A good roleplayer easily recognizes that the other person is human too. We have seen situations from many sides through many kinds of character, and can readily imagine Arab, Persian, Black, Chinese, Roma, Native American, Latino, and other player characters, and play them too. The problem is that, just as we recognize the other person's humanity and why they do not want to change, we also recognize that many cultures simply would not work together.
But imagine what happens if the coalition against ISIS comes together and defeats it, along with Boko Haram, which has already joined them in the region. Then those organizations' fighters will flee and get their families out of the war. However many are terrorists and war criminals, they too will be entitled to the presumption of innocence, and they too will flee poor and destitute. Like those now fleeing from us who were fundamentalists waging holy war against half the world and other factions in the name of another branch of Islam. And we believe that if they come here without having to give up those values and that culture, all the holy wars they proclaimed against one another and the rest of the world will end overnight. While we do not even want to expect an effort to integrate, respect for the laws and culture, or identification with the majority.
Those who consider the latter self-evident generally do not argue; they merely abuse and discredit the other person. I am beginning to think this is because they see no rational argument behind those expectations either. Only universal values of the sort Lovecraft's work mostly described as one of Nyarlathotep's deadly jokes or deceptions. There are universal values: heaven forbid we tell someone that we do not stone gay people to death around here. If we expect adaptation and they dislike it and stay home, the poor thing might die. Better bring over a wheelbarrow of stones in the name of the diversity we spoke up for at Pride yesterday, so that those we defended then can be stoned to death today. As for the incompatibility of the two goals, let us bury our heads in the sand. That usually works, does it not? What a pity that roleplaying can put player characters on both sides. M.A.G.U.S. groups have included gay Toronians very active at orgies, and Shadonian paladins of Domvik who burned precisely such people for sodomy and heresy.
But these values can be invoked to hate one another and abuse the other side, while someone watching from outside can laugh at how stupid humans are. Lovecraft's genius was that, just as he named natural forces in the manner of real religions, he personified this social phenomenon too and named it Nyarlathotep. Similar “universal” values also distinguish the factions killing one another. The question is what we will do when ISIS fighters become the refugees.
Being a demon one day and an innocent refugee in need of rescue the next is nearly impossible. I say that despite good and evil being largely a matter of perspective. The relationship between a church or society with accepted values and a suspicious cult is symmetrical too. But that does not make unconditional admission a better idea. Good mujahid, nice mujahid, we are glad you fled our bombers to come here. No need to leave your values and goals at the door; we will even give you a knife for your holy war if you would like to stab the person welcoming you... Because, you know, if the bombing becomes a problem, they will flee too. If another, hostile Islamic militia pushes them back, they will flee then too. They are neither monsters nor saints. Mostly, people live there too, with human faults, frailties, and qualities. And they can be misled, just like those here who hate either the governing parties or the liberals very intensely. Perhaps both. It is just that there, “Thou shalt not kill” has an asterisk and a fine-print qualification, as it once did here.
The world does not work by giving someone from whom we expect neither adaptation nor respect for local laws the right, under freedom of religion, to stone gay people to death according to Islamic law, while giving the latter the right to stay alive and live happily—and then fulfilling both aims so everyone is happy. No. Most likely the Islamic community will be unhappy, because they were told they did not have to adapt, could live according to their faith, and do what they had to do. A name was even given to this fundamental, universal right: religious freedom. Yet they cannot pass judgment as Islam's teachings prescribe after all. They have been deceived, and the police have taken members of their community away. If, after many such incidents, those left outside radicalize, they were not the idiots or the villains. The person who deceived them was.
Pride marchers may be unhappy too: even if they are not stoned to death, many experience violence in Islam's name and do not know where it will lead. Their safety will be gone too. The smiling politician saying “We love everyone because we are such good Europeans” does not save everyone, but misleads many and sacrifices quite a few people who have no voice at that moment for the sake of power. They also try to persuade themselves and their voters what wonderful people they are, acting on universal values. According to the stereotypes, the immigrant with the strange faith is the cultist. They are the one whose strangeness you would not notice as suspicious; it seems natural. But the person who deceived them this way is committing precisely the kind of deception I can only understand as Nyarlathotep's latest joke. From this point on, it is the refugee who does not know which part of the host society is strange or why. Yet the gay person they are supposed to throw stones at will seem suspicious to them, not the hypocritical liberal politician.