Article Index

In similar debates, a common simple central argument is “What makes the Hungarian gene worth more than...,” used to explain why universal acceptance is necessary. There is one problem. This is not about genes, or about being worth more, or about whether a person receives refuge. Still less is it about being born somewhere fortunate or unfortunate. In the name of grand political correctness, the most incorrect argumentative technique works splendidly: fighting a straw man. Someone who does this, lies, and tries to render the other person powerless through character assassination instead of argument cannot be reasoned with. At that moment, they have excluded themselves from social consultation and democracy. They could rightly say, however, that they did not make those arguments: somebody else on their political side did, or, heaven forbid, a provocateur. 

A much better example for the question of which life or gene is worth more is the Black Lives Matter movement, the All Lives Matter response, and a relatively recent issue connected with them. The USA is no small country and has no small number of police officers. At that scale, mistakes and abuses inevitably occur. When the victims are Black, there is a national uproar and movements like these, followed by claims such as “They only allow this because the victim is Black.” Well, neither the media, billionaires, nor politics allowed it then. And the claim that “White people only care about themselves” also fell down because White liberals often spoke out. When the victim was White? The White parents do not understand why all those Black people who criticize Whites for supposedly standing up only for Whites are silent. Do they want to be as bad as they say White people are? Meanwhile, Black Lives Matter's activists of color do not understand why, if every life matters, Whites do not make an uproar even for their own.

Because they have been telling the truth all along. Every life has value. The police officer's too. And the lives of those the officer protects. If, in ambiguous situations requiring a response to perceived danger, officers did not “overreact,” did not shoot, many officers would become victims. If they had to accept that risk too, far fewer would dare intervene, and crime would claim many more lives. Every human life has value, including those of police officers and law-abiding citizens. If fatalities are unavoidable, there will be fewest when the victim is the criminal who does not cooperate with the officer's instructions. That is independent of both the officer's and the victim's color. Anyone who wants skin color to determine whose life has value and who has a right to live is a Nazi. 

Why do police stop more Black people? Why are many more of them killed in shootings? Three or four good answers immediately suggest themselves. None declares one person bad and another good based on race, skin color, or anything similar. One consideration is poverty. A poor Black minister from around the Bronx will be stopped much more often than a Jewish rabbi from Manhattan. Why? Not because the latter is White, but because the former is poor and may not have enough money to maintain his car properly. The latter's car is almost new and visibly in impeccable condition. One is in a neighborhood where crime and drug cases are everyday problems, requiring many cars to be stopped, especially if they take an unusual route. For the other, that does not even arise. 

Movements like these teach the former to resist police, to say “They are not going to tell us what to do.” Propaganda from related organizations makes him somewhat prejudiced toward officers, stressed, and therefore more likely to break a rule. If he is stopped, there is more likely to be a reason. And we have not yet examined whether other correlations underlie statistics by skin color: for instance, how educational attainment, financial circumstances, or a criminal record affect the frequency of police stops. Yes, an extremist Southern White who likewise wants to act the big boy against police because nobody is going to tell him what to do is also stopped more often than a peaceful citizen. The question is how many Black people ought to be stopped based entirely on characteristics independent of skin color, and whether the actual number is higher, lower, or roughly the same. If it is lower, racism runs in the opposite direction. How interesting that when certain groups are suspects, every real consideration and sometimes false ones too are taken into account; when they are the “victims,” the allegation of racism is not examined nearly as thoroughly.

And yes, there are African American officers, even sheriffs, who approach the issue in exactly the same way: whether the law is obeyed. Indeed, in their cases, where political correctness and avoiding the appearance of racism matter less, they may target Black people at a slightly higher rate. Their problem surely is not with Black people. How the hell would African American cops be enemies of Black people en masse? Thus many claims of such movements have questionable truth, while on many issues they are clearly false. Tough luck, but judging and stigmatizing others on the basis of a false preconception is not necessarily nice. Even though many things belong to the overall picture, including the certainty that some of the many cops will be racist. But also that the overall picture, opposite in many respects—Black cops being stricter toward Black people—suggests the average cop leans the other way. Why, then, would these movements' prejudices be good? If the other side must distance itself from extremists, why does the liberal side not distance itself from this prejudice?

These are not small movements, and not a small number of human lives. Someone who, instead of saying every life matters, joins a political bloc supporting discrimination in the role of “among murderers, the silent are accomplices,” and likewise closes ranks with those asking “What makes the Hungarian gene worth more,” has done a thing or two to make me treat them as belonging to that bloc. Distance yourselves from these extremes, please... Then our opinions will not be formed on this basis.