DL adventure-module series turns beginners into world-saving heroes in less than a year.

M.A.G.U.S.'s basic premise is drastically different. Even at first level, neither a peasant girl nor a soldier need frighten you. A warrior is already a former soldier, a war veteran who stood out among their comrades for some reason. This is not their first encounter with combat, hence the stronger starting character. The aim was to make it believable from the outset why characters receive commissions, and why a handful of adventurers can accomplish things two or three platoons of well-equipped soldiers cannot. I would not object to an edition reinforcing this picture, or even to a game master strengthening it in many respects. One way or another, it can work. Instead, precisely the opposite has become fashionable, followed by justified complaints, on Facebook for example.

I have been playing a long-running life-path campaign with my second group, and one thing keeps troubling me. Characters develop so much in a few years that I cannot realistically imagine it even on Ynev. After all the play and advancement, someone can become a slan grandmaster, powerful magister, or war veteran by thirty, yet nobody would consider such an NPC realistic.

They are not the only one complaining. But once we understand that Ynev has many wars and warriors develop from former soldiers and war veterans into war veterans, the problem diminishes. The situation then represents no fundamentally rapid change. A slan who is already a master by twenty or twenty-two and can help teach younger students revealing more of their talent by thirty is hardly such a surprise. If a first-level wizard is equivalent to someone with an earthly PhD, successes ripening a few years later will surprise nobody. 

But this requires abandoning the attitude that a first-level adventurer is weak. M.A.G.U.S. offers several explanations for why an adventurer can be exceptional even at first level. Several usually provoke laughter. Let us go through them:

  • Adventurer's disease—Csanád called it that. We prefer adrenaline addiction.
  • A psychologist might speak of above-average motivation...
  • A choleric temperament... developing the previous idea further.
  • Several creators considered adventurers chosen ones...
  • A monastery records them, and what is written shapes the world. That makes them “powerful.”
  • If adventurers have a red banner, that too may help.
  • They wrote that novel heroes were life-path characters... I wrote that one must be born a sign-bearer.

If M.A.G.U.S. is intended for life-path campaigns with such characters—as Rúna at least recommends—let us ask whether NPC wizards, martial artists, and witches are equally powerful. Those spectacular iconic abilities that quickly establish an adventurer's considerable reputation may be that powerful only in the hands of a few dozen chosen people. Miraculously, the situation changes immediately, along with the game's character.

V6-14Monster in the Fog2Some say this favors munchkin play. I disagree. If players know this situation means they will almost certainly win, but roleplaying earns positive feedback or rewards inside or outside the game, they will realize an Attack Value of three hundred is damned little use. Unless they want to claim they can do anything and everything. Meanwhile, challenges exist that cannot be beaten up, requiring thought, with the environment as the opponent.

If you fail to defeat a demon not because it is overpowered, but because the GM never introduces it, and without reputation-building good roleplaying there are neither good opponents nor good XP, then earning a legendary opponent gives more reason to boast than a story depending on combat and dice. There is risk, of course; the character can theoretically die. But this picture can provide a foundation accommodating many things. Excitement can come not only from the chance of death, but from defeat or a harmful partial success. 

If this makes players nervous merely picking up the good old d100, there is both excitement and grounds for boasting. Players realize munchkin methods do not bring success. It is that simple. The game's message then is not “what you failed to learn in twenty years will teleport into your head after slaughtering enough camels.” It is easy to imagine benefiting from this.

Other things matter too. The most hackneyed solution is saying time between adventures will solve it. But why not solve it within adventures? Many methods exist. Travel time is one, as is the time between events within adventures, during which characters have opportunities for many things. 

Another option is that many adventures provide insufficient interesting, useful new experience to award substantial XP... But you can award money, followers, land, objects, or information. Eventually, everyday experience no longer suffices for XP that advances a character. Special things may be needed, each requiring an adventure to obtain. In other words, PCs generally receive minimal XP. But after an adventure or series, the wizard obtains old books, a magical item to analyze, or data needed for an experiment, and miraculously receives substantial XP then.

Advancement consequently slows. Simply because if every second adventure brings one character closer to an important discovery and major XP, with only one of five progressing this way at a time, ten adventures are needed for everyone to advance. If four steps are needed per level—four adventures supporting that particular character's development—that makes forty adventures... Say four weekends of play for just one level. Miraculously, with characters already starting strong under the original concept, I doubt they will suddenly develop more than they previously learned over many years. 

If good roleplaying also means doing what the character was chosen for, what even the gods may expect, thereby gaining opportunities to earn XP, then the world contains XP acquired through learning and useful practice while you reward roleplaying. Since “the powergamer does not want to fall behind,” a willingness to think and roleplay will eventually let them fit in too, instead of slaughtering camels. If life-path play is the goal, achieving this is worthwhile.

Beyond slowing advancement, making development part of roleplaying and the story matters just as much. Players can explain meaningfully what developed their characters and how, saying more about their lives. That is no trivial consideration. Remember how difficult it is to treat “when I had enough XP,” when XP was awarded at all, or XP from many slain monsters and avoided traps that would not realistically advance the character, as part of their life story. 

If you establish firmly that only genuinely new experience earns XP, and that talking to an NPC, practicing together, or sharing a task often provides more new experience—including learning—and XP is a rare treasure, advancement becomes more realistic and most players may be motivated to roleplay. Of course, one can say this ruins munchkins' fun. At least as much as ÚTK's other rules intended to restrict munchkin play. Only here, others are less restricted. 

Clearly, however, these methods rely on a long life path and personalized character development within it. Applying them at competitions or events with unfamiliar characters and limited control over advancement is difficult. Where shared interests, agreement, and discussion cannot be relied upon, hard rules restricting players may follow. These can be written as core rules, or as tournament rules alongside normal roleplaying constraints characteristic of the character. 

This shows how much harder it is to limit advancement across a series of events. One of Új Törvénykönyv's greatest strengths is its community-played adventure series writing the world's history, and its competitions. GMing that values characters' actions and consequences is where Tuan's team must be considered better than most previous developers. This system was designed for competitions, events, and a continuing story even when playing with strangers, where many things should receive rules.

The system offers an interesting possibility: say that history-shaping characters are at least as exceptional as Wier because of the path fate assigned them. Their individual chosen status could therefore be created using Új Bestiárium's creature creator. If competitions restrict what can be used from it, slower, more realistic development immediately follows. Special iconic abilities are also easily created with the creature creator, which can itself be developed further. 

For someone wanting a “physically fast” martial artist, this raises the question: why specifically through psi? Why not say that as a chosen one, they are physically fast... but must accelerate their soul too to exploit it? The disagreement between the two views of martial artists is immediately solved. A higher category resolves many things. Naturally, since ancient magic is already available, it would help to interpret creature-creation abilities more freely or expand them over time.