Warning: this article will be long and complicated. It is primarily for people who develop roleplaying systems, at least as a hobby, and feel an attachment to the world of Ynev. That warning was not there by accident. Players are entitled to expect you, as a creator, to spare them dealing with a great many things because you have already done so for them. Including checking them, thus guaranteeing a certain quality. No game system will please everyone, but if you try to mash together everyone's requests and ideas, you will not be consistent either, nor able to produce a steady level of quality. It is your job to watch the mathematics, the connections and quite a few small concepts so that the player does not have to.
This article is not about what would fit into a reformed, corrected edition of the ÚTK. For three reasons. First, the situation will remain uncertain for at least a few more days, and we do not know whether there will be an ÚTK 2. Second, we do not know whether there will be something else. Third, a possible revised ÚTK would be about some errata, not drastic changes or a great reform. Here, some changes are smaller than that, such as a drastic but gradual expansion of the skill list over several supplements. A new core book matters less for this too. Some are on a similar scale, such as a digital core book promoting the system. Others are bigger changes or the design principles behind the scenes. And some, unfortunately, are obvious business considerations. I will start with the last of these.
Why do these questions matter? Because in M.A.G.U.S.'s history, it was always the other side's fault. The trouble is that, when many people thought Nyul was the idiot, after laying the foundations of M.A.G.U.S. and writing Renegát, he brought out CODEX. Another excellent game, with many ideas nobody can deny are his, and nobody can claim do not work. Since then, he has proved himself in computer games too. Although I have some serious doubts about the Grey Hoods' work, they also put usable maps and other things on the table. Since then we have had Inomi, Tuan and Lunír, for example. Today, most of the argument is over whether people who made many mistakes should be associated with companies that are no longer active, because linking them to their present workplace is unfair, or the reverse: only by connecting the past to their current "side" can we assess what to expect.
A smart developer prepares for legal minefields
We have often heard that the trouble with Tuan was publishing things the rights holder said should not have been published. If we say it is almost impossible to find a solution that testers, fan sites and the writing team will all approve, while also meeting some quality standards... We are not far from the truth. From there, it is merely a matter of perspective whether the writers are right because the system's creators failed to deliver the required quality, or the other side is telling the truth: that the creative team obstructs, withholds consent and nitpicks, that with this attitude there will never be a M.A.G.U.S., and that these people have done the same thing to others before. After yet another case, I am beginning to think that, although for some creators the answer is "both", the trend is no accident.
Even when Lunír began its project, I was suspicious: "Again? Yet another new thing?" Then it had a website where you could ask questions, and targeted questions could establish that many of its aims were not stupid. At that point I began worrying for a completely different reason. Not without cause. Although I disliked the attitude towards testers, the question was how the guys handled the situation surrounding M.A.G.U.S. What did they do about the fact that, if the project was good, it could easily be killed off, while if it was bad, it would fail? What do I mean by managing the risk?
Legal traps appeared, and anyone with sense would not necessarily comment. Indeed, sooner or later the plans begin like this: nothing will come of it because the rights holder will not authorise anything good. During the disputes, neither side trusts the other. The question becomes who can earn what from the affair by the end of the expected lawsuits, without necessarily producing a roleplaying game for the domestic market. In any even slightly considered plan, this is the main scenario. That there is some small chance the cooperation might work, something good might appear, the brand might increase in value and big money could be made from that too, is merely a stroke of luck. Who is responsible? The person with many publishers and developers behind them, who refuses even to hear of many good solutions, created this situation and whose predictable behaviour pushes events towards plan A? Or the developer who acts this way? In good conscience, all we can recommend to any developer is this: if cooperation has not worked very well before, it may not work for you either. Prepare for that, with suitable safeguards in the contract for such cases.
Indeed, most people risking their friends' and colleagues' livelihoods and the roof over their families' heads have very little interest in discovering what will happen only after a few releases, when many millions would already be tied up in the project. Having to allow for this is not their fault. Allowing for it is simply rational. Given the dangers above, someone who also cares about their friends and family can prepare in precisely this way. The sole exception that would not prepare for this is Tuan. Not because it would foolishly risk everything for nothing, but because it has already invested the money once in the ÚTK, clubs, tournaments and so on. For Tuan, cooperation would no longer begin with a hugely labour- and capital-intensive phase, but with errata, reprints, established tournaments and marketing. Things that would bring some revenue after little expenditure, and whose permission to proceed could be stipulated in the contract from the outset.
If a company expects the likely problems and structures the contract so it can profit even in that event... There are many possible outcomes, and the rights could migrate in many directions. I do not feel like guessing. But I say it is worth learning from the Lunír affair. To the extent that it tried to prepare for everything in its dealings with testers, there was every possibility that Lunír too could emerge victorious from the legal wrangling. Mainly because it probably prepared well in advance. And if cooperation was imperfect from the very beginning, what else should it have been preparing for since? You can spit at anyone who starts out this way. But that is reality.
From the other side, the document testers were made to sign is probably worthless; several grounds for invalidity can be found. Indeed, since you effectively undertake unlimited work for them, this can have implications that authorities would take issue with too. If grounds for invalidity also apply to the contract with the rights holder and DV, or the court considers that deception may lie behind the situation described above, it could declare that contract void as well. Then the question is who compensates whom. But it matters that, if deception is intentional and an aim of obtaining unlawful gain is also established, the situation is far from healthy. This cuts both ways. Nor does treating testers, the community and so on dishonestly or deceptively help if you later want to claim, "I am always honest."
Unfortunately, no advice is more important for a developer today than what a good lawyer can offer about preparing for legal minefields. A well-prepared, larger legal department may be even better. But it is hardly motivating to have the contract and the attempts important for legal reasons in place, only for the entire project to stop with exactly zero output, because it is better to settle disputes and battles now, before pouring in still more money... Especially when it is uncertain how much chance the finished RPG would have even after a victory, and whether that is what is needed, or... You can avoid this uncertainty by saying that you want to develop a good roleplaying game. That is the first goal. The second is for the game to embody many worthwhile qualities. Only third comes whether it is called M.A.G.U.S. But this requires many little things.