Warning: this article will be long and complicated. It is primarily for people who develop roleplaying systems, at least as a hobby, and feel an attachment to the world of Ynev. That warning was not there by accident. Players are entitled to expect you, as a creator, to spare them dealing with a great many things because you have already done so for them. Including checking them, thus guaranteeing a certain quality. No game system will please everyone, but if you try to mash together everyone's requests and ideas, you will not be consistent either, nor able to produce a steady level of quality. It is your job to watch the mathematics, the connections and quite a few small concepts so that the player does not have to.
This article is not about what would fit into a reformed, corrected edition of the ÚTK. For three reasons. First, the situation will remain uncertain for at least a few more days, and we do not know whether there will be an ÚTK 2. Second, we do not know whether there will be something else. Third, a possible revised ÚTK would be about some errata, not drastic changes or a great reform. Here, some changes are smaller than that, such as a drastic but gradual expansion of the skill list over several supplements. A new core book matters less for this too. Some are on a similar scale, such as a digital core book promoting the system. Others are bigger changes or the design principles behind the scenes. And some, unfortunately, are obvious business considerations. I will start with the last of these.
Why do these questions matter? Because in M.A.G.U.S.'s history, it was always the other side's fault. The trouble is that, when many people thought Nyul was the idiot, after laying the foundations of M.A.G.U.S. and writing Renegát, he brought out CODEX. Another excellent game, with many ideas nobody can deny are his, and nobody can claim do not work. Since then, he has proved himself in computer games too. Although I have some serious doubts about the Grey Hoods' work, they also put usable maps and other things on the table. Since then we have had Inomi, Tuan and Lunír, for example. Today, most of the argument is over whether people who made many mistakes should be associated with companies that are no longer active, because linking them to their present workplace is unfair, or the reverse: only by connecting the past to their current "side" can we assess what to expect.
A smart developer prepares for legal minefields
We have often heard that the trouble with Tuan was publishing things the rights holder said should not have been published. If we say it is almost impossible to find a solution that testers, fan sites and the writing team will all approve, while also meeting some quality standards... We are not far from the truth. From there, it is merely a matter of perspective whether the writers are right because the system's creators failed to deliver the required quality, or the other side is telling the truth: that the creative team obstructs, withholds consent and nitpicks, that with this attitude there will never be a M.A.G.U.S., and that these people have done the same thing to others before. After yet another case, I am beginning to think that, although for some creators the answer is "both", the trend is no accident.
Even when Lunír began its project, I was suspicious: "Again? Yet another new thing?" Then it had a website where you could ask questions, and targeted questions could establish that many of its aims were not stupid. At that point I began worrying for a completely different reason. Not without cause. Although I disliked the attitude towards testers, the question was how the guys handled the situation surrounding M.A.G.U.S. What did they do about the fact that, if the project was good, it could easily be killed off, while if it was bad, it would fail? What do I mean by managing the risk?
Legal traps appeared, and anyone with sense would not necessarily comment. Indeed, sooner or later the plans begin like this: nothing will come of it because the rights holder will not authorise anything good. During the disputes, neither side trusts the other. The question becomes who can earn what from the affair by the end of the expected lawsuits, without necessarily producing a roleplaying game for the domestic market. In any even slightly considered plan, this is the main scenario. That there is some small chance the cooperation might work, something good might appear, the brand might increase in value and big money could be made from that too, is merely a stroke of luck. Who is responsible? The person with many publishers and developers behind them, who refuses even to hear of many good solutions, created this situation and whose predictable behaviour pushes events towards plan A? Or the developer who acts this way? In good conscience, all we can recommend to any developer is this: if cooperation has not worked very well before, it may not work for you either. Prepare for that, with suitable safeguards in the contract for such cases.
Indeed, most people risking their friends' and colleagues' livelihoods and the roof over their families' heads have very little interest in discovering what will happen only after a few releases, when many millions would already be tied up in the project. Having to allow for this is not their fault. Allowing for it is simply rational. Given the dangers above, someone who also cares about their friends and family can prepare in precisely this way. The sole exception that would not prepare for this is Tuan. Not because it would foolishly risk everything for nothing, but because it has already invested the money once in the ÚTK, clubs, tournaments and so on. For Tuan, cooperation would no longer begin with a hugely labour- and capital-intensive phase, but with errata, reprints, established tournaments and marketing. Things that would bring some revenue after little expenditure, and whose permission to proceed could be stipulated in the contract from the outset.
If a company expects the likely problems and structures the contract so it can profit even in that event... There are many possible outcomes, and the rights could migrate in many directions. I do not feel like guessing. But I say it is worth learning from the Lunír affair. To the extent that it tried to prepare for everything in its dealings with testers, there was every possibility that Lunír too could emerge victorious from the legal wrangling. Mainly because it probably prepared well in advance. And if cooperation was imperfect from the very beginning, what else should it have been preparing for since? You can spit at anyone who starts out this way. But that is reality.
From the other side, the document testers were made to sign is probably worthless; several grounds for invalidity can be found. Indeed, since you effectively undertake unlimited work for them, this can have implications that authorities would take issue with too. If grounds for invalidity also apply to the contract with the rights holder and DV, or the court considers that deception may lie behind the situation described above, it could declare that contract void as well. Then the question is who compensates whom. But it matters that, if deception is intentional and an aim of obtaining unlawful gain is also established, the situation is far from healthy. This cuts both ways. Nor does treating testers, the community and so on dishonestly or deceptively help if you later want to claim, "I am always honest."
Unfortunately, no advice is more important for a developer today than what a good lawyer can offer about preparing for legal minefields. A well-prepared, larger legal department may be even better. But it is hardly motivating to have the contract and the attempts important for legal reasons in place, only for the entire project to stop with exactly zero output, because it is better to settle disputes and battles now, before pouring in still more money... Especially when it is uncertain how much chance the finished RPG would have even after a victory, and whether that is what is needed, or... You can avoid this uncertainty by saying that you want to develop a good roleplaying game. That is the first goal. The second is for the game to embody many worthwhile qualities. Only third comes whether it is called M.A.G.U.S. But this requires many little things.
Solid foundations...
It is easy for a player or customer to talk, even when they have to tell the truth. I can very easily find arguments for the ÚTK, from its tournaments to its basically functioning system and many other little things. Just as easily, I can argue against it, citing inherited faults or its attributes, for example. We have embarked on a major NPC-design project. Ideas from anyone are welcome, but a question immediately arose: how do we determine an innkeeper's attributes? What is the average value against which to measure them? Right away, there are four or five positions we could consider:
- 10: For one thing, an average of 10–12 tells us that the average is not the same everywhere. In some places, selection and the effects of local faith produce a slightly higher average, while in an ordinary country village 10 is more typical. Besides, many players consider this the average. Not without reason.
- 10.5: An ordinary person traditionally rolls attributes on 3d6... Adventurers might use 3d6 twice, but let this be the average for NPCs.
- 11: If the average is 10–12, "this is in the middle"... I can also interpret the statement as a mean of 11 and a standard deviation of 1: "10–12" is a plain-language way of saying that. After all, what would it look like if the rulebook wrote things like e^(-1/2 (x-11)^2)/sqrt(2 pi), while telling us to round the attribute value to an integer according to mathematical rules and write that down... István Veér would run a mile.
- 12: 10 is the median, but strong selection makes lower attributes rarer than higher ones, so the mean is already 12. I rarely go below 10; an average around 12 is good.
- 13: The inn became the innkeeper's when their father could no longer run it. Let us include a small age modifier. That makes it roughly legal under the rules...
- 13.5: The 135 points to distribute also apply when the GM creates a monster, an NPC creature and so on. Obviously you can deviate, but this will be a reference point consistent with many people's worlds.
Surely I need not explain the difference between an innkeeper whose values range from 9 to 12, averaging a little over 10, while we explain what they are good at and how much they stand out—we account for the natural distribution so the player and GM no longer have to—and one with few values below 12 and even a 16, who is good at many things but whom we describe as unexceptional. In the latter case, many players would want "much more" and select abilities to obtain many extra attribute points. Whichever interpretation I follow, supporters of the others will think I am the idiot.
This matters not because we are obsessed with maths and rules, but precisely because, when a system's creator talks of solid foundations, the game master needs something to compare against. They do not need a complicated formula, or even a pretty curve. But they must see the attributes of an average peasant, innkeeper and city guard, as well as many famous people, and use that yardstick to place the others.
We do not know how much the innkeeper would stand out among many NPCs. Creating a new race is easy, but a school out of the training expected by guilds and professional associations? That is harder, and in many respects the logical answer is that there should be no school there. So the question arises: what is the solution? Perhaps the innkeeper has seen plenty by now, and experience gained through learning means they are no longer first level? Then how do we measure a third-level innkeeper against the power of first-level characters? These questions arise for us and anyone else who would work with the system, invest effort in it and publish on a website. That work is not wasted if many such pieces remain compatible with one another and with any official version that may appear.
If we cannot be sure of this, we may consider that system a worse choice and be less likely to recommend it, because others also find it harder to produce quality work for it. I am not talking here about descriptions of ill-considered, overpowered schools. And as long as no publisher supplies us with enough official supplements to stop readers occasionally seeking other information, we will feel this is a deficiency.
A solution? Yes and no. Tuan also runs a club, its head is reachable on Facebook, and questions can be asked. But incorrect interpretations still spread in plenty of cases, and it is far from certain that everything will remain this accessible in a few years, or that they will not have better things to do then. At that point, many players will no longer regard these sources as authoritative. For now, though, this is the foundation we build on, trusting that whoever publishes whatever system will provide a concrete answer—one that lets us create an innkeeper, city guard or similar supporting character and NPC.
The first few editions of M.A.G.U.S. discussed average NPCs; we knew their values could be rolled on 3d6. The mean was 10.5, and we had a useful value for the standard deviation too. We could roll and reroll an unrealistic set, but accounting for the standard deviation was even easier. Does a profession need the best out of thirty people? We could calculate that easily for one or two important attributes. Even for three. It does no harm for what you write to be precise and provide a solid foundation that others can build on even if legal minefields make further work difficult.
You cannot do it alone
So far, most M.A.G.U.S. development teams have wanted to fix M.A.G.U.S. as world-saving heroes. But they overlooked one thing. Even under the most optimistic publishing plans, plenty of supplementary material is needed. Its quality can vary. Yet to every fan and every fan site, their own work is the most beautiful. Without it, no system is good enough in its first few years. Someone who does more than write a few things for powergaming, who invests serious work, will use your system as a foundation only if they can trust that you will not wipe out their work with a stroke of the pen. That is the bare minimum. Whether the issue is simply that there will not initially be enough supplements, or that continuation must later happen unofficially, funded out of nothing.
The first edition of M.A.G.U.S. was perfectly respectably playable from its core book. The setting description, however, was more than patchy. Alongside a system unfinished in many respects, Ynev clearly seemed neglected in many ways, even though it was the world where they had played the AD&D adventures on which much was built. There was just one problem: the game master shared the secrets, explanations and so on with nobody, and was often working on the system. In time, the writing team filled out the world. But they were primarily writers, used to creative freedom.
Many players and game masters therefore sought logical explanations for historical events. They found them, and writing them up might even earn praise from Nyul. They gained a well-functioning world that was interesting, varied and distinctive. Then the writers created a different setting description. A player could easily say: "I liked what I had up to now; here they have undermined me." It was easy to point to the Summarium and say this was not how they had imagined a better M.A.G.U.S. edition, so treating its vision as an alternative was an obvious choice. All that takes is a few mistakes in the Summarium, a few situations it cannot explain well. On one side is a vision of the world that works well, even flawlessly, in the group's hands, and towards which they are already biased. On the other is the vision brought by those who "replaced our favourite creators and are now contradicting them".
The writer is also right that they are exercising creative freedom, thinking in terms of literary Ynev, and that no good description of that place existed. Even if the lack of thought is bad work, deceived many fans and destroyed much of value, we must accept the argument: they are a writer. This is what they can do, what they are called to do, and the task was passed to them with all that included. The idiot is not a writer like this acting accordingly, but the person who would entrust them with a harder task. The player using their work but complaining about its many logical flaws is also right. So is the person who largely rejects such additions, or adopts them only with strong criticism, and plays in a consistent, good world.
Since then, however, many writers and creators have produced some quite atmospheric things. Toron, for example. It is not always obvious what is good to adopt and what is not. Many people choose an older edition of M.A.G.U.S. precisely because it is no longer being "developed". How can the many elements of its vision of the world be fitted together? How can creative tools produce a compromise? That could make an interesting article of its own, but there would be rather too many articles aimed at creators. For now, let us say: allow room for inference, and remain consistent yourself. You can even involve some of the fans.
Most people dislike empty blank spaces that others fill with nothing but contrived nonsense. What about areas that a few hints allow people to flesh out well and fairly consistently, producing work they can be proud of? Where a superficial description is excellent for players as a reflection of what their characters know, while deductions and recognisable connections beneath the surface can underpin adventures and campaigns? That is a very different kind of blank space, judged very differently.
You can easily announce a competition to fill out and develop particular areas on the basis of connections in the history and other material already described. The blank space may suddenly engage the audience, and the "blank map", dismissed as dull, sketchy rubbish, suddenly fills with content.
Game balance and a little statistics
We know the basic concept: now there will be game balance. Someone will always complain. Uh-huh. In a "typical" adventure module with lots of fighting, combat values are truly valuable. But in an investigative adventure to be completed with "almost no combat", +10 TÉ is worth exactly as much as in an adventure whose main antagonist is called wind, rain or snow because the characters must contend with the weather. Until you know what kinds of adventures the group enjoys and what the game master will run, you have no chance of assessing the value of +10 TÉ. Good balance would be difficult on that basis. And we have not yet accounted for different combos, limitations arising from alignment or the players' many aptitudes. No wonder people argue back and forth about balance.
One player says their spells mainly deal damage, summon things and harm the enemy, whereas the priest can heal and fight a little too. It would be unfair for the priest to do similar damage with spells. The priest, meanwhile, sees themselves as poor at combat yet often forced into it, because they must reserve their magical power and the divine favour behind it for healing. On the very rare occasions they can deal damage with prayers, they should not lag behind a practitioner of experiential magic. The priest can easily argue that, when they finally get to do damage with prayers, it would be nice to stand out on that rare occasion; it is unfair that the warlock overshadows them even then. Both players' arguments are convincing. What would balance look like here? There will always be tantrums.
You can, however, assess how often particular abilities generally come into play for characters at different levels and groups with different experience and needs. It is worth assessing how common the Time Gate spell is, given that it requires a level-22 priest. Most groups presumably do not often have high priests more powerful than Mogorva Chei in their vicinity. Likewise, some magic items are highly unlikely to be used in most groups.
Make a table showing how often, on average, each ability, spell, magic item, skill and so on appears in one hundred hours of play for each typical kind of group.
Forget Dreonar
You can influence what players use and how often by the adventures you make available, perhaps bundled with the core book itself. Do not try to save money here: by the time the core book appears, have several adventures ready, some free and some as publications to buy. Before you say I have put the cart before the horse, or that I quickly moved from mathematics, statistics and foundations to inconsequential adventures, let me point out two things. First, working on adventures also helps you assess what will inevitably appear in play even in the short term. Second, you shape that for most of the community. More experienced players and game masters can decide whether to supplement the system for themselves.
The point is that a system includes more than what you write down. It includes how it is used. If many incompatible additions appear, and differently interpreted rules produce a tangled chaos where players can be sure of almost nothing, that would hardly be ideal. Equally, the number of people playing the system and the difficulty of finding a group are part of it too. If you need an example adventure, it is worth making a few sample characters and including simple descriptions of their spells and skills, plus a little straightforward rules explanation. But keep plan B in place. If you lose the rights, you should be able to bring most people over to your own world. The aim is for nobody to have an interest in taking away your rights, while you remain prepared for it. And not only legally.
Look beyond the first book
There is Becoming One, there is the Kiss of Transformation, and a wizard can also "remote-control" an animal with some mental magic. But how well have they learned to use wings? How do they handle updraughts? Do they know that even a bird can stall? I have to say that skills suited to an animal body would be useful. So might descriptions of the simple skills learned by the character's cat, practically a member of the family. The ability to communicate with more intelligent-than-average animals would not hurt either. But it would be foolish to hold a new core book accountable for lacking this. Not everything belongs in a core book.
A New Bestiary, though? A different matter. It is more important there. Why? When creating a system, an important task is imagining which supplements make it "complete" and, once they do, where further expansion might fit. I know many people say there is always room for a book describing subclasses within classes, but even that need not operate at the level of Priests and Paladins. Above all, it need not give new names to existing skills, spectacularly demonstrating that the supplement's creators do not know the system they are contributing to.
If a religion supplement's concept is not "there is a goddess of infidelity, but we call a different goddess unfaithful... there is a priestess who never learns to fight, but has a few Weapon Use skills on top of the priest's basic skills and can beat a soldier anyway", then divine emissaries, the properties of divine planes and related skills could come into play. If there will also be a creature-creation system here, its options belong here too. Much else can be planned. But not everything belongs in the same place.
The new Rúna
I do not know whether a printed Rúna would have a market... But free or paid electronic content is possible. The aim, however, is not for the creative team to write it. Quite the opposite: the magazine would feature the "cream" of content submitted by fan sites. In exchange for reprinting, a tiny "seal" would identify fan material published in issue X and made official. The result? Hopefully, the creative teams of many websites would want to meet the quality standards, and more and more such material would appear. You could also recruit more easily for the next supplements, or for an adventure anthology. If monthly publication is impossible, every two months may suffice.
Unlimited space, unlimited possibilities
I am not naïve. M.A.G.U.S. will never get an OGL-style licence; we cannot touch that. But fan development can still be supported with a book expressly intended to help developers. The principle is simple: the core book contains sample characters and points of reference. The developers' version also contains the formula. Players rarely encounter the mathematics and statistics, but anyone who wants access to them and to develop on solid foundations could buy it. An electronic edition has unlimited space: you can put commentary alongside every rule. That also helps you remember it better, and reduces the trouble caused by people clinging to fan material that makes no sense because of similar lack of information.
As many groups, as many Ynevs...
Rather a lot happens on Ynev at once... Because we imagine everyone's adventures there. But what if you can agree, and put it in the contract, that every gaming group and every group of writers can have their own interpretation of Ynev, with many shared elements of course? A contract can even specify the common points: the map, religions and rulers, for example. But nothing falling under creative freedom should be included. Several adventure strands and several possible continuations are not necessarily a bad thing. Especially if this gives you a free hand in some of them, while the existing writing team can continue its own version under an appropriate trademark. New subject matter should not pull the ground out from under them.
Which interpretation has the better market? Is András Gáspár right that his vision of Ynev made M.A.G.U.S. popular? That is open to question. But neither is the opposing argument necessarily correct: that arrow machine guns and the surprises that seem almost compulsorily inserted are there to provide something new and original even when we can expect fewer intricate plots, nuanced characters, diverse cultures and so on, because the necessary creativity and rethinking of the world from that perspective are missing behind the story. That criticism, after all, claims it would be better and more popular another way.
A generic system, open source?
At the beginning of this article I suggested that, if there is some small chance the cooperation might work, that is merely a stroke of luck. You cannot build plans on it. With M.A.G.U.S., I would certainly start by publishing a setting-independent core book within a few days of the other release. I would give it a strong identity, because this is my "gold reserve". Then build M.A.G.U.S. on that system. If the contract does not prohibit it, the generic system can later receive supplements, setting-independent adventures and many other worlds. Many M.A.G.U.S. players will already know it. And I would certainly allow others to adapt their own setting descriptions to the system and publish them. I would structure royalties somewhat like BRP licensing.
If trouble comes, you can easily release a new edition of the generic system. A supplement, a setting, anything. You will have your own world, events and brand. If they take the M.A.G.U.S. brand away while few M.A.G.U.S. publications are available, and you can readily take your community with you, they can do far less damage to you than the rights holder would do to themselves. If the community stays with your tournaments and grows to like the new world, the next M.A.G.U.S. novel is years away, and legal traps leave people expecting nothing good, then your game and world may draw the community while the next M.A.G.U.S. novels achieve even less than they might have if you had been given a free hand on Ynev. From there, "everyone" would have an interest in multiple versions of Ynev. And you would have your plan B.
If cooperation still fails, legal proceedings and their minefields should not be your only plan. Nor does it hurt to have a short-story collection, map and so on ready for your other world, easily reaching your players. Plans B and C need not consist solely of preparing for legal wrangling. Assess your options.