Article Index

So to hell with political correctness; let us ask: would you welcome an individual of some fantasy or science-fiction species? A nice Asari from Mass Effect, say? And a Xenomorph from Alien? See, it does matter whom we welcome! If admission is unconditional, it includes the extremes too. Fortunately, only within the fictional world. That is why the political correctness of an immigrant cultist portrayed in Call of Cthulhu is not a consideration. And why admission without conditions or expectations is not a universal value. But let us take an example that cannot be dismissed as “fantasy” because Xenomorphs do not exist. Start with a simple problem. History has had, and still has, dictators and many supporters who could not have been convicted under the laws in force when they committed their deeds. After their downfall, laws to hold them accountable were introduced by political decision.

They are fleeing persecution arising from political decisions in circumstances where they “had no chance” to obey a law imposed on them afterward. There is no simpler form of persecution. Yet it could also be done to certain Romanian dictators. Or suppose I am running an adventure during the Second World War, set in the USA, where technological development—whether based on ordinary inventions or technology received from somewhere else—the changing society, dangers able to hide within it, many historical perspectives, and the American Big Brother feeling developing then matter much more than the Nazi issue directly. I certainly do not climb aboard the “Panzer! Cool” train, but the issue of similarly retrospective courts and rules does come to mind.

It is easy to see that, in the situation above, granting asylum to Nazi, communist, and similar leaders means harboring those very people, which according to the same circles is a crime. So must everyone be admitted, or does it depend on many things after all, with a little double standard involved? Clearly, the problem with unconditional admission is not admission or empathy, but unconditionality: calling something a universal value, independent of everything else, when it is not. If it were, unconditionality would hold too—that is how universal values work—but it very much does not. These are not universal human values. And around Nyarlathotep and his cultists, we tend to encounter “universal truths” that are anything but: deadly jokes and deceptions. That makes this a good subject for Call of Cthulhu. 

It also makes a politician who calls it a universal value a liar. When, in the name of PC, those saying unpleasant things are stigmatized and efforts are made to render them powerless, that is censorship and trampling freedom of speech. By people who, if they had to take responsibility for their own lies, would immediately take to the streets to defend freedom of speech. They do not merely trample basic rights and build dictatorship—one can undermine others from opposition too, without constitutional authorization—but, as victims of cases covered up in the name of PC show, sacrifice other people's lives and physical and mental health for power. For groups capable of that, intolerant of dissent and considering themselves the only potentially legitimate ones, it makes no difference whether they call themselves Nazis, communists, or European liberals. 

To move beyond M.A.G.U.S., Shadowrun, and Call of Cthulhu, let me ask: do you think a party recruited from both sides of the Blood War works in AD&D or D&D? Or, in Star Wars, is it a good idea to assume a Jedi and a Sith character will make a stable group while both remain what they are? Why would anyone think that people who could not coexist peacefully before will now do so here without adapting or changing? Especially when the Shia hates the Sunni, and the Sunni the Shia, to the death precisely because “they made me leave my homeland, lose everything, and lose so many friends.” What magic wand would bring reconciliation without the necessary change? 

Taking people in always carries risks. Not because every refugee is a criminal, but because refugees are people just like non-refugees. Some are criminals. Others are held back from crime at home by something that may not exist in a foreign country. Someone unwilling to integrate, unwilling to accept the new homeland's laws as their own, surrounded by similar people, and lacking empathy for the majority because of their own bad fortune may have very little holding them back from crime. But taking people in can always be good too: alongside the extremely bad person and cultist, there will be the extremely good. Even someone who becomes good only from the pressure to fit in at the new place. There will be cultural tensions... But both cultures also learn from each other, and progress occurs too. Put in slightly computer-RPG terms: “Learning about the other culture and solving problems can be worth plenty of XP. +3 CODEX entries, +1 level.”